ࡱ> Y bjbjWW&==]6666666JJJJ8J2"888888ACCCCCC$ "pgE688888g66888>6868AJJ66668ArT66A8\ >JJv 3 >=D5@5=F8O: >20O 0<5@8:0=A:0O AB@0B538O 157>?0A=>AB8 8 <8@0 28-29 >:BO1@O 2003 3., 0H8=3B>=, !( 7 2ABC?8B5;L=>3> A;>20 6>=0 >45ABK (John D. Podesta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ichard C. Leone)  @57845=B0 D>=40  (The Century Foundation) =5H=5?>;8B8G5A:89 :C@A =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F88 2K7K205B C <=>38E 0<5@8:0=F52 2?>;=5 >?@0240==>5 15A?>:>9AB2>. K ?>;0305<, GB> >= B@51C5B :>@@5:F88 8 CE>40 >B >4=>AB>@>==8E @5H5=89 8 459AB289, GB> B>;L:> 25@=5B 4>25@85 : 0<5@8:0=A:><C ?@028B5;LAB2C 8 ?>72>;8B 1>;55 MDD5:B82=> ?@>B82>459AB2>20BL C3@>70< =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. #3@>70 B5@@>@87<0 70AB028;0 =0A ?5@5A<>B@5BL =0HC 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:CN 8 2>5==CN AB@0B538N. >2K5 2K7>2K ?@825;8 : :>=A5=ACAC =5 B>;L:> 2=CB@8 0<5@8:0=A:>3> >1I5AB20, => 8 : 548=><C ?>=8<0=8N >?0A=>AB8 2 <564C=0@>4=>< A>>1I5AB25. 4=0:>, 2K1@0==0O 04<8=8AB@0F859 CH0 ?>;8B8:0 >4=>AB>@>==8E 459AB289 8 ?@525=B82=>3> ?@8<5=5=8O A8;K ?@825;0 : 4>2>;L=> ?;0G52=K< @57C;LB0B0<  ?>B5@5 4>25@8O : ?@028B5;LAB2C 2=CB@8 AB@0=K 8 @>ABC 0=B80<5@8:0=87<0 2 <8@5. 5:>B>@K5 AG8B0NB, GB> :@8B8:>20BL ?@028B5;LAB2> 2> 2@5<O 2>9=K  7=0G8B 83@0BL =0 @C:C 2@030< B5G5AB20. K 65 ?>;0305<, GB>, 2>-?5@2KE, A2>1>40 A;>20  >48= 87 >A=>2>?>;030NI8E ?@8=F8?>2 45<>:@0B88, 0, 2>-2B>@KE, - :>=AB@C:B82=0O :@8B8:0 B>;L:> ?><>65B 871560BL A5@L57=KE >H81>: 2 1C4CI5<. K=5H=55 @C:>2>4AB2> ?@>2>48B ?>;8B8:C ?5@<0=5=B=>3> ' 8 >4=>2@5<5==> =5 E>G5B 25AB8 480;>3 A >1I5AB2><. 5B =8G53> =5?0B@8>B8G=>3> 2 B><, GB> >??>78F8O 8 ! B@51CNB >B =53> >B:@KB>AB8 8 ?>4>BG5B=>AB8. 574C<=0O ?>445@6:0 ?>;8B8:8 ?@525=B82=KE 2>9= =5 O2;O5BAO ?@87=0:>< 1>;LH>3> ?0B@8>B87<0. >4>1=K9 ?0B@8>B87< =5 A45;05B =0F8N 1>;55 A8;L=>9, 0 687=L 2 AB@0=5 1>;55 157>?0A=>9. * * * O4 70<5G0=89 A5=0B>@0 %8;0@8 ;8=B>= (Hillary R. Clinton) !53>4=O <K ?5@568205< :@8B8G5A:89 ?5@8>4 =5 B>;L:> 2 8AB>@88 =0H59 AB@0=K, => 8 2 8AB>@88 45<>:@0B8G5A:>9 A8AB5<K 2 F5;><. >?@>A 2 B><, :0: A>>B=>AOBAO ?@>2>73;0H05<K5 =0<8 45<>:@0B8G5A:85 =>@<K 8 ?@8=F8?K A ?@0:B8G5A:8<8 459AB28O<8 !( 2> 2708<>>B=>H5=8OE A >AB0;L=K< <8@><. K=5H=OO 0<5@8:0=A:0O 04<8=8AB@0F8O, ?> ACB8, ?5@5G5@:=C;0 2A5 107>2K5 ?@028;0 45<>:@0B8G5A:>3> ?>2545=8O =0 <564C=0@>4=>9 0@5=5. >5==0O A8;0 AB0;0 =5 ?>A;54=8< 0@3C<5=B><, 0, =0?@>B82, ?5@2>AB5?5==K< A@54AB2>< >B@065=8O 2>7<>6=KE C3@>7 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 !(.  21 25:5 2>7<>6=>ABL ?@525=B82=KE A8;>2KE 459AB289 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0-<;04H53> 2>725;0 2 3;02=K9 ?>ABC;0B 0<5@8:0=A:>9 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388, B5< A0<K< C70:>=82 2545=85 2>9=K =0 >?5@565=85. K B25@48< > =5C:>A=8B5;L=>< A>1;N45=88 70:>=>2, 8 2 B> 65 2@5<O =5 A>1;N405< 8 4065 =0@CH05< <564C=0@>4=K5 A>3;0H5=8O, 1C4L B> 8>BA:>5 A>3;0H5=85 8;8 >3>2>@ > ?>2A5<5AB=>< 70?@5B5 =0 8A?KB0=8O. "0:>9 ?>4E>4 !( : ?>=8<0=8N 48:B0BC@K 70:>=0 2>A?@8=8<05BAO <8@>2K< A>>1I5AB2>< :0: ?>;8B8:0 42>9=KE AB0=40@B>2, CG8BK20NI0O ;8HL 8=B5@5AK 0H8=3B>=0. 0H0 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:0O AB@0B538O 2A5 40;LH5 >BE>48B >B ?@8=F8?>2 <564C=0@>4=>3> A>B@C4=8G5AB20 2 AB>@>=C 03@5AA82=>3> C=8;0B5@0;87<0, :>B>@K9 A?>A>15= ;8HL 5I5 1>;LH5 >BB>;:=CBL =0H8E A>N7=8:>2 8 ?>4=OBL =>2CN 2>;=C 0=B80<5@8:0=87<0 C =0H8E =54@C3>2. A;8 3;02=>9 F5;LN <K 70O2;O5< ?@>42865=85 45<>:@0B88 2 3;>10;L=>< <0AHB015, B> <K 4>;6=K =0G0BL A =5C:>A=8B5;L=>3> A>1;N45=8O 45<>:@0B8G5A:8E ?@8=F8?>2 =0H8<8 ;845@0<8, :0: C A51O 4><0, B0: 8 =0 <564C=0@>4=>9 0@5=5.  ?5@2CN >G5@54L, 8<55BAO 2 284C >B:@KB>ABL 8 ?@>7@0G=>ABL 2;0AB8, 0 B0:65 55 ?>4>BG5B=>ABL >1I5AB2C 2> 2A5E :@8B8G5A:8 206=KE @5H5=8OE. 5A><=5==>, 8 2 45<>:@0B8G5A:>< >1I5AB25 ACI5AB2CNB 3>AC40@AB25==K5 A5:@5BK, :>B>@K5 A;54C5B >E@0=OBL. > G@57<5@=0O A5:@5B=>ABL =5 <>65B 1KBL >?@0240=0 B0<, 345 >=0 8A?>;L7C5BAO 2 :0:8E-B> ?>;8B8G5A:8E F5;OE ?@02OI59 M;8BK, 0 =5 4;O >15A?5G5=8O =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. =0G5 <K >BE>48< >B >4=>3> 87 3;02=KE AB>;?>2 45<>:@0B88  ?@020 >1I5AB20 =0 8=D>@<0F8N. A>1CN 0:BC0;L=>ABL 2>?@>A >1 8=D>@<8@>20==>AB8 >1I5AB20 ?@8>1@5; ?>A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O 8 =0G0;0 2>9=K A B5@@>@87<><. = 5I5 1>;LH5 >1>AB@8;AO 2 A2O78 A> A?>@0<8 2>:@C3 4>AB>25@=>AB8 @072548=D>@<0F88 ?> @0:C. ("> ;8 MB> ?@>20; @07254:8, B> ;8 ?>;8B8:8 55 ?@>AB> ?>4AB028;8). <5@8:0=A:>5 >1I5AB2> 4>;6=> 1KBL C25@5=>, GB> ?@028B5;LAB2> =8G53> >B =53> =5 A:@K205B, 0 254L 8<5==> B0:>5 >ICI5=85 ?@5>1;0405B 2 >B=>H5=88 <>B820F88 =5>1E>48<>AB8 2>9=K 2 @0:5. @C38< ?@8<5@><, ?>:07K20NI8<, GB> A =0H8<8 45<>:@0B8G5A:8<8 8=AB8BCB0<8 =5 2A5 2 ?>@O4:5, O2;O5BAO @0AA;54>20=85 :><8AA859 >=3@5AA0 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O. >@078B5;L=>, => 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 >B:070;0AL ?@54>AB028BL 59 2 ?>;=>< >1J5<5 70B@51>20==K5 :>=3@5AA<5=0<8 4>:C<5=BK, 8 ?@54A540B5;L :><8AA88, 1K2H89 3C15@=0B>@ HB0B0 LN-65@A8 8= 4065 2K=C645= 1K; ?@83@>78BL ?@028B5;LAB25==K< G8=>2=8:0< AC451=K< ?@5A;54>20=85<. @C38< 2>?8NI8< D0:B>< O2;O5BAO 7025A0 A5:@5B=>AB8 A> AB>@>=K 28F5-?@57845=B0 8:0 '59=8 2 >B=>H5=88 ?@>2>48<>9 =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F859 M=5@35B8G5A:>9 ?>;8B8:8. >72@0I0OAL : @0:C, E>G5BAO >B<5B8BL >3@><=>5 =5A>>B25BAB285 <564C B5<, GB> <K 2848< =0 M:@0=0E B5;5287>@>2 8 B5<, GB> =0< A>>1I0NB ?@028B5;LAB25==K5 G8=>2=8:8 2> 3;025 A ?@57845=B><. <5==> ?>B><C, GB> <K =5 8<55< ?@020 ?@>83@0BL 2 @0:5, 0<5@8:0=A:89 =0@>4 8<55B ?@02> 7=0BL 2AN ?@024C, :0:>9 1K 3>@L:>9 >=8 =8 1K;0. !;54C5B ?@>25AB8 ?>;=><0AHB01=K9 0C48B 45OB5;L=>AB8 0<5@8:0=A:8E >@30=870F89 8 :><?0=89, @01>B0NI8E 2 @0:5, 4;O B>3>, GB>1K =0;>3>?;0B5;LI8:8 7=0;8, :C40 B@0BOBAO <8;;80@4K 4>;;0@>2, 8 GB>1K =5 1K;> =8:0:8E ?>4>7@5=89, GB> :B>-B> =068205BAO =0 2>9=5. ('B> A0<> ?> A515 01A>;NB=> 0<>@0;L=> 2 45<>:@0B8G5A:>< >1I5AB25). !;54C5B ?@87=0BL, GB> 2 @0:5 845B =0AB>OI0O ?0@B870=A:0O 2>9=0, 0 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 =8:0: =5 E>G5B 84B8 =0 >B:@KBK9 480;>3 A >??>78F859 8 >1I5AB2><.  :>=F5 :>=F>2, >=3@5AA =5 ?@>AB> >@30=870F8O, 345 =5 3;O4O 2878@CNB 2A5 ?>;8B8G5A:85 @5H5=8O 8A?>;=8B5;L=>9 2;0AB8. B:07K20OAL >B >B:@KB>AB8 8 A>B@C4=8G5AB20, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 @8A:C5B @0AB5@OBL >AB0B:8 4>25@8O A> AB>@>=K 0<5@8:0=A:>3> =0@>40 8 <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20.  A2>59 8AB>@88 <5@8:0 AB0;:820;0AL A> <=>38<8 >?0A=>ABO<8 8 C3@>70<8 (B>@0O <8@>20O 2>9=0, E>;>4=0O 2>9=0), 8 2A5340 <K =0E>48;8 A>>B25BAB2CNICN AB@0B538N 157>?0A=>AB8, ?@82>4OICN : CA?5EC. @8 MB>< <K =0E>48;8 >?>@C 2 4>25@88 =0H8< 459AB28O< A> AB>@>=K 0<5@8:0=A:>3> =0@>40 8 <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20, :>B>@>5 >A=>2K20;>AL =0 4>25@88 : =0H5<C ?@028B5;LAB2C 8 ?>=8<0=88 <>B820F88 53> 459AB289. K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O >?@><5BG82> @0AB@0G8205B =0HC :07=C 8 :@548B 4>25@8O, =0:>?;5==K5 ?@54K4CI8<8 ?@028B5;LAB20<8, GB> 2?>;=5 <>65B >15@=CBLAO ?>B5@59 ;848@CNI53> ?>;>65=8O 2 <8@5. * * * 7 2KABC?;5=89 =0 A5:F88 ! 1 0E>48BAO ;8 A53>4=O <5@8:0 2 1>;LH59 157>?0A=>AB8? 0F8>=0;L=0O 157>?0A=>ABL 8 4>:B@8=0 CH0. !0<CM;L 5@35@ (Samuel R.Berger)  1K2H89 A>25B=8: ?> =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 ?@8 ?@57845=B5 ;8=B>=5, =K=5H=89 @C:>2>48B5;L :>=A0;B8=3>2>9 D8@<K Stonebridge International. >:B@8=0 CH0 :>@5==K< >1@07>< 87<5=8;0 E0@0:B5@ 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 !(. =0 AD>@<8@>20;0AL ?>4 2;8O=85< B@038G5A:8E A>1KB89 11 A5=BO1@O, :>340 <5@8:5 ?@8H;>AL @0AAB0BLAO A 8;;N7859 A2>59 =5CO728<>AB8.  :B> 1K =8 1K; =0 <5AB5 CH0, 5<C ?@8H;>AL 1K @5H0BL ?@>1;5<K MB>9 @048:0;L=> 87<5=82H59AO @50;L=>AB8: >1J5:B82=> ;02=K< ?@8>@8B5B>< =>2>9 AB@0B5388 AB0;0 1>@L10 A B5@@>@87<><. B>@0O 7040G0, =0 2K?>;=5=85 :>B>@>9 =0F5;5=0 4>:B@8=0 CH0, 2?>;=5 ;>38G5A:8 70:;NG05BAO 2 =54>?CI5=88 ?>?040=8O # 2 @C:8 B5@@>@8AB>2 8 3>AC40@AB2-873>52. >O2;5=85 =0 <8@>2>9 0@5=5 B0:>3> D0:B>@0 :0: =53>AC40@AB25==K9 B5@@>@87<, 70AB028;> 87<5=8BL :;0AA8G5A:CN <>45;L A45@6820=8O, CA?5H=> DC=:F8>=8@>202HCN 2 :0G5AB25 AB@0B5388 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 =0 ?@>BO65=88 42CE AB>;5B89. "5@@>@8AB>2-A0<>C189F =5 A45@60BL C3@>7>9 >B25B=>3> O45@=>3> C40@0. 4=0:> ?@57845=B CH ?>H5; 5I5 40;LH5, @0A?@>AB@0=82 845N 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<>< =0 3>AC40@AB20, 2E>4OI85 2 B0: =07K205<CN >AL 7;0 (@0:, !525@=0O >@5O, @0=). @8 MB>< @5GL H;0 > ?@525=B82=>< 8A?>;L7>20=88 2>5==>9 A8;K, 5A;8 C3@>70 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 =5<8=C5<0. !>3;0A=> 4>:B@8=K CH0, 2A5< ?@>1;5<=K< 3>AC40@AB20< 4>;65= 1KBL ?@54JO2;5= C;LB8<0BC<  ;81> >B:070BLAO >B ?>?KB>: A>740BL 8;8 70?>;CG8BL #, ;81> >6840BL ?@525=B82=KE A8;>2KE 459AB289 A> AB>@>=K !(. @0:B8G5A:0O @50;870F8O 4>:B@8=K CH0, =0?@8<5@ 2 A;CG05 A !525@=>9 >@559, ?@825;0 ;8HL : CA8;5=8N :>=D@>=B0F88, 0 =8:0: =5 : ;8:2840F88 C3@>7K. # AB>@>==8:>2 4>:B@8=K CH0 ACI5AB2CNB 8 4@C385 8458, A?>A>1=K5 2K720BL 1>;LH85 A><=5=8O. 0?@8<5@, >=8 ?>;030NB, GB> F5;520O :>0;8F8O O2;O5BAO 1>;55 ?>;57=K< 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8< 8=AB@C<5=B><, G5< CAB>9G82K9 4>;3>A@>G=K9 A>N7. > 8E <=5=8N, E>BO <564C=0@>4=0O ?>445@6:0 8 65;0B5;L=0, =>, 2 :@09=5< A;CG05, <>6=> >1>9B8AL 8 157 =55. @8 MB>< 3;02=K< 8=AB@C<5=B>< ?@>42865=8O =0F8>=0;L=KE 8=B5@5A>2 2 <8@5 ?@87=05BAO 2>5==0O A8;0, 0 =5 48?;><0B8O 8 4@C385 2>7<>6=>AB8 B0: =07K205<>9 <O3:>9 A8;K. !53>4=OH=OO =5@04>AB=0O A8BC0F8O 2 @0:5 - =5 @57C;LB0B >H81>G=KE @5H5=89, 0 A;54AB285 @50;870F88 4>:B@8=K CH0 =0 ?@0:B8:5. '5< @0=LH5 <K ?>9<5<, GB> 2 @0:5 <5@8:0 8<55B 45;> A :;0AA8G5A:8< ?@>O2;5=85< ?0@B870=A:>9 2>9=K, B5< ;CGH5 4;O =0A.  >B B>3>, GB> <K ?>AB@>8< =>2K5 1>;L=8FK 8 <5G5B8, A>?@>B82;5=85 =5 ?@5:@0B8BAO. I5 @O4 2>?@>A>2 : AB>@>==8:0< 4>:B@8=K CH0. 0: >=8 A>18@0NBAO 459AB2>20BL 2 >B=>H5=88 AB@0=, :>B>@K5 2A5 65 =0<5@5=K AB0BL G;5=0<8 O45@=>3> :;C10? 'B> >=8 ?@54?@8<CB, 5A;8 !525@=0O >@5O ?@>4>;68B A>74020BL O45@=>5 >@C685? 06=> ;8 4;O <5@8:8 C2065=85 A> AB>@>=K <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20 8 GB> >=8 ?>=8<0NB ?>4 A;>2>< C2060BL? 0:8< >1@07>< !( A>18@0NBAO AK3@0BL @>;L <8@>2>3> ;845@0? ><8=8@>20=85, C=8;0B5@0;87< 8 ?@525=B82=K5 2>9=K 2> 04;5@ (Ivo Daadler)  M:A?5@B ?> 2>?@>A0< <564C=0@>4=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 87 8=AB8BCB0 Brookings, 02B>@ :=838 52>;NF8O CH0 2> 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:5 (Bush Revolution in Foreign Policy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lyde Prestowitz)  ?@57845=B =AB8BCB0 M:>=><8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 (Economic Strategy Institute), 02B>@ :=838 >AC40@AB2>-873>9 (Rogne Nation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usan Rice)  M:A?5@B ?> ?@>1;5<0< 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:8 8=AB8BCB0 Brookings, @01>B0;0 2 !>25B5 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 2 04<8=8AB@0F88 ;8=B>=0 K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O 459AB2C5B B0:, 1C4B> <K 548=AB25==0O AB@0=0 2 <8@5, C :>B>@>9 5ABL =0F8>=0;L=K5 8=B5@5AK. K =0@CH05< <563>AC40@AB25==K5 A>3;0H5=8O 8 ?>4@K205< 02B>@8B5B <564C=0@>4=KE >@30=870F89, 0 A2>59 2KA>:><5@=>9 ?>;8B8:>9 >4=>AB>@>==8E 459AB289 >BB>;:=C;8 >B A51O 1>;LHCN G0ABL <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20. =K<8 A;>20<8, 2 =0A 284OB 3535<>=0-M3>8AB0, 0 =5 =0F8N-;845@0, 459AB2CNICN 2> 1;03> 2A53> <8@0. 5>1E>48<> @50;L=> ?>25@=CBLAO ;8F>< : ?@>1;5<0< 8 G0O=8O< 8=KE =0@>4>2 8 =0F89. C6=> =0CG8BLAO ?@8A;CH820BLAO 8 AB0@0BLAO ?>=OBL, GB> 701>B8B ;N459 70 ?@545;0<8 !(. 5;L7O @5H8BL ?@>1;5<C =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, :>340 4>1@0O ?>;>28=0 =0A5;5=8O 75<=>3> H0@0 6825B <5=LH5, G5< =0 2 $ 2 45=L.  A2O78 A 2KH5A:070==K< E>G5BAO ?>?>4@>1=55 >AB0=>28BLAO =0 ?@>1;5<5 @5018;8B0F88 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2, :>B>@K5 A0<8 ?> A515 O2;ONBAO C3@>7>9 =5 B>;L:> 4;O ?@>6820NI8E B0< ;N459, => 8 ?@54AB02;ONB A5@L57=K9 2K7>2 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 !(. >4 3>AC40@AB20<8-=5C40G=8:0<8 8;8 3>AC40@AB20<8, ?>B5@?52H8<8 D80A:>, <K ?>4@07C<5205< AB@0=K, 345, 2 A8;C @07;8G=KE ?@8G8= (2>>@C65==K9 :>=D;8:B, >BACBAB285 8;8 =5MDD5:B82=>ABL 3>AC40@AB25==KE 8=AB8BCB>2), F5=B@0;L=0O 2;0ABL =5 :>=B@>;8@C5B >B45;L=K5 @538>=K 8 =5 >15A?5G8205B 687=545OB5;L=>ABL =0A5;5=8O. @8<5@0<8 <>3CB A;C68BL D30=8AB0=, !><0;8, 815@8O, !C40=, 0:8AB0= 8 @0:. 0G0ABCN 8<5==> 3>AC40@AB20-=5C40G=8:8 O2;ONBAO ?@81568I5< 8 >?>@=>9 107>9 4;O 2AO:>3> @>40 B5@@>@8AB>2 8 >@30=87>20==>9 ?@5ABC?=>AB8. A>7=020O ?@>1;5<C, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 =5 2K@01>B0;0 =8:0:>9 2=OB=>9 AB@0B5388 459AB289 2 >B=>H5=88 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2. 0< A@>G=> =C6=0 AB@0B538O, A>G5B0NI0O 2 A515 ?@525=B82=K5 459AB28O, =0?@02;5==K5 =0 @07@5H5=85 2=CB@5==53> :>=D;8:B0 8 45B0;L=K9 ?;0= 3>AC40@AB25==>3> 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O 8 AB@>8B5;LAB20. %>BO 8 =5B >1I53> @5H5=8O 4;O 2A5E A;CG052, => 2K@01>B:0 107>2KE M;5<5=B>2 AB@0B5388 =5>1E>48<0. @0:B8:0 ?>:070;0, GB> =0< =5>1E>48<> A5@L57=> ?>4=OBL MDD5:B82=>ABL 8 =0456=>ABL @07254A;C61, 70=8<0NI8EAO ?@>1;5<0B8:>9 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2 8 A2O70==KE A =8<8 C3@>7 <564C=0@>4=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. !;54C5B 0:B82=55 ?><>30BL @5018;8B0F88 B0:8E AB@0= A ?><>ILN 8=25AB8F89, B>@3>2KE ?@5D5@5=F89 8 @5AB@C:BC@870F88 4>;3>2.  A;CG05 CA?5H=>3> @0728B8O A>1KB89, <>6=> 1C45B 25AB8 @5GL 8 > A>3;0A>20=88 CA8;89 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N <564C=0@>4=><C B5@@>@87<C, 8<5O 2 284C C=8GB>65=85 53> 107 =0 B5@@8B>@88 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2. C6=K =5 M?87>48G5A:85 3C<0=8B0@=K5 >?5@0F88, 0 ?@>4C<0==0O AB@0B538O @5018;8B0F88 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2, CA?5H=0O @50;870F8O :>B>@>9 O28BAO 206=K< 2:;04>< 2 45;> C:@5?;5=8O =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 !(. !> 2@5<5=5< 2>7<>6=> 8 ?>;CG5=85 M:>=><8G5A:8E 482845=4>2, B0: :0: @O4 MB8E AB@0= >1;0405B 1>;LH8<8 70?0A0<8 C3;52>4>@>4=KE 8 <8=5@0;L=KE @5AC@A>2.  70:;NG5=85 E>GC A:070BL, GB>, =5A<>B@O =0 2A5 2K7>2K A>2@5<5==>AB8, <5@8:0 A?>A>1=0 83@0BL @>;L =0F88-;845@0, => B>;L:> 2 B>< A;CG05, 5A;8 1C45B >?8@0BLAO =0 ?><>IL A>N7=8:>2 8 4@C759 8 @50;L=> 709<5BAO @07@5H5=85< ?@>1;5< >AB0;L=>3> <8@0. =5H=85 8 2=CB@5==85 ?@8>@8B5BK 2 M?>EC 0=B80<5@8:0=87<0 >15@B C18= (Robert Rubin)  @C:>2>48B5;L >4=>3> 87 10=:>2 2 LN->@:5, 1K2H89 A>25B=8: ?> M:>=><8G5A:8< 2>?@>A0< ?@8 ?@57845=B5 ;8=B>=5 > <>5<C <=5=8N, =K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O ?@>2>48B >H81>G=CN D8A:0;L=CN ?>;8B8:C, :>B>@0O <>65B ?@52@0B8BLAO 2 C3@>7C M:>=><8G5A:><C 1;03>A>AB>O=8N AB@0=K. N465B=K9 :><8B5B >=3@5AA0 70?;0=8@>20; =0 45AOB8;5B=89 ?5@8>4 ?@>D8F8B 1N465B0 2 @07<5@5 5,6 B@8;;8>=0 4>;;0@>2. 4=0:>, A>3;0A=> =5402=8< @0AG5B0< 8725AB=>9 D8=0=A>2>-0=0;8B8G5A:>9 D8@<K Goldman Sachs & Company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ichard Holbrooke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oseph C.Wilson)  1K2H89 :0@L5@=K9 48?;><0, =K=5 48@5:B>@ :>=A0;B8=3>2>9 D8@<K J.C.Wilson International Ventures > <>5<C <=5=8N, ACI5AB2>20;> <=>3> A?>A>1>2 2>7459AB2>20BL =0 @568< !0440<0 %CA59=0 A ?><>ILN B0: =07K205<>9 <O3:>9 A8;K, => 04<8=8AB@0F8O, 2848<>, =5 872;5:;0 =8:0:8E C@>:>2 87 >?KB0 >A=88 8 D30=8AB0=0, 8 ?>H;0 =0?@>;><, 2K1@02 2>5==>5 2B>@65=85 8 >::C?0F8N @0:0. > 2 D30=8AB0=5 <K @5H0;8 7040GC, :>B>@0O =0E>48;0 ?>=8<0=85 8 ?>445@6:C A> AB>@>=K <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20. %>BO 8 745AL, O=:8 ?@8H;8, ?>AB@5;O;8, ?>:@CH8;8, 0 70B5< 2720;8;8 =5;53:>5 45;> 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O AB@0=K =0 ?;5G8 B5E 65 52@>?59F52. >>1I5 A@548 =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2 2 ?@57845=BA:>< >:@C65=88 ACI5AB2C5B 420 B8?0 ;N459. 4=8 B>;L:> 8 2KA<0B@820NB =>2CN C3@>7C, GB>1K BCB 65 C40@8BL ?> =59 :C;0:><.  4@C385 =>AB0;L38@CNB ?> 2@5<5=0< @8B0=A:>9 8<?5@88, :>B>@K5 =5?;>E> 1K;> 1K 2>AA>740BL 2 D30=8AB0=5 8 @0:5. 5 7@O 65 ?@57845=B CH 2A5@L57 @0AAC6405B >1 MB8E AB@0=0E :0: > 1C4CI8E <0O:0E 45<>:@0B88. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO ?@>3@0<<K 459AB289 ?> AB018;870F88 ?>;>65=8O 2 @0:5 8 53> 2>AAB0=>2;5=8N, B>, ?5@2>-=0?5@2>, =5>1E>48<> A@>G=>5 8 H8@>:>5 <564C=0@>4=>5 CG0AB85 2 MB>< ?@>F5AA5. @8 MB>< 2>2;5G5==>ABL <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20 =5 4>;6=0 ?@>E>48BL B>;L:> 2 @0<:0E , :>B>@CN <=>385 8@0:FK 2>A?@8=8<0NB :0: 035=B0 0?040, 70AB0282H53> 8E 68BL 2 BO65;>< @568<5 M:>=><8G5A:8E A0=:F89. !;54C5B CA:>@8BL ?@>F5AA ?5@540G8 2A5E ?>;=><>G89 8 >B25BAB25==>AB8 70:>==> 871@0==><C 8@0:A:><C ?@028B5;LAB2C. K 4>;6=K ?@8;>68BL <0:A8<C< CA8;89 4;O B>3>, GB>1K ?@>ABK5 8@0:FK AB0;8 AG8B0BL 0<5@8:0=F52 =5 >::C?0=B0<8, 0 ?><>I=8:0<8 2 ?>AB@>5=88 1>;55 A25B;>3> 8 ?@>F25B0NI53> 1C4CI53> @0:0. 'B> :0A05BAO A>1AB25==> 0@<88, B> 55 3;02=>9 7040G59 O2;O5BAO :0: >15A?5G5=85 >1I59 157>?0A=>AB8 2 AB@0=5, B0: 8 >15A?5G5=85 157>?0A=>AB8 8 687=5==> 206=KE ?>B@51=>AB59 3@0640=A:>3> =0A5;5=8O. >2>@O 65 >1 CG0AB88 <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20, O 8<5N 2 284C =5 B>;L:> ?>AK;:C 2>8=A:8E :>=B8=35=B>2, => 8 D8=0=A>2>-M:>=><8G5A:CN 45OB5;L=>ABL =0 B5@@8B>@88 @0:0. @0240, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 45<>=AB@8@C5B A>2A5< 8=>9 ?>4E>4, 83=>@8@CO 2>7<>6=>ABL ?@82;5G5=8O 187=5A0 87 4@C38E AB@0=. >:0 65 >G5284=>, GB> 2 A2>8E CA8;8OE ?> 2>AAB0=>2;5=8N @0:0 =K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O B5@?8B ?>;=>5 D80A:>. 0: 2K:>@G520BL B5@@>@87< 65AA8:0 (B5@= (Jessica Stern)  @01>B0;0 2 0??0@0B5 A>25B=8:>2 ?> =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 ?@8 ?@57845=B5 ;8=B>=5 8 2 !>25B5 ?> <564C=0@>4=K< >B=>H5=8O<, 02B>@ :=838 "5@@>@ 2> 8<O >30 (Terror in the name of God) 59AB28B5;L=>, 2 @0:5 845B 2>9=0, => =5 A A>;40B0<8 2@065A:>3> 3>AC40@AB20, 0 A 8459=K<8 ?@>B82=8:0<8, :>B>@K5 AG8B0NB, GB> <5@8:0 65AB>:> C=8GB>605B <CAC;L<0=. #65 =0:0=C=5 2B>@65=8O 2 @0: 2 8A;0<A:>< <8@5 =01;N40;AO @57:89 2A?;5A: 0=B80<5@8:0=A:8E =0AB@>5=89, GB> ?>72>;8;> ;L 0945 @5:@CB8@>20BL <=>3> =>2KE 2>8=>2 468E040.  8E G8A;5 1>;LH>5 :>;8G5AB2> >G5=L <>;>4KE ;N459 8 65=I8=. "5@@>@8ABK =0CG8;8AL 8A?>;L7>20BL 2 A2>8E F5;OE 2A5 ?@58<CI5AB20 ?@>F5AA0 3;>10;870F88: >B:@KB>ABL 3@0=8F, 2>7<>6=>ABL A2>1>4=> ?5@542830BLAO ?> <8@C, ;53:>ABL B@0=A=0F8>=0;L=>3> ?5@5<5I5=8O 45=53 8 F5==>AB59, =B5@=5B, =0:>=5F.  8A;0<A:8E AB@0=0E >=8 CA?5H=> M:A?;C0B8@CNB =54>2>;LAB2> :>@@C<?8@>20==K<8 02B>:@0B8G5A:8<8 @568<0<8, :>B>@K5 O:>1K ?>445@6820NBAO <5@8:>9. <5==> A;01K5 3>AC40@AB20 O2;ONBAO =081>;55 1;03>?@8OB=>9 A@54>9 4;O 70@>645=8O 8 @0728B8O B5@@>@87<0. 0G0ABCN B0<, 345 3>AC40@AB2> ?;>E> 2K?>;=O5B 8;8 A>2A5< =5 2K?>;=O5B A2>8 >1O70==>AB8 ?5@54 =0A5;5=85<, 53> DC=:F88, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 A>F80;L=K5, 15@CB =0 A51O <564C=0@>4=K5 B5@@>@8AB8G5A:85 >@30=870F88. =8 ?@54>AB02;ONB ;N4O< <548F8=A:85 CA;C38 8 >1@07>20=85 (>G5=L G0AB> G5@57 @07;8G=K5 1;03>B2>@8B5;L=K5 D>@4K 8 >@30=870F88), 8A?>42>;L 2K@0I820O 87 =8E =>2KE 70I8B=8:>2 25@K. &5;0O A5BL 4CE>2=KE A5<8=0@89 (<54@5A5) 2 =488, 0:8AB0=5, 0=3;045H 8 =4>=5788, A>740==KE =0 45=L38 1;03>B2>@8B5;L=KE D>=4>2 87 !0C4>2A:>9 @0288, D0:B8G5A:8 ?@52@0B8;8AL 2 H:>;K ?> ?>43>B>2:5 2>8=>2 468E040. 5;L7O A1@0AK20BL A> AG5B>2 8 ?@>1;5<C =8I5BK. 54=K5 8 C=865==K5 G0I5 AB0=>2OBAO >1J5:B>< 25@1>2:8 2 B5@@>@8AB8G5A:85 >@30=870F88. -<8AA0@K <564C=0@>4=>3> B5@@>@87<0 83@0NB =0 GC2AB20E A>F80;L=> C=865==>9 8 =5A?>A>1=>9 : A0<>@50;870F88 ;8G=>AB8. =8 A>1;07=ONB 2>7<>6=>ABLN :>;;5:B82=>9 @50;870F88 ?@8 2K?>;=5=88 2KA>:>9 1>65AB25==>9 <8AA88. 5 7@O 0?>;>35B 8A;0<A:>3> M:AB@5<87<0 020E5@8 2 A2>8E ?8A0=8OE ?>AB>O==> B25@48B >1 C=865=88 8 >1@5B5=88 A0<>C2065=8O G5@57 CG0AB85 2 468E045. 68E04  A2OI5==0O 2>9=0 2A5E ?@02>25@=KE <CAC;L<0=. #<5AB=> 70<5B8BL, GB> @0: 8 53> AB>;8F0 03404 >G5=L <=>3> 7=0G0B 2 8AB>@88 A;0<0, ?>MB><C 0<5@8:0=A:0O >::C?0F8O @0AA<0B@8205BAO :0: 65AB>:>5 C=865=85 8 >A:>@1;5=85 2A53> <CAC;L<0=A:>3> <8@0. > <=5=8N >4=>3> M:A?5@B0 87 !0C4>2A:>9 @0288, 0<5@8:0=A:>5 2B>@65=85 8 >::C?0F8O @0:0  ?@>AB> ?>40@>: 5= 045=C 8 53> >@30=870F88. N1>9 B5@@>@8AB =0G8=05B A 8458, A 25@K 2 1>65AB25==CN ?@02>BC A2>59 <8AA88, :>B>@K5 A> 2@5<5=5< ?@52@0I0NBAO 2 >1@07 687=8. ABC?0O 2 @O4K >@30=870F88 B8?0 ;L 094K, G5;>25: ?>AB5?5==> AB0=>28BAO ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K< B5@@>@8AB><, 4;O :>B>@>3> B0:0O 45OB5;L=>ABL 8 5ABL A0<0 687=L. G5@0 A2>59 7040G59 ;L 0940 AG8B0;0 =5>1E>48<>ABL 2K3=0BL 0<5@8:0=F52 A> A2OB>9 75<;8 !0C4>2A:>9 @0288. !53>4=O >=8 AB0@0NBAO A45;0BL MB> 2 @0:5. "@C4=> A:070BL, :0:CN F5;L >=8 ?>AB02OB ?5@54 A>1>9 702B@0, <>65B 1KBL 1>@L1C A 3;>10;870F859. K =5 <>65< 70<5=8BL 8< <>738, => <K 2?>;=5 A?>A>1=K A>:@0I0BL 8E ?8B0B5;L=CN A@54C, 87 :>B>@>9 >=8 @5:@CB8@CNB =>2KE 2>8=>2 468E040. 5>1E>48<> A18BL 2>;=C 0=B80<5@8:0=87<0 2 8A;0<A:>< <8@5 8 2 3>AC40@AB20E-=5C40G=8:0E.  4;O MB>3> B@51C5BAO =5 ?5@8>48G5A:8 >:07K205<0O 3C<0=8B0@=0O ?><>IL, 0 4>;3>A@>G=0O AB@0B538O ?>445@6:8 8 @0728B8O MB8E AB@0=, ?>AB>O==0O 1>@L10 A <8@>2>9 154=>ABLN. 708<>459AB285 A 3>AC40@AB20<8-=5C40G=8:0<8 4>;6=> AB0BL >4=8< 87 M;5<5=B>2 =0H59 AB@0B5388 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. 8@=0O AB@0B538O $;8=B 525@5B (Flint Leverett)  M:A?5@B 87 8=AB8BCB0 Brookings, @01>B0; 2 !>25B5 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 ?@8 04<8=8AB@0F8OE ;8=B>=0 8 CH0-<;04H53>  >BACBAB285 C =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F88 OA=>9 8 ?>A;54>20B5;L=>9 @538>=0;L=>9 AB@0B5388, E>B5;>AL 1K A>A@54>B>G8BL 2=8<0=85 =0 ?@>1;5<5 3>AC40@AB2, A?>=A8@CNI8E B5@@>@87< 8 =0 0@01>-87@08;LA:>< :>=D;8:B5.  >B=>H5=88 B0:8E 3>AC40@AB2 :0: !8@8O 8 @0= A;54C5B ?@>2>48BL @07C<=CN 8 A10;0=A8@>20==CN ?>;8B8:C :=CB0 8 ?@O=8:0. <5@8:0 4>;6=0 40BL OA=> ?>=OBL, GB> 8E <>65B 640BL 2 B>< A;CG05, 5A;8 >=8 87<5=OB A2>5 ?>2545=85 8, GB>, 5A;8 >=8 1C4CB ?@>4>;60BL ?>445@6820BL B5@@>@87< 8 AB@5<8BLAO : >1;040=8N #.  A>60;5=8N, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 701C:A>20;0 2 @0:5 8 =5 70=8<05BAO @50;L=>9 48?;><0B859 2 >B=>H5=88 4@C38E ?@>1;5<=KE AB@0=. 5@2>9 D07>9 2 4>;3>A@>G=>9 1>@L15 A B5@@>@87<>< 1K; D30=8AB0=, 345 <K 4>18;8AL >?@545;5==>3> CA?5E0, 70@CG82H8AL ?>445@6:>9 <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20 8 =0H8E A>N7=8:>2. >, =5 70:>=G82 A 2>AAB0=>2;5=85< 3>AC40@AB20 745AL, <5@8:0 2 >4=>AB>@>==5< ?>@O4:5 ?@8ABC?8;0 : A<5=5 @568<0 A ?><>ILN 2>5==>9 A8;K 2 @0:5.  8B>35 <K 702O7;8 2 >158E AB@0=0E, :>B>@K5 ?> ?;0=C =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F88 4>;6=K 1K;8 ?@52@0B8BLAO 2 <0O:8 45<>:@0B88 8 >1@075F 4;O ?>4@060=8O. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO ?0;5AB8=>-87@08;LA:>3> :>=D;8:B0, B> 2 MB>< 2>?@>A5 !( 4>;6=K 157 2AO:8E M:82>:>2 8 42CA<KA;5==>AB59 ?>A;54>20B5;L=> ?@>2>48BL 2 687=L ;8=8N =0 A>740=85 42CE AC25@5==KE 3>AC40@AB2, GB> O2;O5BAO 548=AB25==K< 2KE>4>< 87 <=>3>;5B=53> :@>202>3> :>=D;8:B0. !>B@C4=8G5AB2> A A>N7=8:0<8 8 <564C=0@>4=K<8 >@30=870F8O<8 5=5@0;-<09>@ 2 >BAB02:5 8;LO< MH (William Nash) A:>@5=5=85 B5@@>@87<0  MB> A;>6=59H0O 7040G0, :>B>@0O ?>B@51C5B <=>3>;5B=8E CA8;89 2A53> <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20.  >A=88 <K 4>18;8AL CA?5E0 8<5==> ?>B><C, GB> 459AB2>20;8 2 @0<:0E <=>3>AB>@>==59 :>0;8F88. 525@>OB=59H0O 2 ?@>H;>< A8BC0F8O: @07405BAO B5;5D>==K9 72>=>:, 8 O A;KHC 2 B@C1:5 3>;>A :><0=48@0 @>AA89A:8E 45A0=B=8:>2, :>B>@K9 3>2>@8B: >1@>5 CB@>, 35=5@0;! 4C 20H8E 40;L=59H8E ?@8:07>2. !<5N 7025@8BL, @>AA89A:89 :>=B8=35=B 2=5A >3@><=K9 2:;04 2 45;> CAB0=>2;5=8O <8@0 8 2 >A=88, 8 2 >A>25. ">;L:> 2 @0<:0E <564C=0@>4=KE :>0;8F89 8 4>;3>2@5<5==KE A>N7>2 <>6=> CA?5H=> 30A8BL 2>>@C65==K5 :>=D;8:BK 8 2>AAB0=02;820BL 3>AC40@AB20. 7 2KABC?;5=89 =0 A5:F88 ! 3 ?0A=K9 2K7>2: :0: >AB0=>28BL @0A?@>AB@0=5=85 O45@=>3>, E8<8G5A:>3> 8 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O 8;LO< 5@8 (William J. Perry) ;02=>9 >?0A=>ABLN 4;O <5@8:8 =0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L O2;O5BAO 2>7<>6=>ABL ?@8<5=5=8O B5@@>@8AB0<8 :0:>3>-;81> 2840 # =0 B5@@8B>@88 AB@0=K. I5 4> B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O A0<0 5= ;045= 3@><>3;0A=> 70O2;O; > =5>1E>48<>AB8 8<5BL B0:>5 >@C685, GB>1K A 53> ?><>ILN C18BL :0: <>6=> 1>;LH5 =525@=KE O=:8. 0H0 7040G0  =5 ?>72>;8BL B5@@>@8AB0< 702;045BL # 8 8A?>;L7>20BL 53> ?@>B82 =0A. !525@=0O >@5O 8 @0= -HB>= 0@B5@ (Ashton B. Carter)  ?@>D5AA>@ 0@20@4A:>3> C=825@A8B5B0 0H0 ?>;8B8:0 2 >1;0AB8 ?@>B82>459AB28O @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N # 70:;NG05BAO :0: 2 459AB28OE 2 @0<:0E A>N7>2, 345 <K AC<5;8 C1548BL 5@<0=8N, /?>=8N 8 "C@F8N >B:070BLAO >B ?>4>1=>3> >@C68O, B0: 8 2 @0AH8@5=88 8 C:@5?;5=88 @568<0 =5@0A?@>AB@0=5=8O 2 @0<:0E @07;8G=KE <564C=0@>4=KE 4>3>2>@>2 8 A>3;0H5=89. (>;>68B5;L=K5 ?@8<5@K: #:@08=0, 070EAB0=, 5;>@CAA8O, .6=0O D@8:0, @35=B8=0, @078;8O). "0<, 345 48?;><0B8O 1K;0 15AA8;L=0, ?@8E>48;>AL ?@81530BL : <5@0< :>=B@>;O =04 M:A?>@B>< :><?>=5=B>2 8 <0B5@80;>2, ?@83>4=KE 4;O 873>B>2;5=8O # 8 4065 : B09=K< >?5@0F8O< A?5FA;C61  =0H =01>@ 8=AB@C<5=B>2 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N C3@>75 ?@8<5=5=8O # 2E>4OB 8 <5@K 0:B82=>9 8 ?0AA82=>9 >1>@>=K, 8 ?@525=B82=K5 459AB28O. >A;54=85, :AB0B8, @0AA<0B@820;8AL 2 >B=>H5=88 !525@=>9 >@58 2 1994 3>4C 8 1K;8 ?@0:B8G5A:8 @50;87>20=K 2 >B=>H5=88 @0:0 2 1993 3>4C. >A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O >1@07>20;0AL 8 459AB2C5B H8@>:0O <564C=0@>4=0O :>0;8F8O ?> 1>@L15 A B5@@>@87<><. !53>4=O =5>1E>48<> A>740BL B0:>3> 65 @>40 :>0;8F8N ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N # 2 <8@5. @C3>9 7040G59 O2;O5BAO B@0=AD>@<0F8O 2>5==>9 AB@C:BC@K 2 AB>@>=C ?>2KH5=8O 55 MDD5:B82=>AB8 2 >B@065=88 2>7<>6=KE 0B0: A ?@8<5=5=85< #, >B:C40 1K >=8 =8 8AE>48;8. !;54C5B @0AH8@OBL 8 C:@5?;OBL <564C=0@>4=K5 4>3>2>@K 8 A>3;0H5=8O, =0?@02;5==K5 =0 ?@>B82>459AB285 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N #. , =0:>=5F, ?><=O ?5G0;L=K9 >?KB @0:0 8 D@07C 0<AD5;L40 BACBAB285 4>:070B5;LAB2 =5 O2;O5BAO 4>:070B5;LAB2>< >BACBAB28O, =5>1E>48<> 5I5 @07 C?><O=CBL ?@>1;5<C MDD5:B82=>AB8 8 =0456=>AB8 @07254A>>1I5AB20 !( 2 >B=>H5=88 :><?;5:A0 2>?@>A>2 ?> # 8 B5@@>@87<C. 0A;5485 E>;>4=>9 2>9=K >C7 >B<>;;5@ (Rose Gottemoeller) # =0A 5ABL CA?5H=K9 >?KB A>B@C4=8G5AB20 A >AA859 ?> A>:@0I5=8N O45@=>3> >@C68O 8 A@54AB2 53> 4>AB02:8. # =0A 5ABL CA?5H=K9 >?KB ?> ?@52@0I5=8N #:@08=K 8 070EAB0=0 2 157JO45@=K5 3>AC40@AB20, 2K254O 87 MB8E AB@0= 2A5 O45@=K5 1>53>;>2:8 8 O45@=K5 <0B5@80;K ?>4 =0456=K9 <564C=0@>4=K9 :>=B@>;L.  B5G5=85 10 ;5B <K :>=B@>;8@>20;8 A8BC0F8N 2 !525@=>9 >@55, =5 4>?CA:0O 2>7<>6=>AB8 8A?>;L7>20BL B>?;82=K5 ?;CB>=852K5 AB5@6=8 2 :0G5AB25 <0B5@80;>2 4;O 873>B>2;5=8O O45@=>3> >@C68O. 'B> :0A05BAO @0=0, B> A ?><>ILN >AA88 8 "- A;54C5B @5H0BL 425 ?@>1;5<K: 2K2>7 >B@01>B0==>3> O45@=>3> B>?;820 8 >ACI5AB2;5=85 <564C=0@>4=>3> :>=B@>;O =04 MB8< ?@>F5AA><; >AB0=>2:0 8@0=A:>9 ?@>3@0<<K ?> >1>30I5=8N C@0=0 A 40;L=59H8< 45<>=B065< >1>@C4>20=8O 8 ?>;=>9 ;8:2840F859 MB>3> ?@>872>4AB20 8 53> >1J5:B>2.  @0<:0E >;LH>9 2>AL<5@:8 C65 ?>;>65=> =0G0;> ?>4>1=KE A>2<5AB=KE CA8;89 (B0: =07K205<>5 3;>10;L=>5 ?0@B=5@AB2> ?@>B82 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O # 8 <0B5@80;>2, ?@83>4=KE 4;O 53> 873>B>2;5=8O), :>B>@K5 @01>B0NB =5 B>;L:> 2 8=B5@5A0E !( 8 >AA88, => 8 A0<>3> @0=0. #:@5?;OO 2=CB@5==NN 157>?0A=>ABL, =5;L7O 701K20BL > 2>7<>6=>< 8AB>G=8:5 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O #.  A>60;5=8N, >4=8< 87 >A=>2=KE O2;O5BAO >AA8O, GL5 >A;01;5=85, A>?@>2>6405<>5 CEC4H5=85< @568<0 :>=B@>;O 8 <5@ 157>?0A=>AB8 =04 #, <0B5@80;0<8 8 :><?>=5=B0<8, =5>1E>48<K<8 4;O 53> 873>B>2;5=8O ?@54AB02;O5BAO 3;02=K< 2K7>2>< 2 MB>9 >1;0AB8. K;> 1K ?@5C25;8G5=85< A:070BL, GB> 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 =8G53> =5 45;05B 2 MB>< =0?@02;5=88, => >=0 :0:-B> 702O7;0 2 A?>@0E > 2708<=KE >1O70B5;LAB20E 8 =8:0: =5 4>AB83=5B ?@0:B8G5A:>9 @50;870F88 :>=:@5B=KE ?@>3@0<< 8 ?@>5:B>2, =0?@02;5==KE =0 ?>2KH5=85 AB5?5=8 157>?0A=>AB8 2 >B=>H5=88 @>AA89A:>3> O45@=>3> ?>B5=F80;0 8 # 2 F5;><. (0?@8<5@, ?>28A 2 2>74CE5 ?@>5:B A>740=8O 1J548=5==>3> F5=B@0 ?> >1<5=C 8=D>@<0F859, ?@8720==>9 A=878BL @8A: A;CG09=>3> 8;8 =5A0=:F8>=8@>20==>3> 70?CA:0 10;;8AB8G5A:8E @0:5B). 0< =C6=K =5 :>=AB@C:B82=K5 48A:CAA88 A >AA859, 0 @50;L=K5 ?@>3@0<<K, @01>B0NI85 =0 =0F8>=0;L=CN 157>?0A=>ABL !(.  B><C 65 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 =54>AB0B>G=> D8=0=A8@C5B MBC @01>BC. !;54>20;> 1K 2K45;8BL ?>@O4:0 B@5E <8;;80@4>2 4>;;0@>2, GB>, :AB0B8, 7=0G8B5;L=> <5=LH5 AC<<K, 5653>4=> 2K45;O5<>9 =0 A>740=85  . 0A?@>AB@0=5=85 E8<8G5A:>3> 8 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O -<<8 !<8BA>= (Amy Smithson)  M:A?5@B &5=B@0 AB@0B538G5A:8E 8 <564C=0@>4=KE 8AA;54>20=89 (CSIS) %>B5;>AL 1K >B<5B8BL B@8 ACI5AB25==KE <><5=B0 2 40==>9 ?@>1;5<5: B5E=8G5A:85 ?@5?OBAB28O, A>740205<K5 <564C B5@@>@8AB0<8 8 MB8<8 A<5@B>=>A=K<8 2840<8 >@C68O; 3>B>2=>ABL =0H8E 3>@>4>2 8 =0A5;5=8O : ?>4>1=>3> @>40 0B0:0< 8 CB5G:0 <>73>2 8 <0B5@80;>2 87 1K2H53> A>25BA:>3> , A2O70==>3> A ?@>872>4AB2>< E8<8G5A:>3> 8 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O. A>1> ?>4G5@:=C 7=0G5=85 @07;8G=KE <564C=0@>4=KE 4>3>2>@>2 8 A>3;0H5=89, =0?@02;5==KE =0 =5@0A?@>AB@0=5=85 MB8E 284>2 >@C68O. !53>4=O 155 AB@0= O2;ONBAO CG0AB=8:0<8 >3>2>@0 > 70?@5I5=88 ?@>872>4AB20 8 ?@8<5=5=8O E8<8G5A:>3> >@C68O >B 1997 3>40. 4=0:> >AB05BAO ?@>1;5<0 A >3@><=K<8 70?0A0<8 @>AA89A:>3> E8<8G5A:>3> >@C68O (?>@O4:0 40 BKAOG B>==), 2 G5< 5ABL 8 28=0 0<5@8:0=A:>9 AB>@>=K, :>B>@0O =5 2K?>;=8;0 A2>8E >15I0=89 2 G0AB8 ?><>I8 ?> 53> C=8GB>65=8N. !( 4>;6=K 459AB2>20BL 1>;55 @5H8B5;L=> 2 >B=>H5=88 D0:B>2 =0@CH5=8O <564C=0@>4=KE :>=25=F89 > E8<8G5A:>< 8 18>;>38G5A:>< >@C688 A> AB>@>=K !8@88, !525@=>9 >@58 8 @0=0. !;54C5B 2:;NG8BL 2 ?>25AB:C 4=O <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20 B0:85 206=K5 2>?@>AK :0: 18>157>?0A=>ABL 8 35==0O 8=65=5@8O. 0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L 2 100 AB@0=0E <8@0 ?@8=OB> 1>;55 BKAOG8 70:>=>2 ?> @07;8G=K< 0A?5:B0< ?@>1;5<K E8<8G5A:>3> 8 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O. 1A>;NB=> =52>7<>6=> CA;548BL 8 ?@>:>=B@>;8@>20BL 2K?>;=5=85 MB>9 3>@K 70:>=>40B5;L=KE 0:B>2. > <=5=8N <=>38E M:A?5@B>2, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 70=8<05BAO ?>;8B8G5A:>9 @8B>@8:>9, 0 =5 @50;L=>9 AB@0B53859 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N E8<8G5A:>3> 8 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O 8 C=8GB>65=8N 8<5NI8EAO 2 <8@5 70?0A>2 MB>3> >@C68O. >@L10 A @0A?@>AB@0=5=85< # 8 =>20O 3>=:0 2>>@C65=89 5=48 (5@<0= (Wendy Sherman)  48?;><0B >A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O, :>340 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 ?@8H;0 : 2K2>4C > =587156=>AB8 2>9=K 2 @0:5, =0 0<5@8:0=A:>5 >1I5AB2> >1@CH8;AO 20; CAB@0H0NI59 8=D>@<0F88 > B5@@>@8AB0E, >1 #, > A818@A:>9 O725 8 4@C38E ?>4>1=KE AB@0ABOE. >O28;>AL ?>=8<0=85 >?0A=>AB8 MB8E C3@>7 8 2 <8@>2>< A>>1I5AB25, => 2<5AB> B>3>, GB>1K >1J548=8BL 8 2>73;028BL <564C=0@>4=K5 CA8;8O ?> 1>@L15 A =>2K<8 2K7>20<8 ?>4 M384>9 , 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 27O;0 :C@A =0 >4=>AB>@>==85 ?@525=B82=K5 459AB28O 8 A>740=85 F5;52KE :>0;8F89. "0:0O ?>;8B8:0, >A>15==> 2 A2O78 A A><=8B5;L=K<8 >1>A=>20=8O<8 2>9=K 2 @0:5, ?@825;0 : ?>B5@5 4>25@8O : <5@8:5 8 55 A?5FA;C610<. 5>1E>48<> A@>G=> 2>AAB0=02;820BL =0H5 @5=><5 2 <8@5, 5A;8 <K AG8B05<, GB> !( ?> ?@02C O2;ONBAO 3;>10;L=K< ;845@><, GL5 <>@0;L=>5 ?@02> ?@87=05BAO <564C=0@>4=K< A>>1I5AB2><. > =0 D>=5 @8B>@8:8 04<8=8AB@0F88 CH0 > ?@>B82>459AB288 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N #, >=0 ?@8ABC?05B : @07@01>B:5 =>2KE 284>2 O45@=>3> >@C68O <0;>9 <>I=>AB8, O:>1K ?@54=07=0G5==>9 4;O >B@065=8O =>2KE C3@>7 21 25:. 4=0:> ?>4>1=K5 H038 ?>4@K20NB =K=5 459AB2CNI85 <564C=0@>4=K5 A>3;0H5=8O, =0?@8<5@ >3>2>@ > 2A5>1J5<;NI5< 70?@5B5 =0 O45@=K5 8A?KB0=8O. >;CG05BAO, GB> 2>?@5:8 A;>20<, <5@8:0 AB0=>28BAO 8=8F80B>@>< =>2>9 3>=:8 2>>@C65=89.  40==>9 A8BC0F88 4;O =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 !( 1K;8 1K 1>;55 ?>;57=K<8 CA8;8O ?> C:@5?;5=8N 8 @0AH8@5=8N 2A5E =K=5 459AB2CNI8E <564C=0@>4=KE A>3;0H5=89 8 >@30=870F89, 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L, >3>2>@0 > =5@0A?@>AB@0=5=88 # 8 "-. 0 ?@0:B8:5 65 <K 2848<, GB> 2<5AB> AB@0B5388 65AB:>3> <564C=0@>4=>3> :>=B@>;O, 8=A?5:F89 8, 5A;8 =5>1E>48<>, A0=:F89, 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 ?@54?>G;0 ?>;8B8:C >4=>AB>@>==8E A8;>2KE ?@525=B82=KE @5H5=89, 4>?CA:0NI8E 4065 ?@8<5=5=85 O45@=>3> >@C68O, E>BL 8 <0;>9 <>I=>AB8.  !525@=>9 >@55 -HB>= 0@B5@ >A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O <K B0: 8 =5 4>18;8AL <8@>2>3> :>=A5=ACA0 >B=>A8B5;L=> C3@>7K #, 53> @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O 8 >?0A=>AB8 ?>?040=8O 2 @C:8 B5@@>@8AB>2. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO =5?>A@54AB25==> !525@=>9 >@58, B> A8BC0F8O 745AL ?@54AB02;O5BAO 1>;55 A5@L57=>9, G5< 2 A2>5 2@5<O 8@0:A:89 :@878A. 5;> =5 B>;L:> 2 B><, GB> >=0 A?>A>1=0 A>740BL 8;8 C65 8<55B (>?OBL 2>?@>A =0456=>AB8 8 MDD5:B82=>AB8 =0H59 @07254:8) 5 8;8 6 O45@=KE 1>5?@8?0A>2, => 8 2 B><, GB> >=8 <>3CB ?>?0ABL : ;N4O<, ?8B0NI8< =5=028ABL : <5@8:5 A> 2A5<8 2KB5:0NI8<8 ?>A;54AB28O<8. !59G0A <K ?KB05<AO @07@5H8BL MBC >?0A=59HCN A8BC0F8N ?CB5< <=>3>AB>@>==8E 48?;><0B8G5A:8E ?5@53>2>@>2, => GB> 45;0BL, 5A;8 >=8 >:06CBAO 157@57C;LB0B=K<8?  A>60;5=8N, <K 4>;6=K 1KBL 3>B>2K : ?@8<5=5=8N ?@525=B82=>9 2>5==>9 A8;K, GB>1K =5 4>?CAB8BL @568< E5=LO=0 : 0B><=>9 1><15. >65B 1KBL, >B:0702H8AL >B MB>3> 2 1994 3>4C, <K ;8HL CAC3C18;8 ?@>1;5<C, 402 2>7<>6=>ABL !525@=>9 >@55 70=8<0BLAO O45@=K< H0=B06><. 57 2AO:>3> A><=5=8O, <K 4>;6=K =5 B>;L:> ?@>4>;60BL, => 8 =0@0I820BL =0H8 48?;><0B8G5A:85 CA8;8O, 402 B25@4>5 >15I0=85 =5 =0?040BL =0 !525@=CN >@5N, 5A;8 >=0 >B:065BAO >B A>740=8O O45@=>3> >@C68O. 0H <0;>?@8OB=K9 287028 4>;65= OA=> ?>=8<0BL, GB> 2 ?@>B82=>< A;CG05 >= >:065BAO <564C=0@>4=K< 873>5< 8 <>65B ?>425@3=CBLAO ?@525=B82=><C A8;>2><C @07>@C65=8N. -B> @8A:>20==0O, => >?@0240==0O, A B>G:8 7@5=8O >15A?5G5=8O =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, ?>;8B8:0. * * * A=>2=K5 <><5=BK 87 4>:;040 183=520 6578=A:>3> 57>?0A=>ABL <5@8:8 2 M?>EC 55 ?>402;ONI53> ?@52>AE>4AB20. >A;54=85 3>;>A>20=8O 2  ?> @0:C 8 87@08;LA:>-?0;5AB8=A:><C :>=D;8:BC >BG5B;82> C:07K20NB =0 420 =5?@8OB=KE 4;O !( D0:B0  ?>B5@N 4>25@8O A> AB>@>=K <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20 8 CA8;5=85 <564C=0@>4=>9 87>;OF88. 0=8<0O 15A?@5F545=B=>5 ?>;>65=85 548=AB25==>9 A25@E45@602K, <5@8:0 2 ?>;8B8G5A:>< A<KA;5 >:070;0AL =0 A0<>9 =87:>9 B>G:5 70 2AN 8AB>@8N AB@0=K. =>385 =0H8 4@C7LO 8 A>N7=8:8 70 @C156>< ?@>4>;60NB @0745;OBL 0<5@8:0=A:85 8450;K 8 F5==>AB8, => >=8 ?5@5AB0;8 ?>=8<0BL =0HC ?>;8B8:C, :>B>@CN 2>A?@8=8<0NB :0: 45<03>38N, 70<5H0==CN =0 ;68. 5:>B>@K5 <>3CB ?>?KB0BLAO >1JOA=8BL B0:>5 >B=>H5=85 : !( ?@>AB>9 7028ABLN : 1>;55 A8;L=><C 8 1>30B><C, => MB8< ?@>I5 2A53> >?@0240BL A2>8 A>1AB25==K5 ?@><0E8 8 ?@>AG5BK. >A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O 2>A?@8OB85 2=5H=53> <8@0 0<5@8:0=A:>9 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 M;8B>9 AB0;> =>A8BL 1C:20;L=> ?0@0=>840;L=K9 E0@0:B5@, GB> =0H;> >B@065=85 2 7=0<5=8B>9 D>@<C;5 ?@57845=B0 CH0: B> =5 A =0<8, B>B ?@>B82 =0A. -B> 1>;LH528ABA:>5 @C:>2>4AB2> : 459AB28N (8<5==> B0:>9 B578A 2K428=C; 5=8=, >1@0I0OAL : A>F80;-45<>:@0B0<) ?>G5<C-B> AB0;> :@05C3>;L=K< :0<=5< 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 <>I=59H59 <8@>2>9 45@602K, 2A5340 AB>O2H59 =0 70I8B5 8450;>2 45<>:@0B88 8 A2>1>4K. 5>?@0240==>5 AC65=85 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 4> 2>9=K A B5@@>@87<>< >BG0AB8 >1JOA=O5BAO ?0=8G5A:8< AB@0E>< 2>7<>6=>AB8 ?>?040=8O 2 @C:8 B5@@>@8AB>2 :0:8E-;81> 284>2 A>2@5<5==>3> #, >BG0AB8 3@0=48>7=K<8 ?@>20;0<8 A?5FA;C61, >:0702H8EAO =5A?>A>1=K<8 ?@542845BL 8 ?@54>B2@0B8BL =>2K5 C3@>7K. !53>4=O 0<5@8:0=A:>5 >1I5AB2> 4>;6=> >B25B8BL =0 420 2>?@>A0: >3CB ;8 !( >ACI5AB2;OBL @>;L <8@>2>3> ;845@0, @C:>2>4AB2COAL AB@0E>< 8 1>O7=LN? !?>A>1=K ;8 <K >1@5AB8 ?>445@6:C =0H8E 4@C759 8 A>N7=8:>2, >1@0I0OAL : =8< A ?>78F89 B> =5 A =0<8, B>B ?@>B82 =0A? >2>@8BL > =5:>59 <5AA80=A:>9 @>;8 <5@8:8, A2>4OI59AO : C=8GB>65=8N <564C=0@>4=>3> B5@@>@87<0 - 7=0G8B =5 70<5G0BL 4@C385 A5@L57=K5 ?@>1;5<K, B@51CNI85 A2>53> @07@5H5=8O. 0 8 A0<8 @0AAC645=8O > ?@>1;5<5 B5@@>@87<0 =>AOB 25AL<0 01AB@0:B=K9 E0@0:B5@ A ?@82;5G5=85< :2078B5>;>38G5A:8E 0@3C<5=B>2 8 D>@<C;8@>2>:. K 4>;6=K B>G=> ?@54AB02;OBL, :B> :>=:@5B=> ?@54AB02;O5B C3@>7C 157>?0A=>AB8 !( 8 2A5<C <8@C 2 F5;><. @8 MB>< =0H0 48A:CAA8O =5 4>;6=0 2K;8BLAO 2 ?@>AB>5 >E0820=85 8 :@8B8:C A53>4=OH=59 04<8=8AB@0F88. K 4>;6=K 2A?><=8BL > DC=40<5=B0;L=KE ?@8=F8?0E D>@<8@>20=8O =0H59 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388, 2 >A=>25 :>B>@KE ;568B ?;N@0;87< <=5=89 45<>:@0B>2 8 @5A?C1;8:0=F52. ">;L:> B0:0O A8=B5B8G5A:0O ?>78F8O, 8A?>;L7C5<0O 2> 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:5, 8 ?@52@0B8;0 <5@8:C 2 254CICN <8@>2CN 45@602C. 0< =5>1E>48<> 2=>2L 2K@01>B0BL A10;0=A8@>20==CN 8 381:CN ?>;8B8:C, A?>A>1=CN : 1KAB@>9 040?B0F88 8 :><?@><8AA0<.  :>=F5 :>=F>2, >B 2K1>@0 ?>;8B8:8 7028A8B CA?5E 8;8 =5CA?5E 2 ?@>42865=88 0<5@8:0=A:8E 8=B5@5A>2. %>BO 2 =0H8E >B=>H5=8OE A 52@>?59A:8<8 4@C7LO<8 8 A>N7=8:0<8 8 ACI5AB2C5B =5GB> B@0=AF5=45=B0;L=>5, =>, AB@5<OAL : 2708<>?>=8<0=8N, =5;L7O B>;L:> 48:B>20BL 8 C?@5:0BL. 54L 8 0<5@8:0=A:0O B>G:0 7@5=8O =5 2A5340 <>65B >:070BLAO 01A>;NB=> 25@=>9. =0G8B5;L=> 1>;55 ?@>4C:B82=> AB@5<8BLAO : A>B@C4=8G5AB2C A 2@>?>9 2 F5;><, 0 =5 45;8BL 55 =0 =>2KE 8 AB0@KE 4@C759 8 >??>=5=B>2. !>740=85 AB018;L=>9 <564C=0@>4=>9 A8AB5<K, 2 :>B>@>9 !( 2KABC?0NB 2 :0G5AB25 >1J5:B82=>3> ;845@0, 459AB2CNI53> 2 8=B5@5A0E 2A53> <8@0, =52>7<>6=> 157 :>=AB@C:B82=>3> 480;>30 A >;LH>9 2@>?>9. -B0 A8AB5<0 ?@54?>;0305B 8 2>2;5G5==>ABL >AA88, >4=>2@5<5==> C3;C1;ONI59 >B=>H5=8O 8 A 2@>?>9, 8 A 52@>-0B;0=B8G5A:8< A>>1I5AB2><. 4=0:> <K 4>;6=K OA=> ?>=8<0BL, GB> 3;02=>9 F5;LN =0H59 AB@0B5388 2 >B=>H5=88 >AA88 O2;O5BAO ?@>42865=85 45<>:@0B88, 8450;0<8 :>B>@>9 =5;L7O ?>ABC?8BLAO 4065 4;O @50;870F88 :0:8E-B> B0:B8G5A:8E 7040G.  MB>< A<KA;5 25AL<0 15A?>:>8B 157>3>2>@>G=>5 2>A?@8OB85 04<8=8AB@0F859 CH0 =K=5H=59 @>AA89A:>9 2;0AB8, ?>GB8 A?;>HL A>AB>OI59 87 1K2H8E A>B@C4=8:>2 , :0: CA?5H=>3> 45<>:@0B8G5A:>3> @568<0. !B@5<OAL : 4>AB865=8N 1>;55 B5A=KE 8 4>25@8B5;L=KE >B=>H5=89 A >AA859, <K 4>;6=K B@572> ?@>0=0;878@>20BL 2A5 A2>8 ?@><0E8 8 ?@>AG5BK, => 8 >A:25 A;54C5B ?>=8<0BL, GB> =52>7<>6=> >6840BL CA?5E0 >B ?0@B=5@AB20, :>340 >4=0 87 AB>@>= =8:0: =5 E>G5B >B:070BLAO >B 8<?5@A:>3> A>2:>2>3> <KH;5=8O. K 8<55< 2 284C 8 ?@>4>;60NI89AO 35=>F84 2 '5G=5, 8 ?>402;5=85 A2>1>4K !, 8 45;> .!& <5@8:0=A:0O AB>@>=0 =8:0: =5 <>65B 1KBL 157CG0AB=>9 : ?>4>1=K< 459AB28O< @>AA89A:8E 2;0AB59, =0=>AOI8E A5@L57=K9 CI5@1 =0@>640NI59AO 2 AB@0=5 45<>:@0B88. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO @0AH8@5=8O 7>=K <8@0 2 3;>10;L=>< <0AHB015, B> E>BO <5@8:0 8 83@05B 745AL ?5@2>AB5?5==CN @>;L, => 8 >=0 =5 2A5A8;L=0. 9 =5>1E>48<0 ?>445@6:0 8 ! 8 $, E>BL 8 A >?@545;5==K<8 >3>2>@:0<8 2 04@5A 55 =5?>;=>3> A>>B25BAB28O AB0BCAC 45<>:@0B8G5A:>3> 3>AC40@AB20.  A2>8E CA8;8OE ?> A>740=8N 7>=K <8@0 3;>10;L=>3> <0AHB010 <5@8:5 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L ?@8E>48BAO 8<5BL 45;> A 7>=0<8 :>=D;8:B0, B0:8<8 :0: ;86=89 >AB>:. A;8 1@0BL >B45;L=> @0:, B> MBC ?@>1;5<C A53>4=O A;54C5B @5H0BL ?>;8B8G5A:8< ?CB5<, 8A?>;L7CO A8;C 2 :0G5AB25 8=AB@C<5=B0 ?>445@6:8 ?@>F5AA0 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O AB@0=K.  MB>< A<KA;5 =5>1E>48<0 1KAB@59H0O 8=B5@=0F8>=0;870F8O 2>5==>3> ?@8ACBAB28O 2 @0:5, GB> >1J5:B82=> 70:@5?8B C65 4>AB83=CBK5 CA?5E8 2 45;5 ?5@5CAB@>9AB20 8@0:A:>9 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 8 M:>=><8G5A:>9 A8AB5<K. ><8<> 1>;55 H8@>:>3> ?@82;5G5=8O <564C=0@>4=KE A8;, A;54C5B :0: <>6=> A:>@55 ?5@540BL 2AN ?>;=>BC 2;0AB8 AC25@5==><C 8@0:A:><C ?@028B5;LAB2C. K=5H=89 AC25@5=8B5B @0:0 =>A8B ;8HL =><8=0;L=K9 E0@0:B5@. >, ?>4G5@:820O B>, GB> =0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L @0: O2;O5BAO ?>;=>ABLN AC25@5==K< 3>AC40@AB2><, <K >1J5:B82=> ?><>305< =K=5H=8< 8@0:A:8< 2;0ABO< =5 B>;L:> >1@5AB8 ?>;8B8G5A:CN ;538B8<=>ABL, => 8 ?>A:>@55 >?@545;8BLAO A A0<>845=B8D8:0F859 AB@0=K. 0AAC640O > =K=5H=59 A8BC0F88 2 @0:5, =5C<5AB=> ?@>2>48BL 0=0;>38N A L5B=0<><. 0E>4OAL ?>4 <564C=0@>4=K< 7>=B8:><, 8@0:A:85 2;0AB8 2?>;=5 A?>A>1=K A?@028BLAO A ?@>A0440<>2A:>9 >??>78F859 8 2=CB@5==8< B5@@>@87<><. 0< 65, A> A2>59 AB>@>=K, =5>1E>48<> ?>=OBL ;>38:C 8 48=0<8:C 2=CB@5==5<C A>?@>B82;5=8N 2 @0:5. 45AL >G5=L 206=>, GB>1K G0ABL @5H5=8O MB>9 ?@>1;5<K 27O;> =0 A51O <564C=0@>4=>5 A>>1I5AB2> 8 A0<8 8@0:FK. ;86=89 >AB>: =8:>340 =5 AB0=5B 7>=>9 <8@0 157 @5H5=8O ?0;5AB8=>-87@08;LA:>3> :>=D;8:B0 8 OA=>3> >?@545;5=8O ?>78F88 !( 2 MB>< ?@8=F8?80;L=>< 2>?@>A5. AC645=85 ?0;5AB8=A:8E B5@@>@8AB>2 =5 4>;6=> ?@52@0B8BLAO 2 >3C;L=CN ?>445@6:C 65AB>:8E 8 871KB>G=KE >B25B=KE <5@ 87@08;LA:8E 2;0AB59, ?@>4>;60NI8E A>740=85 ?>A5;5=89 :>;>=80;L=>3> B8?0 8 AB@>OI8E @0745;ONICN AB5=C. 5 1C45< ;C:028BL. !B02:0 2 83@5  AC4L10 3>AC40@AB20 7@08;L, O2;ONI53>AO 45<>:@0B8G5A:>9 AB@0=>9 8 8AB>@8G5A:8< A>N7=8:>< !( =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5.  2A5 65 :@878A =8:>340 =5 @07@5H8BAO, 5A;8 =5 1C45B A>740=> =57028A8<>5 ?0;5AB8=A:>5 3>AC40@AB2>. !>740205<0O 7@08;5< AB5=0 157>?0A=>AB8 =5 @5H8BL ?@>1;5<C, 0 ;8HL 703>=8B 1>;57=L 2=CB@L. =>385 87@08;LBO=5 A0<8 AG8B0NB, GB>, 5A;8 A>1KB8O 1C4CB @072820BLAO 2 =K=5H=5< @CA;5, B> 8E AB@0=0 <>65B ?>2B>@8BL ?5G0;L=CN AC4L1C N6=>0D@8:0=A:>3> @568<0 0?0@B5840, :>340 2 >4=>9 AB@0=5 <5=LH8=AB2> ?KB0;>AL 3>A?>4AB2>20BL =04 1>;LH8=AB2><. !( 4>;6=K ?>445@6820BL BC 74>@>2CN G0ABL 87@08;LA:>3> 8 ?0;5AB8=A:>3> >1I5AB20, :>B>@0O AB@5<8BAO : <8@C 8 3>B>20 @048 =53> ?>9B8 =0 >?@545;5==K5 :><?@><8AAK. A:>@5 1C45B >1=0@>4>20= =>2K9 ?;0= <8@=>3> @5H5=8O 2>?@>A0, :>B>@K9 2 B5G5=85 =5A:>;L:8E <5AOF52 A>2<5AB=> @07@010BK20;8 87@08;LBO=5 8 ?0;5AB8=FK. >;030N, GB> 2 >B;8G85 >B (0@>=0, :>B>@K9 70@0=55 53> >AC48;, =0< A;54C5B ?>445@60BL MBC =>2CN ?>?KB:C A>740=8O 7>=K <8@0 2 MB>< @538>=5. @O4 ;8 >H81CAL, 5A;8 2>7L<C A<5;>ABL 70O28BL, GB> 0<5@8:0=A:85 52@58 8 2A5 0<5@8:0=A:>5 A>>1I5AB2> E>BOB <8@=>3> ?>;8B8G5A:>3> @5H5=8O ?0;5AB8=>-87@08;LA:>3> :>=D;8:B0. I5 >4=>9 ?@>1;5<>9, ?> :>B>@>9 =0< =5>1E>48<> B5A=> A>B@C4=8G0BL A <564C=0@>4=K< A>>1I5AB2><, O2;O5BAO @0A?@>AB@0=5=85 O45@=>3> >@C68O.  MB>< 2>?@>A5 C !( ?@>AB> =5B 8=>9 0;LB5@=0B82K. A;8 1K <K ?>?KB0;8AL @5H8BL ?@>1;5<C !525@=>9 >@58 2 >48=>G:C 8 B>;L:> A ?><>ILN A8;K, B> B0:>9 H03 =5?@5<5==> 1K 2K720; 2A?;5A: 0=B80<5@8:0=87<0 8 =0F8>=0;87<0 2 .6=>9 >@55, CA:>@8; ?@>F5AA ?>O2;5=8O /?>=88 2 :0G5AB25 =>2>9 O45@=>9 45@602K, GB> <>3;> 1K =0@CH8BL AB@0B538G5A:89 10;0=A A8; =0 2A5< 40;L=5< >AB>:5.  A;CG05 A @0=>< <K B0:65 =5 A:@K205< A2>59 708=B5@5A>20==>AB8 2 A<5=5 45A?>B8G=>3> B5>:@0B8G5A:>3> @568<0. > >?OBL 65 A8;>2K5 ?@525=B82=K5 459AB28O <>3;8 1K CAC3C18BL A8BC0F8N 8 ;8HL @0AH8@8BL 7>=C :>=D;8:B0 2 ;86=52>AB>G=>< @538>=5. @>1;5<0 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O # 2:;NG05B 2 A51O =5 B>;L:> AB@5<;5=85 B0:8E AB@0= :0: !525@=0O >@5O 8;8 @0= 8< >1;040BL, => 8 C3@>7C ?>?040=8O MB8E A<5@B>=>A=KE 8 @07@CH8B5;L=KE 284>2 2>>@C65=8O 2 @C:8 B5@@>@8AB>2. 5;8: A>1;07= @5H8BL 2>?@>A, ?@8153=C2 : >4=>AB>@>==8< ?@525=B82=K< A8;>2K< 459AB28O<, => 2 B0:>< A;CG05 <K 4>;6=K 1KBL 01A>;NB=> C25@5=K 2 B><, GB>: !CI5AB2C5B @50;L=0O C3@>70 157>?0A=>AB8 !( 8 8E A>N7=8:0<. 5B =8:0:8E 48?;><0B8G5A:8E ?>;8B8G5A:8E A@54AB2 55 ;8:2848@>20BL 8;8 ?@54>B2@0B8BL.  A2O78 A MB8< =0 ?5@2>5 <5AB> 2KE>48B >1I5=0F8>=0;L=0O 7040G0 @5>@30=87>20BL @01>BC 8 AB@C:BC@C =0H8E @07254A;C61 A F5;LN ?>2KH5=8O 8E MDD5:B82=>AB8 8 =0456=>AB8. 0=LH5 1K;> ;53G5 2KAB@>8BL AB@0B538N 157>?0A=>AB8, B0: :0: 2A5 C3@>7K 1K;8 >G5284=K 8 G5B:> >?@545;O5<K. !53>4=O <K 6825< 2 25: =5>?@545;5==KE 8, ?>@>9, =5>6840==KE 2K7>2>2 8 C3@>7, >BG53> A0<0 ?@>1;5<0 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 AB0;0 A;>6=55 8 70?CB0==55. >B ?>G5<C 2A5 1>;LH55 7=0G5=85 8<55B ?>;CG5=85 A2>52@5<5==>9 8 4>AB>25@=>9 @072548=D>@<0F88.  MB>9 A2O78 E>G5BAO =0?><=8BL, GB> 2A5 =0H5 7=0=85 > =0;8G88 C @0:0 # =>A8;> 25AL<0 01AB@0:B=K9 E0@0:B5@, M:AB@0?>;8@COAL >B B>3> D0:B0, GB> :>340-B> !040< %CA59= 459AB28B5;L=> 53> 8<5; 8 4065 ?@8<5=O;. 0G8=0O 2B>@65=85, 0<5@8:0=A:85 2>5==K5 =5 8<5;8 =8 <0;59H53> ?@54AB02;5=8O 345, :>340 8 :0:85 284K 8@0:A:>3> # <>3CB 1KBL ?@8<5=5=K ?@>B82 =8E. =K<8 A;>20<8, >=8 =5 1K;8 >15A?5G5=K =8:0:>9 :>=:@5B=>9 8 4>AB>25@=>9 8=D>@<0F859, 0 254L @0: 1K; =5 B0:>9 87>;8@>20==>9 8 70:@KB>9 AB@0=>9, :0: 2 A2>5 2@5<O !>25BA:89 !>N7, 345 =0H8 @07254A;C61K 8<5;8 7=0G8B5;L=> 1>;LH85 CA?5E8. @><0E8 8 >H81:8 =0H8E @07254A;C61 >1>@0G820NBAO 87JO=0<8 8 ?@>20;0<8 2 >1I59 AB@0B5388 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. 54L, 5A;8 <K 27O;8 =0 A51O @>;L <8@>2>3> ;845@0, B> 4;O 55 @50;870F88 =5>1E>48<> 4>25@85 A> AB>@>=K <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20. >;030N, GB> 4> 2>9=K A @0:>< B0:>5 4>25@85 C <5@8:8 1K;>. >=5G=>, C B>9 65 5@<0=88 8;8 >@25388 8<5NBAO A2>8 A>1AB25==K5 @07254A;C61K, => >=8 4>25@O;8 =0H8< AC645=8O< ?> B><C 8;8 8=><C <564C=0@>4=>-7=0G8<><C 2>?@>AC, 0 A59G0A =5 4>25@ONB. 0< =5>1E>48<> 2>AAB0=>28BL 4>25@85 : ?>;8B8:5 AB@0=K 8 : 55 @07254A;C610< 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L. 5A:>;L:> A;>2 > =>2KE @50;8OE 8 0<5@8:0=A:>< 8450;87<5. 0 ?@>BO65=88 <=>38E 45AOB8;5B89 <8@ 2845; 2 <5@8:5 A2>53> @>40 ?@8<5@ 4;O ?>4@060=8O - >1I5AB2>, ?@540==>5 8450;0< A2>1>4K 8 45<>:@0B88 8 3>B>2>5 70I8I0BL A2>8 F5==>AB8 :0: 2=CB@8 AB@0=K, B0: 8 70 @C156><. !53>4=O <=>385 >15A?>:>5=K B5<, GB> =0H8 A?>A>1K 8 8=AB@C<5=BK 70I8BK 2E>4OB 2 ?@>B82>@5G8O A =0H8<8 8450;0<8. K@010BK20O =>2CN AB@0B538N 157>?0A=>AB8, <K 4>;6=K 459AB2>20BL B0:, GB>1K 4@C385 AB@0=K =5 2845;8 2 !( M3>8AB8G=>3> 8 =04<5==>3> ?0@B=5@0, 701>BOI53>AO B>;L:> > A2>8E 8=B5@5A0E. 564C=0@>4=>5 A>>1I5AB2> 4>;6=> >ICI0BL, GB> =0H8 459AB28O 254CB : C:@5?;5=8N 157>?0A=>AB8 8 AB018;L=>AB8, 0 =5 =0>1>@>B. K 4>;6=K A<8@8BLAO A B5<, GB> <8@ 1C45B 5I5 4>;3>5 2@5<O >AB020BLAO =5157>?0A=K<. !;54C5B =5 B>;L:> =0CG8BLAO 68BL 2 MB8E @50;8OE, => 8 ?>A;54>20B5;L=> 8 @07C<=> ?@>2>48BL 1>;55 381:CN ?>;8B8:C, =0?@02;5==CN =0 @0AH8@5=85 7>=K <8@0. * * * 7 2KABC?;5=8O A5=0B>@0 6>75D0 845=0 (Joseph R. Biden, Jr.)  =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F88 ACI5AB2C5B A5@L57=>5 @0AE>645=85 2> 273;O40E =0 B>, :0:>5 <5AB> <5@8:0 4>;6=0 70=8<0BL 2 A53>4=OH=5< <8@5 8 :0:>2K 55 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:85 ?@8>@8B5BK.  >4=C D@0:F8N 2E>4OB '59=8, 0<AD5;L4, C;D>28F 8 8=K5 B0: =07K205<K5 =5>:>=A5@20B>@K, 0 4@C3CN A>AB02;O5B 0CM;; 8 1;87:85 5<C 2>5==K5 G8=K. >@>9 B@C4=> ?>=OBL, GLN AB>@>=C ?>445@68205B ?@57845=B, 8 :B> 2>>1I5 >B25G05B 70 ?@8=OB85 @5H5=89. K ?>AB>O==> A;KH8< >B CH0, GB> 5<C =C6=> ?>A>25B>20BLAO A >=4>;87>9 09A, :>B>@0O D0:B8G5A:8 83@05B @>;L ?5@52>4G8:0 ?@57845=B0 8 >4=>2@5<5==> D8;LB@C5B 2AN ?>ABC?0NICN : =5<C 8=D>@<0F8N. <5==> ?>MB><C 53> 2KA:07K20=8O >1 >B25BAB25==>AB8 <5@8:8 70 AC4L1C <8@0 2>A?@8=8<0NBAO :0: >1KG=0O ?>;8B8G5A:0O @8B>@8:0. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO =5?>A@54AB25==> 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 !(, B> O =5 2>A?@8=8<0N =8 <>B828@>2:C =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2, A:5?B8G5A:8 >B=>AOI8EAO : <564C=0@>4=K< 0;LO=A0< 2@>45 " 8 : <564C=0@>4=K< 8=AB8BCB0< 2@>45 , =8 : B5< 01A>;NB=K< <C;LB8;0B5@0;8AB0<, :>B>@K5 AB>OB 70 ?>;CG5=85 <8@>2>9 8=4C;L35=F88 =0 :064>5 ?@8<5=5=85 0<5@8:0=A:>9 2>5==>9 A8;K. / 2KABC?0N 70 B@572CN 8 2725H5==CN ?>;8B8:C ?@>A25I5==>3> =0F8>=0;87<0, :>340 <5@8:0 157 2AO:8E 8728=5=89 8 >?@0240=89 @5H8B5;L=> ?@8<5=O5B A8;C ?@>B82 @50;L=> 2>7=8:H59 C3@>7K 55 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, => 2 B> 65 2@5<O =8 2 :>5< A;CG05 =5 >B:07K205BAO 459AB2>20BL 2<5AB5 A <564C=0@>4=K< A>>1I5AB2><. &5=0 2>?@>A0 A;8H:>< 2KA>:0, 8 0<5@8:0=A:89 =0@>4 708=B5@5A>20= 2 B><, GB>1K ?@>2>48<0O 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:0O AB@0B538O @50;L=> 45;0;0 53> 687=L 1>;55 157>?0A=>9 8 AB018;L=>9. 4=0:>, A?CABO 2 3>4 ?>A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O 0<5@8:0=FK =5 >ICI0NB A51O <5=55 CO728<K<8 8 1>;55 70I8I5==K<8, ?>B><C GB> 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 C?CAB8;0 2>7<>6=>ABL A>740=8O MDD5:B82=>9 =0F8>=0;L=>9 AB@0B5388, GB> =5E>BO ?@87=05B 4065 <8=8AB@ >1>@>=K !( >=0;L4 0<AD5;L4. 5>1E>48<> =5<54;5==> ?@8ABC?8BL : :>@@5:B8@>2:5 =0H53> 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>3> :C@A0 2 AB>@>=C ?@54;0305<>3> <=>9 ?@>A25I5==>3> =0F8>=0;87<0.  =0G0BL =04> A CAB@0=5=8O 48A10;0=A0 2 =0H59 15A?@5F545=B=>9 A?>A>1=>AB8 ?@>5F8@>20BL 2>5==CN A8;C 2 ;N1>< C3>;:5 75<=>3> H0@0 8 <0;>9 MDD5:B82=>AB8 A>E@0=O5<>9 2>5==>9 A8;K 2 :>=:@5B=KE <5AB0E. >4>1=0O ?>;8B8:0 2 D30=8AB0=5 C65 ?@825;0 : B><C, GB> ?@57845=B AB@0=K 0@709 D0:B8G5A:8 O2;O5BAO ;8HL <M@>< 01C;0. "0;810= ?@>872>48B ?5@53@C??8@>2:C A8;, 0 2<5AB> 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O D30=8AB0=0 <K =01;N405< 53> ?@52@0I5=85 2 <8@>2>3> ;845@0 ?> 2K@0I820=8N 8 ?@>4065 =0@:>B8:>2. 0H0 =5A?>A>1=>ABL CAB0=>28BL <8@ 8 =0G0BL @5:>=AB@C:F8N 3>AC40@AB20 2 D30=8AB0=5 <>65B >15@=CBLAO ?@>20;>< 8 2 @0:5, G53> =8:0: =5;L7O 4>?CAB8BL. 4<8=8AB@0F8O 65 CH0, =5 2ABC?0O =8 2 :0:85 >1JOA=5=8O 8 48A:CAA88 =8 A >=3@5AA><, =8 A >1I5AB2><, ?@>4>;605B 3=CBL A2>N ;8=8N, CAB0<8 >=4>;87K 09A A>>1I0O =0<, GB> 8 2 D30=8AB0=5, 8 2 @0:5 & 2A5 ?>4 :>=B@>;5<, A8BC0F8O AB018;L=0O.  254L =K=5H=OO 0<5@8:0=A:0O ?>;8B8:0 2 >B=>H5=88 MB8E 42CE AB@0= <>65B ?@825AB8 8E : A>AB>O=8N 3>AC40@AB2-=5C40G=8:>2, :>B>@K5, ?> >1I5<C <=5=8N, 8 O2;ONBAO A0<>9 1;03>?@8OB=>9 A@54>9 4;O 70@>645=8O 8 @0728B8O B5@@>@87<0. 0H ?@>20; 2 D30=8AB0=5 8 @0:5 A?>A>15= =0=5AB8 A5@L57=K9 CI5@1 AB@0B538G5A:8< 8=B5@5A0< !( 2 <8@5.  MB>< A;CG05 2>7<>6=> CA8;5=85 8A;0<A:>3> DC=40<5=B0;87<0 2 @0=5, >A;01;5=85 C<5@5==KE AB>@>==8:>2 <>45@=870F88 2 "C@F88 8 >@40=88 8 4065 @0A?04 3>AC40@AB25==>AB8 2 0:8AB0=5. @57845=B CH 4>;65= =5<54;5==> 2ABC?8BL 2 >B:@KBK9 480;>3 A >=3@5AA>< 8 >1I5AB2>< =5 B>;L:> 4;O B>3>, GB>1K 25@=CBL ?@56=55 4>25@85, =>, 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L, 4;O B>3>, GB>1K >1JOA=8BL, GB> >B =K=5H=53> CA?5E0 8;8 =5CA?5E0 =0H8E 459AB289 2 D30=8AB0=5 8 @0:5 2> <=>3>< 7028A8B 157>?0A=>ABL :0: A0<>9 <5@8:8, B0: 8 <8@0 2 F5;><. K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O =07K205B @0: ?5@54>2>9 ;8=859 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<><, => 3>@L:0O 8AB8=0 A>AB>8B 2 B><, GB>, ?@>83@02 2 MB>9 AB@0=5, B5@@>@8ABK =5 ?5@5AB0=CB 0B0:>20BL =0A 2 4@C38E <5AB0E. #G8BK20O CA?5H=K9 >?KB @07@5H5=8O 2>>@C65==>3> :>=D;8:B0 =0 0;:0=0E, A;54C5B A@07C 65 ?>A;5 A25@65=8O 48:B0B>@A:>3> @568<0 ?@8ABC?0BL : A>740=8N 8 @0725@BK20=8N <564C=0@>4=KE ?>;8F59A:8E A8; 2 AB@0=5 8 4065 : =5?>A@54AB25==><C 2>AAB0=>2;5=8N 8 ?5@5CAB@>9AB2C 3>AC40@AB20. (<5==> 3>AC40@AB25==>5 AB@>8B5;LAB2>, 2848<>, 709<5B F5=B@0;L=>5 <5AB> 2 =0H59 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 =0 4>;385-4>;385 3>4K 2?5@54). A;8 65 A53>4=O C =0A =5B G5B:>3> ?;0=0 ?>A;52>5==KE 459AB289, B> A;54>20;> 1K :@5?:> ?>4C<0BL ?5@54 B5<, :0: 22O7K20BL AB@0=C 2 2>9=C. >;8B8:0 65 04<8=8AB@0F88 CH0 A>AB>O;0 2 A;54CNI5<: >=0 A=0G0;0 =5A:>;L:> ?@5C25;8G8;0 C3@>7C A> AB>@>=K @0:0, 0 70B5<, =5 >1@0I0O =8:0:>3> 2=8<0=8O =0 <=5=85 <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20, ?@8ABC?8;0 : @50;870F88 A2>59 4>:B@8=K ?@525=B82=KE A8;>2KE 459AB289. (@8 MB>< C =55 =5 1K;> =8 <0;59H53> ?>=OB8O, GB> 45;0BL 2 @0:5 ?>A;5 >:>=G0=8O 2>5==>9 D07K >?5@0F88).  8B>35: 0<5@8:0=A:85 2>9A:0 =5ACB 2AN BO65ABL >::C?0F88 @0:0 =0 A515; 0<5@8:0=A:>5 ?@028B5;LAB2> 70?>;CG8;> :@878A 4>25@8O :0: 2=CB@8 AB@0=K, B0: 8 70 @C156><; 45AB018;870F8O 2 <8@5 =0@0AB05B, B0: :0: <564C=0@>4=>5 A>>1I5AB2> ?>AG8B0;>, GB> 4>:B@8=0 ?@525=B82=KE A8;>2KE 459AB289 AB0=>28BAO =0H8< >A=>2=K< 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8< 8=AB@C<5=B><. !53>4=O <5@8:0 B@0B8B >3@><=K5 45=L38 8 =5A5B ;N4A:85 ?>B5@8, => A8BC0F8O A =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>ABLN AB0;0 EC65, G5< 1K;0 4> 2>9=K 2 @0:5.  =K=5H=59 A8BC0F88 548=AB25==> ?@028;L=K< @5H5=85< ?@54AB02;O5BAO AB@0B538O ?@82;5G5=8O : CG0AB8N 2 @07@5H5=88 ?@>1;5<K @0:0 2A53> <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20 2> 3;025 A  8 >4=>2@5<5==>5 A>740=85 =>2>9 8@0:A:>9 0@<88 8 ?>;8F88 8 ?>A;54CNI0O ?5@540G0 2;0AB8 2 @C:8 ;538B8<=> 871@0==>3> ?@028B5;LAB20. !;54CNI8< H03>< 2 AB>@>=C ?@>A25I5==>3> =0F8>=0;87<0 ?@54AB02;O5BAO A<5I5=85 0:F5=B0 C7:>9 4>:B@8=K ?@525=B82=KE 2>5==KE 459AB289 =0 1>;55 H8@>:CN AB@0B538N C?@5645=8O. G5284=>, GB> CA?5H=0O 2 3>4K E>;>4=>9 2>9=K 4>:B@8=0 A45@6820=8O, <0;>MDD5:B82=0 ?5@54 C3@>70<8 B5@@>@87<0 8 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O #, => =5;L7O 703>=OBL 2AN ?>;8B8:C 2 C7:85 @0<:8 ?@525=B82=KE 2>5==KE 459AB289. >72>4O 4>:B@8=C CH0 2 01A>;NB, <K ;8HL ?C305< <8@, 70AB02;OO ?@>1;5<=K5 AB@0=K (!525@=0O >@5O, @0=) 5I5 1KAB@55 >1702>48BLAO O45@=K< >@C685<, :0: A@54AB2>< A45@6820=8O ?@>B82 2>7<>6=>9 03@5AA88 !(.  B0:85 ?>B5=F80;L=> :>=D;8:B=K5 ?0@K :0: =48O 8 0:8AB0=,   8 "0920=L, 7@08;L 8 53> 0@01A:>5 >:@C65=85, !525@=0O 8 .6=0O >@5O =0G8=0NB A5@L57=> 704C<K20BLAO =04 0<5@8:0=A:8< B578A>< > ;538B8<=>AB8 A=0G0;0 ?@8<5=OBL A8;C, 0 ?>B>< 704020BL 4@C3 4@C3C 2>?@>AK. !>3;0A8B5AL, GB> MB> >G5=L 27@K2>>?0A=0O A8BC0F8O. K;> 1K 1>;55 @07C<=K< A>A@54>B>G8BL CA8;8O =0 <5@0E C?@5645=8O, B0:8E :0: C:@5?;5=85 157>?0A=>AB8 O45@=KE 0@A5=0;>2 8 C=8GB>65=85 70?0A>2 E8<8G5A:>3> >@C68O. (0G8=0O A >AA88 8 1K2H8E @5A?C1;8: !!! ). !;54C5B C:@5?;OBL 8 @0AH8@OBL <564C=0@>4=K5 ?@02>2K5 @568<K, =0?@02;5==K5 =0 ?@>B82>459AB285 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O #.  A2>5 2@5<O 3;02=>9 C3@>7>9 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 !( O2;O;AO !>25BA:89 !>N7, 8 <K A>740;8 ". "0: 8 A59G0A =C6=0 H8@>:0O <564C=0@>4=0O :>0;8F8O 3>AC40@AB2 4;O ?@>B82>459AB28O >A=>2=>9 C3@>75 <8@C  B5@@>@87<C. -B> 4>;6=0 1KBL @50;L=> ACI5AB2CNI0O 8 E>@>H> D8=0=A8@C5<0O <564C=0@>4=0O 0=B8B5@@>@8AB8G5A:0O >@30=870F8O. 5>1E>48<> @072820BL MDD5:B82=CN ?C1;8G=CN 48?;><0B8N (>1@07>20B5;L=K5 8 3C<0=8B0@=K5 ?@>3@0<<K, =0CG=K9 8 :C;LBC@=K9 >1<5=, 8 B.4.), A?>A>1=CN ?@>B82>AB>OBL @0A?@>AB@0=5=8N M:AB@5<8ABA:>9 845>;>388 8 03@5AA82=><C 0=B80<5@8:0=87<C. =>2L ?>4G5@:=C, GB> 2A5 MB> 2>7<>6=> B>;L:> 2 CA;>28OE B5A=>3> A>B@C4=8G5AB20 <5@8:8 A >AB0;L=K< <8@><.  A>60;5=8N, ?>A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O 04<8=8AB@0F8O CH0 27O;0 :C@A =0 ?>;8B8:C >4=>AB>@>==8E 459AB289, GB> 70:>=><5@=> ?@825;> : =0H59 A0<>87>;OF88 2 <8@5, => =5 C:@5?8;> =0F8>=0;L=CN 157>?0A=>ABL !(. -B> ?@>87>H;> ?>B><C, GB> 2>7>1;040;0 =5>:>=A5@20B82=0O 845>;>38O, ?@02OI0O 10; 2 =K=5H=59 04<8=8AB@0F88.  2 MB>9 845>;>38G5A:>9 A8AB5<5 <5@8:0 ?@54AB02;O5BAO 2 <8@5 :0: C;;825@ 2 AB@0=5 ;8;8?CB>2. BAN40 8 4>:B@8=0 >4=>AB>@>==8E ?@525=B82=KE 2>5==KE 459AB289, 8 ?@5=51@565=85 : <=5=8N <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20. ;02=>9 >?>@>9 =5>:>=A5@20B82=>9 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 AB0;0 =5?@527>945==0O 8 157>3>2>@>G=0O 2>5==0O <>IL <5@8:8. 0, <K ;53:> 8 ?@0:B8G5A:8 2 >48=>G:C A ?><>ILN 2>5==>9 A8;K A25@3;8 8 "0;810=, 8 @568< !0440<0 %CA59=0, => A<>65< ;8 <K >4=8, 157 ?><>I8 <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20, =5 B>;L:> AB018;878@>20BL A8BC0F8N 2 D30=8AB0=5 8 @0:5, => 8 2>AAB0=>28BL 8E :0: 45<>:@0B8G5A:85 3>AC40@AB20? 0 A<5=C A;>682H59AO A8AB5<K <564C=0@>4=>3> ?@020 ?@8E>4OB 70:>=K 46C=3;59, 345 <5@8:0 459AB2C5B :0: A0<K9 <>3CG89 725@L, => 8 A0<K9 A8;L=K9 E8I=8: =5 <>65B A51O GC2AB2>20BL 2 ?>;=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. A;8 ?@57845=B CH0 =5 >A>7=05B, GB> 53> =5>:>=A5@20B82=>5 >:@C65=85 2545B <5@8:C 2 BC?8: 8 =5 2>7L<5B =0 2>>@C65=85 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:CN AB@0B538N, CG8BK20NICN 2>5==CN <>IL, => =5 >B:07K20NICNAO >B 8A?>;L7>20=8O, 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L, <O3:>9 A8;K (M:>=><8G5A:8E, ?>;8B8G5A:8E 8 48?;><0B8G5A:8E @KG03>2 2;8O=8O), B> 5<C 1C45B >G5=L B@C4=> ?>1548BL =0 ?@54AB>OI8E 2 A;54CNI5< 3>4C ?@57845=BA:8E 2K1>@0E. * * * 7 @5G8 3C15@=0B>@0 HB0B0 8@468=8O 0@:0 >@=5@0 (Mark Warner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andall Larsen) > A8E ?>@ C =0A =5B 7025@H5==>9 AB@0B5388 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8, =5 >?@545;5=K ?@8>@8B5BK 8 =5 @07@01>B0=K <5E0=87<K 55 @50;870F88. K @0AAC6405< > 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8, => =0H8 :@C?=59H85 :>=B59=5@=K5 B5@<8=0;K >AB0NBAO CO728<K<8 4;O 459AB289 B5@@>@8AB>2.  2>?@>A =5 2 45=L30E, 0 2 2K1@0==>9 04<8=8AB@0F859 CH0 AB@0B5388. !59G0A 2 2>?@>A0E 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 >=0 459AB2C5B ?>4>1=> 48=>702@C, C :>B>@>3> <=>3> A8;K, => <0;> <>73>2. #G8BK20O 3>@L:89 >?KB 11 A5=BO1@O, =5>1E>48<> A>74020BL 25@B8:0;L=> 8 3>@87>=B0;L=> 8=B53@8@>20==CN :><<C=8:0F8>==CN A8AB5<C, ?>72>;ONICN A>3;0A>20==> 459AB2>20BL 2A5< A;C610<, >15A?5G820NI8< 157>?0A=>ABL 8 687=545OB5;L=>ABL =0A5;5=8O 2 CA;>28OE G@572KG09=KE A8BC0F89. A>15==> 2708<>A2O70==CN A8AB5<C :><<C=8:0F89 <564C <5AB=K<8 A;C610<8 M:AB@5==>3> @5038@>20=8O, =0?@8<5@, ?>60@=K<8 8 D545@0;L=K<8 035=BAB20<8  8=8AB5@AB2>< 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8, $ , 0F8>=0;L=>9 320@4859 8 B.4. #:@5?;5=85 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 O2;O5BAO ;>38G5A:8< >B25B>< =0 =>2K5 2K7>2K 21 25:0, => MB>B ?@>F5AA =8:>8< >1@07>< =5 4>;65= CI5<;OBL =0H8 45<>:@0B8G5A:85 ?@020 8 F5==>AB8. 4=8< 87 206=59H8E M;5<5=B>2 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 >AB05BAO MDD5:B82=0O 8 =0456=0O 45OB5;L=>ABL @07254A>>1I5AB20 !(.  MB>< 2>?@>A5 A2>N @>;L 4>;6=K AK3@0BL ?5@54>2K5 F8D@>2K5 B5E=>;>388, 8A?>;L7C5<K5 B0:, GB>1K =5 =0=>A8BL 2@540 70:>=>?>A;CH=><C 3@0640=8=C. 45AL ?>;>68B5;L=K< <><5=B>< A;54C5B >B<5B8BL A>740=85 548=>3> F5=B@0 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N B5@@>@8AB8G5A:8< C3@>70<, >1J548=82H53> 8 :>>@48=8@CNI53> 459AB28O & # 8 $ . I5 @07 ?>4G5@:=C, =0< =5>1E>48<> A@>G=> 2K@01>B0BL 548=CN, ;>38G5A:8 A2O70==CN AB@0B538N 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 AB@0=K, 345 >?@545;5=K C3@>7K, =0H8 A;01K5 <5AB0 8 :>=:@5B=K5 <5@K, 8 A?>A>1K 70I8BK. =K<8 A;>20<8, =0< =C65= 45B0;L=K9 ?;0= 459AB289 AB@0=K 2 CA;>28OE G@572KG09=KE A8BC0F89 A ?@8<5=5=85< #.  A2O78 A MB8< C<5AB=> C?><O=CBL, GB> ?@8<5@=> 50 <8;;8>=>2 G5;>25: 2 !( =5 >E20G5=> =K=5 459AB2CNI59 A8AB5<>9 74@02>>E@0=5=8O. !>3;0A=> 4>:;04C 35=BAB20 ?> 1>@L15 A =0@:>B8:0<8, 2 AB@0=C 1K;> =5;530;L=> 22575=> 300 B>== :>:08=0, GB> <>6=> @0AA<0B@820BL :0: @07=>284=>ABL 18>;>38G5A:>9 2>9=K.  =B5@=5B5 A2>1>4=> @0A?@>AB@0=ONBAO @5F5?BK A>740=8O 18>;>38G5A:8 >?0A=KE AC1AB0=F89 8 4065 ?@54;0305BAO >1>@C4>20=85 4;O 8E ?@>872>4AB20. "0: GB> =5B =5>1E>48<>AB8 22>78BL 18>;>38G5A:>5 >@C685 87-70 @C1560.  AB@0=5 =0AG8BK205BAO ?@8<5@=> 123 >1J5:B0, 345 @07<5I5=K E8<8G5A:85 ;01>@0B>@88 8;8 ?@>872>4AB20. #A?5H=K9 B5@@>@8AB8G5A:89 0:B =0 ;N1>< 87 =8E <>3 1K ?>2;5GL 70 A>1>9 <8;;8>==K5 65@B2K A@548 3@0640=A:>3> =0A5;5=8O. A;8 65 <K A>18@05<AO A>740BL =0 =0H8E 3@0=8F0E =5:CN ;8=8N 068=> 21 25:0, B> <K A5@L57=> @8A:C5< =0@CH8BL B>@3>2>-M:>=><8G5A:85 A2O78 A 2=5H=8< <8@><. 4=>2@5<5==> <K ?>G5<C-B> ?@54?>G8B05< =5 70<5G0BL ?@>1;5<C =570:>==>9 8<<83@0F88 2 0;8D>@=88, GB> G@520B> A5@L57=K<8 ?>A;54AB28O<8 4;O A>F80;L=KE 8 <548F8=A:8E A;C61 2 A;CG05 2>7=8:=>25=8O G@572KG09=>9 A8BC0F88. #:@5?;OO 2=CB@5==NN 157>?0A=>ABL, A;54C5B 2K1@0BL 7>;>BCN A5@548=C <564C ?>;=>9 ?@>7@0G=>ABLN 3@0=8F 8 01A>;NB=>9 87>;8@>20==>ABLN. 57>?0A=>ABL 0<5@8:0=A:8E 3>@>4>2 -420@4 0@F0 (Ed Garza)  <M@ !0=-=B>=8> >A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O CNN =0720;0 !0=-=B>=8> A0<K< ?>43>B>2;5==K< : G@572KG09=K< A8BC0F8O 3>@>4>< !(. 57>?0A=>ABL 8 70I8B0 3>@>4>2 O2;O5BAO ?@8>@8B5B>< 2 >1I59 AB@0B5388 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8. 45AL 206=> >1@0B8BL 2=8<0=85 =0 B0: A:070BL @538>=0;L=>5 ?0@B=5@AB2> 2 @5H5=88 A8BC0F89 ' 2 >B45;L=KE 3>@>40E. @8 MB>< A;54C5B ?><=8BL, GB> ?@8<5@=> 85% 2A59 3>@>4A:>9 8=D@0AB@C:BC@K 2 AB@0=5 =0E>48BAO 2 G0AB=KE @C:0E. BAN40 2KB5:05B 2>?@>A > A>B@C4=8G5AB25 2 45;5 >15A?5G5=8O 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 <564C >1I5AB25==K< 8 G0AB=K< A5:B>@>< M:>=><8:8 8 C?@02;5=8O. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO A>1AB25==> >1I5AB25==>3> A5:B>@0, B> 2>7=8:05B 2>?@>A MDD5:B82=>3> 2708<>459AB28O <564C D545@0;L=K<8 2;0ABO<8, ?@028B5;LAB2>< HB0B0 8 <5AB=K< A0<>C?@02;5=85<. G5=L 206=>, GB>1K 8 187=5A, 8 3@0640=A:>5 >1I5AB2> ?>=8<0;8 8 CG0AB2>20;8 2 ?@>42865=88 AB@0B5388 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 =0 2A5E C@>2=OE. >B>2K ;8 <K : 18>;>38G5A:>9, E8<8G5A:>9 8;8 O45@=>9 0B0:5 =0 !(? 0@30@5B 0<1C@3 (Margaret A. Gamburg) !53>4=O <K AB>;:=C;8AL A =>2K< 284>< B5@@>@87<0, :>B>@K9 AB@5<8BAO =5 : 4>AB865=8N :0:8E-B> ?>;8B8G5A:8E F5;59, 0 : C=8GB>65=8N :0: <>6=> 1>;LH53> G8A;0 =525@=KE, B.5. 682CI8E 8 <KA;OI8E =5 B0:, :0: >=8, ;N459. 5B A><=5=8O 2 B><, GB>, 5A;8 2 @C:8 ?>?045B E8<8G5A:>5, 18>;>38G5A:>5 8;8 O45@=>5 >@C685, B> >=8 =5 ?@5<8=CB 8< 2>A?>;L7>20BLAO. 0 ?>A;54=85 420 3>40 1K;8 ?@54?@8=OBK A5@L57=K5 CA8;8O 2 A0<KE @07;8G=KE >1;0ABOE, GB>1K 1KBL 3>B>2K< : >B@065=8N MB8E A<5@B>=>A=KE C3@>7. 57CA;>2=>, A53>4=O <K 3>B>2K ;CGH5, G5< 4> 11 A5=BO1@O, => 2A5 65 >AB05<AO CO728<K<8. %>G5BAO ?>4G5@:=CBL, GB>, B0: :0: MB8 B@8 2840 # @07;8G0NBAO ?> E0@0:B5@C 8 >?0A=>AB8 2>7459AB28O, B> 8 AB@0B538O ?@>B82>459AB28O 2 >B=>H5=88 8E 4>;6=0 1KBL 48DD5@5=F8@>20==>9. 081>;55 ?5@A?5:B82=K< A?>A>1>< ?@>B82>459AB28O O45@=><C B5@@>@87<C ?@54AB02;O5BAO MDD5:B82=>5 >15A?5G5=85 157>?0A=>AB8 8 =0456=>3> E@0=5=8O #, 53> :><?>=5=B>2 8 <0B5@80;>2, ?@83>4=KE 4;O 53> 873>B>2;5=8O, :0: 2 !(, B0: 8 2 4@C38E AB@0=0E, >A>15==> 2 >AA88. !>:@0I5=85 >?0A=>AB8 E8<8G5A:>3> B5@@>@87<0 ;568B 2 @0<:0E ?@>3@0<<K ?> C=8GB>65=8N 70?0A>2 E8<8G5A:>3> >@C68O (B>;L:> =0 >4=>< 2>5==>< >1J5:B5 2 >AA88 E@0=8BAO 1,9 <8;;8>=0 E8<8G5A:8E A=0@O4>2) 8 C:@5?;5=8N <5@ 70I8BK >?0A=KE E8<8G5A:8E ?@>872>4AB2 8 8AA;54>20=89. 06=59H59 7040G59 >AB05BAO A>740=85 8=B53@8@>20==>9 A8AB5<K @5038@>20=8O =0 2>7<>6=K5 B5@@>@8AB8G5A:85 0B0:8 A ?@8<5=5=85< #. A>15==> MB> >B=>A8BAO : 18>;>38G5A:><C >@C68N, A0<><C 4>ABC?=><C 87 MB>9 A<5@B>=>A=>9 B@804K.  MB>9 A2O78 >AB05BAO <=>3> 2>?@>A>2 : C@>2=N 3>B>2=>AB8 0<5@8:0=A:>9 A8AB5<K 74@02>>E@0=5=8O ?@>B82>AB>OBL =>2K< 2K7>20<. !;54C5B ?><=8BL, GB> B5@@>@8ABK <>3CB A>25@H8BL 18>;>38G5A:CN 0B0:C 8 =5 =0 ;N459, 0, =0?@8<5@, 2K720BL <0AA>2K9 ?0456 A:>B0 8;8 3815;L C@>60O, GB> G@520B> A5@L57=59H8<8 M:>=><8G5A:8<8 ?>A;54AB28O<8. 0<5GC, GB> ?@>1;5<5 B0: =07K205<>3> A5;LA:>E>7O9AB25==>3> B5@@>@87<0 =5 C45;O5BAO ?>GB8 =8:0:>3> 2=8<0=8O, GB> <>65B >15@=CBLAO 1>;LH8< ?@>20;>< 2 A;CG05 8A?>;L7>20=8O 18>;>38G5A:>3> >@C68O. @02>2K5 >@85=B8@K 2 1>@L15 A @50;L=K<8 B5@@>@8AB0<8 6C;L5BB 09C< (Juliette Kayyem) %>GC >AB0=>28BLAO =0 ?@02>2KE 2>?@>A0E ?@8 >15A?5G5=88 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8. 0:>2K 4>;6=K 1KBL 70:>=K 8 :0: >=8 4>;6=K @50;87>2K20BLAO 2 CA;>28OE D0:B8G5A:>9 2>9=K A <564C=0@>4=K< B5@@>@87<><. @5645 2A53> A;54C5B A>E@0=OBL G5B:89 10;0=A 8=B5@5A>2 <564C =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>ABLN 8 3@0640=A:8<8 ?@020<8 8 A2>1>4>9 G5;>25:0. 59AB28O 04<8=8AB@0F88 CH0 3>2>@OB > B><, GB>, ?> 8E <=5=8N, 745AL =5B =8:0:>9 ?@>1;5<K, 0 ?@8=OB85 42CE B0: =07K205<KE 0B@8>B8G5A:8E 0:B>2 >=8 =07K20NB A8AB5<0B870F859 ACI5AB2CNI8E 70:>=>2. -B>, <O3:> 3>2>@O, =5?@0240. 0?@8<5@, 0B@8>B8G5A:89 0:B II =0@CH05B '5B25@BCN ?>?@02:C >=AB8BCF88, D0:B8G5A:8 ?>72>;OO 2;0ABO< A>18@0BL :>=D845=F80;L=CN 187=5A-8=D>@<0F8N ?CB5< ?@8=C48B5;L=>9 40G8 ?>:070=89. !CI5AB2C5B F5;K9 @O4 4@C38E ?@8<5@>2, B0: 8;8 8=0G5 CI5<;ONI8E 45<>:@0B8G5A:85 A2>1>4K 8 ?@020 G5;>25:0, => A;54C5B ?>4G5@:=CBL, GB> 2A5 MB8 O:>1K 2@5<5==K5 :BK 70 420 3>40 ?@52@0B8;8AL 2 @50;L=> 459AB2CNI89 ?@02>2>9 @568< =0 B5@@8B>@88 !(. >7<>6=>, GB> ?>A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O =5:>B>@>5 C65AB>G5=85 1K;> =5>1E>48<>, :0: 1K;0 8 =5>1E>48<>ABL 2 A>740=88 D8;LB@0F8>==>3> ;035@O 2 C0=B0=><>. (C6=> 1K;> >B45;8BL @50;L=KE B5@@>@8AB>2 >B ?>?02H8EAO ?>4 3>@OGCN @C:C) > A59G0A <K 2848<  B>, GB> :070;>AL 2@5<5==>9 =5>1E>48<>ABLN, ?@52@0I05BAO 2 ?>AB>O==CN 459AB28B5;L=>ABL. @O4 ;8 ;N48, C45@68205<K5 =0 C0=B0=><>, ?@54AB02;ONB 8=B5@5A 4;O 0<5@8:0=A:8E @07254A;C61, B>340 ?>G5<C >=8 =5 ?@54AB0NB ?5@54 AC4><?  =0G02H59AO 2>9=5 A B5@@>@87<>< ?>G5<C-B> 4> A8E ?>@ =5B @50;L=KE B5@@>@8AB>2, ?>4;560I8E AC451=><C =0:070=8N. "5< =5 <5=55, =>2K9 ?@02>2>9 @568< 459AB2C5B, 8 :>3>-B> 0@5AB>2K20NB. (>7<>6=>, 4065 459AB28B5;L=> >?0A=KE B5@@>@8AB>2). > <>5<C <=5=8N, ?@>B82>AB>O=85 B5@@>@87<C 1K;> 1K 1>;55 CA?5H=K<, 5A;8 1K =K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O A>A@54>B>G8;0 CA8;8O =0 A>740=88 8 C:@5?;5=88 =5:>59 <564C=0@>4=>9 :>0;8F88 ?@02>2KE 8 AC451=KE >@30=>2. 'B> 65 :0A05BAO ?>4>BG5B=>AB8 2;0AB8 >1I5AB2C, B> O 2KABC?0N 70 CA8;5=85 :>=B@>;O A> AB>@>=K >=3@5AA0 =04 8=8AB5@AB2>< 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 8 70 CA8;5=85 :>=B@>;O A> AB>@>=K 8=8AB5@AB20 NAB8F88 =04 $ . >2K9 ?@02>2>9 @568< 04<8=8AB@0F88 CH0 8 2 G0AB=>AB8 C65AB>G5=85 8<<83@0F8>==>9 ?>;8B8:8 8 287>2>3> @568<0 ?>H;8 =5 =0 ?>;L7C 70:>=>?>A;CH=K< 3@0640=0<, :0: 0<5@8:0=F0<, B0: 8 8=>AB@0=F0<. 45AL >AB05BAO <=>3> A?>@=KE <><5=B>2. <5@8:5 A;54C5B 2K@01>B0BL 1>;55 A10;0=A8@>20==K9 ?@02>2>9 @568< 8 4>;3>A@>G=CN AB@0B538N 459AB289 ?@02>2KE 8 AC451=KE >@30=>2 2 CA;>28OE 2>9=K A B5@@>@87<><. , CG8BK20O A?5F8D8:C A>2@5<5==>3> B5@@>@87<0, E>GC >1@0B8BL 2=8<0=85, GB> ?>402;ONI55 1>;LH8=AB2> A>B@C4=8:>2 A?5FA;C61 8 ?@02>>E@0=8B5;L=KE >@30=>2  15;K5 <C6G8=K, =5 7=0NI85 :C;LBC@K 8 O7K:0 <CAC;L<0=A:>3> <8@0, GB> 45;05B 8E 45OB5;L=>ABL <5=55 MDD5:B82=>9 8 CA?5H=>9. 7 2KABC?;5=89 =0 A5:F88 ! 5 <5@8:0=A:0O <>IL, 55 2>7<>6=>AB8 8 =5>1E>48<>ABL 87<5=5=89 >=3@5AA<5= 659<A 8G (James A. Leach) 0< ?@54AB>8B >1AC48BL F5;K9 @O4 =5?@>ABKE 2>?@>A>2. 0?@8<5@, A?>A>1=0 ;8 ?>402;ONI0O 2>5==0O <>IL !( 70I8B8BL AB@0=C >B B5@@>@87<0? ;8 405B ;8 ?>402;ONI0O M:>=><8G5A:0O <>IL AB@0=K 30@0=B88 ;>O;L=>AB8 8 4@C61K A> AB>@>=K 4@C38E 3>AC40@AB2, >A>15==> 4>;6=8:>2 <5@8:8?  =5 ?>:07K205B ;8 >?KB @0:0, GB> A0<0O 1>;LH0O ?@>1;5<0 !( =0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L =5 1N465B=K9 45D8F8B 8;8 =0;>3>20O ?>;8B8:0 04<8=8AB@0F88 CH0, 0 0=B03>=87< A> AB>@>=K 1>;LH>9 G0AB8 <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20? 73;O4 2 1C4CI55: 0<5@8:0=A:0O 2>5==0O AB@C:BC@0 8 @0AE>4K =0 >1>@>=C 8H5;L $;5@=>9 (Michele A. Flournoy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ernard E. Trainor)  ?>A;54=85 3>4K 0<5@8:0=A:8< 2>5==K< ?@8H;>AL @5H0BL 7040G8 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, :>B>@K5 >:070;8AL =5 ?> ?;5GC =8 ?>;8B8:0<, =8 48?;><0B0<.  =04> ?@87=0BL, GB> 459AB2>20;8 0<5@8:0=A:85 ! =0 <8@>2>9 0@5=5 25AL<0 MDD5:B82=>, 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L, ?>B><C, GB> D83C@0 8 ?A8E>;>38O ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=>3> 2>5==>3>  O2;5=85 B@0=A=0F8>=0;L=>5. >-2B>@KE, >>@C65==K5 !8;K  >G5=L >@30=87>20==0O 8 E>@>H> C?@02;O5<0O AB@C:BC@0. =8 <>3CB 459AB2>20BL G5@57 <564C=0@>4=K5 2>5==K5 0;LO=AK 8 :>0;8F88, 8A?>;L7CO A>2<5AB=K5 CG5=8O 8 1>52CN ?>43>B>2:C. 0725 <>6=> 1K;> @0=LH5 ?@54AB028BL, =0?@8<5@, >1ICN @01>BC " 8 AB@0=, :>340-B> 2E>482H8E 2 0@H02A:89 4>3>2>@, !( 8 >AA88, 1K2H8E 3;02=KE <8@>2KE >??>=5=B>2. > ACB8, 2>5==K5 CG0AB2CNB 2 @5H5=88 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8E 7040G =0@O4C A 48?;><0B0<8 8 ?>;8B8:0<8 8 ?@8 MB>< :><0=4CNI89 3@C??8@>2:>9 2>9A: 8;8 D;>B><, 70G0ABCN, 8<55B 7=0G8B5;L=> 1>;LH85 @5AC@AK 8 2>7<>6=>AB8, G5< ?@>D8;L=K5 HB0BA:85 3>AC40@AB25==K5 G8=>2=8:8 8 AB@C:BC@K. <5@8:0=A:85 :><0=4CNI85, >B25G0NI85 70 :0:>9-;81> ?>B5=F80;L=K9 " (B50B@ 2>5==KE 459AB289)  MB> A2>53> @>40 0=0;>3 @8<A:8E ?@>:>=AC;>2. > 745AL 2>7=8:05B =5:0O ?@02>20O :>;;878O, B0: :0: A> 2@5<5= ?>O2;5=8O 0:>=0 > =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 >B 1947 3>40 <8@ @048:0;L=> 87<5=8;AO. # =0A 2>7=8:;8 =>2K5 2K7>2K, A2O70==K5 A 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>ABLN 8 B5@@>@87<><. >2K5 @50;88 B@51CNB =>@<0B82=>-?@02>2KE 8 AB@C:BC@=KE 87<5=5=89, :0: 2 70:>=>40B5;LAB25, B0: 8 2 A0<>9 0@<88. 5>1E>48< =>2K9 70:>=, 345 1C45B G5B:> ?@>?8A0=>, GB> 4>;6=0 45;0BL 0@<8O 8 :0: 2708<>459AB2>20BL A 4@C38<8 3>AC40@AB25==K<8 AB@C:BC@0<8 (?@5645 2A53> A >AC40@AB25==K< 45?0@B0<5=B><) ?@8 ?@0:B8G5A:>9 @50;870F88 AB@0B5388 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. !53>4=O 65 2 @0:5 0<5@8:0=A:85 ! 2K?>;=ONB <=>385 =5 A2>9AB25==K5 59 7040G8, ?> ACB8, 45;0O @01>BC 70 4@C385 3@0640=A:85 AB@C:BC@K 8 3>AC40@AB25==K5 8=AB8BCBK. !;54C5B ?><=8BL, GB> 2>9=K 21 25:0 2 :>@=5 >B;8G0NBAO >B :>=D;8:B>2 20-3>. G5284=>, GB> 2 =8E =5 871560BL CG0AB8O 0<5@8:0=A:>9 0@<88, => >=> 1C45B 83@0BL :0G5AB25==> 8=CN @>;L 8 7=0G5=85. 0:A8<0;L=> C25;8G8BL MDD5:B82=>ABL 8 =0456=>ABL =0F8>=0;L=>9 @07254:8 659<A (B59=15@3 (James Steinberg)  28F5-?@57845=B =AB8BCB0 Brookings, 1K2H89 ?><>I=8: A>25B=8:0 ?> =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 ! ?>O2;5=85< =>2KE =5>6840==KE 8 =5>?@545;5==KE C3@>7 2 =0G0;5 21 25:0 @>;L @07254:8 ?@8>1@5;0 8A:;NG8B5;L=>5 7=0G5=85.  A?>@K > B><, A?>A>1=0 ;8 =0H0 =K=5H=OO @07254K20B5;L=0O A8AB5<0 MDD5:B82=> 1>@>BLAO A B5@@>@87<>< 8;8 > B><, 1K;8 8;8 =5 1K; ?@>20; @07254:8 2 @0:5, ;8HL ?>4B25@640NB ?5@2>AB5?5==CN =5>1E>48<>ABL =0;8G8O >?5@0B82=>-459AB2CNI59 8 =0456=>9 @07254:8. > A;>20< >=0;L40 0<AD5;L40, 2> 2@5<5=0 E>;>4=>9 2>9=K =0H8 @07254A;C61K AB@5<8;8AL =09B8 =58725AB=>5 2 8725AB=><. !53>4=O 65 8< ?@8E>48BAO 8<5BL 45;> A =58725AB=>< 2 =58725AB=><. AB>G=8:8 =>2KE C3@>7 =5 8<5NB G5B:>3> <5AB>=0E>645=8O 8 >1;040NB 25AL<0 @07<KBK< E0@0:B5@><. $0:B8G5A:8 <K >G5=L <0;> 7=05< > B5@@>@87<5 8 B5@@>@8AB8G5A:8E >@30=870F8OE. !59G0A B@51C5BAO A>18@0BL 8 >1@010BK20BL 3>@074> 1>;LH5 @072548=D>@<0F88, G5< MB> 1K;>, :>340 =0< ?@>B82>AB>O; 2?>;=5 >?@545;5==K9 ?@>B82=8: 2 ;8F5 !!!  8 @O40 4@C38E 3>AC40@AB2. -B8< 70=8<0;8AL C?>;=><>G5==K5 3>AC40@AB25==K5 AB@C:BC@K A >3@0=8G5==K< :@C3>< ?@>D5AA8>=0;>2. > 2 ?@>B82>AB>O=88 B5@@>@87<C =5HB0B=K< A>B@C4=8:>< >@30=>2 @07254:8 <>65B >:070BLAO 8 ?>;8F59A:89, 8 >E@0==8: G0AB=>9 :><?0=88, 8 <548F8=A:89 @01>B=8:, 8 ?>60@=K9. >>1I5, ?> ACB8 45;0, ;N1>9 70:>=>?>A;CH=K9 3@0640=8=, >1;040NI89 8=D>@<0F859 > 2>7<>6=>< B5@0:B5. =K<8 A;>20<8, 2 1>@L15 A =>2K<8 C3@>70<8 ?@>D5AA8>=0;L=K5 @07254G8:8 8 8E 035=BK =5 <>3CB >1>9B8AL 157 ?><>I8 74@02><KA;OI8E 8 70:>=>?>A;CH=KE ;N459 2 <8@5, :>B>@K5 2 A8;C >1AB>OB5;LAB2 <>3CB >:070BLAO =>A8B5;O<8 ?>;57=>9 8=D>@<0F88.  A>>B25BAB288 A A53>4=OH=8<8 @50;8O<8, =0H5 @07254A>>1I5AB2> B@51C5B >@30=870F8>==>-AB@C:BC@=KE 87<5=5=89 8 2K@01>B:8 =>2>9 AB@0B5388. 7<5=5=8O 4>;6=K 70B@>=CBL =5 B>;L:> ?@>F5AA A1>@0 8=D>@<0F88, => 8 55 0=0;87. <55BAO 2 284C ?@82;5G5=85 3>@074> 1>;55 H8@>:> :@C30 M:A?5@B>2 8 A?5F80;8AB>2 A0<KE =5>6840==KE =0?@02;5=89. @8 MB>< A;54C5B CG8BK20BL 2>?@>AK A5:@5B=>AB8 8 ?@>1;5<C 2>7<>6=>9 CB5G:8 @072548=D>@<0F88. 0H0 =K=5H=OO @07254K20B5;L=0O A8AB5<0 8<55B G5B:>5 @0745;5=85 =0 2=5H=NN 8 2=CB@5==NN @07254:C, GB> 1K;> 2?>;=5 >?@0240==> 2> 2@5<5=0 E>;>4=>9 2>9=K. !53>4=O >=> ?>B5@O;> 2AO:89 A<KA; 8 B>;L:> <5H05B MDD5:B82=><C >1J548=5=8N 8 :>>@48=0F88 2A5E @07254CA8;89 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N =>2K< 2K7>20<.  MB>< 65 :>=B5:AB5 ;568B 8 ?5@5A<>B@ 2708<>>B=>H5=89 <564C @07254A>>1I5AB2>< 8 4@C38<8 ?@02>>E@0=8B5;L=K<8 >@30=0<8, A $  2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L. %>BO $  8 2K?>;=O5B :>=B@@07254K20B5;L=K5 DC=:F88, => 2A5 65 MB> ?@02>>E@0=8B5;L=0O >@30=870F8O, 3;02=>9 7040G59 :>B>@>9 O2;O5BAO ?>8<:0 ?@5ABC?=8:>2 8 ?@5?@>2>645=85 8E 2 AC4. K=5H=85 2K7>2K 2> 3;02C C3;0 AB02OB ?@54>B2@0I5=85 B5@0:B0, 0 =5 AC451=>5 =0:070=85 ?@5ABC?=8:0. #3@>7K 2=CB@5==59 157>?0A=>AB8 8 ?@>1;5<K, 2>7=8:H85 ?5@54 :>=B@@07254:>9, =5 <>3CB 1KBL MDD5:B82=> @5H5=K 157 >@30=870F8>==>-AB@C:BC@=KE 87<5=5=89 =0F8>=0;L=>9 @07254K20B5;L=>9 A8AB5<K 8 2=54@5=8O =>2>9 AB@0B5388 459AB289. @8 MB>< =5>1E>48<> AB@>3>5 A>1;N45=85 10;0=A0 <564C ?>2KH5=85< MDD5:B82=>AB8 8 =0456=>AB8 @07254:8 8 AB@>38< A>1;N45=85< 3@0640=A:8E ?@02 8 A2>1>4. 0: ?>:070; >?KB @0:0, ACI5AB2C5B 5I5 >4=0 ?@>1;5<0, A2O70==0O A 2708<>459AB285< 8 2708<>>B=>H5=8O<8 <564C @07254A>>1I5AB2>< 8 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 2;0ABLN. 5 A;54C5B 8A?>;L7>20BL @07254:C 2 :0G5AB25 @07<5==>9 <>=5BK 4;O 4>AB865=8O A2>8E ?>;8B8G5A:8E F5;59. 0H0 @07254:0 D0:B8G5A:8 1K;0 A>740=0 2 1947 3>4C. 04> ?@87=0BL, GB> A B5E ?>@ <8@ @078B5;L=> 87<5=8;AO, 0 MB> B@51C5B :0@48=0;L=KE 87<5=5=89 2 ?@8=F8?0E @01>BK 8 2 A0<>9 845>;>388 =0H59 @07254K20B5;L=>9 A8AB5<K. 0: 1>;55 MDD5:B82=> ?@>B82>AB>OBL B5@@>@87<C M=4 8@A (Rand Beers)  !>25B=8: ?> 2>?@>A0< =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 A5=0B>@0 5@@8, 4>;3>5 2@5<O @01>B0; 2 !>25B5 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8 0 A53>4=OH=89 45=L C !( >BACBAB2C5B 4>;3>A@>G=0O ?@>3@0<<0 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<><. >B >A=>2=K5 ?OBL ?@8=F8?>2 8 :;NG52K5 A5<L M;5<5=B>2, =0 :>B>@KE 1078@C5BAO AB@0B538O 2>9=K A B5@@>@87<><. 5@2K< O2;O5BAO G5B:>5 ?>=8<0=85 B>3>, GB> MB0 1>@L10 <>65B @0ABO=CBLAO =0 4>;385-4>;385 3>4K. 7 MB>3> 2KB5:05B 2B>@>9 ?@8=F8? =5>1E>48<>AB8 ?>445@6:8 CA8;89 3>AC40@AB20 A> AB>@>=K >1I5AB20, :0: MB> 1K;> 2 ?5@8>4 E>;>4=>9 2>9=K, 2?;>BL 4> ?045=8O :><<C=87<0. "@5BL8< O2;O5BAO A>740=85 A8AB5<K 3>AC40@AB25==KE 8 =53>AC40@AB25==KE 8=AB8BCB>2 (B0:8E :0: &5=B@ 70 ?@>3@5AA <5@8:8). >B>@K5 1C4CB 70=8<0BLAO MB>9 ?@>1;5<0B8:>9 =0 ?>AB>O==>9 >A=>25, =57028A8<> >B B>3>, :0:0O ?0@B8O A53>4=O C @C;O ?@02;5=8O. '5B25@BK< ?@8=F8?>< 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<>< O2;O5BAO <=>3>AB>@>==89 ?>4E>4 2=CB@8 AB@0=K 8 8=B5@=0F8>=0;L=K9 ?>4E>4 2 <8@5. (K 4>;6=K 25@=CBLAO : A>2<5AB=K< CA8;8O< 2 @0<:0E ). , =0:>=5F, <K 4>;6=K ?><=8BL, GB> 2>9=0 A B5@@>@87<><  MB> =5 :@0B:>A@>G=K9 =>2K9 :@5AB>2K9 ?>E>4, 0 4>;3>A@>G=K5 ?>AB>O==K5 CA8;8O 2A53> <8@>2>3> A>>1I5AB20, 2:;NG0O <CAC;L<0=A:85 AB@0=K. "5?5@L > :;NG52KE M;5<5=B0E 2 1>@L15 A B5@@>@87<><, ?5@2K< 87 :>B>@KE O2;O5BAO =59B@0;870F8O ;845@>2 ;L 094K 8 @07@CH5=85 55 <564C=0@>4=>9 A5B8. >=5G=>, ?@8 MB>< =5 A;54C5B 701K20BL 8 > 4@C38E B5@@>@8AB8G5A:8E >@30=870F8OE 8 A>?@8:0A0NI59AO A =8<8 <564C=0@>4=>9 >@30=87>20==>9 ?@5ABC?=>AB8 2 2845 =0@:><0D88. B>@>9 M;5<5=B  ;8H5=85 B5@@>@8AB>2 8E C1568I 2 3>AC40@AB20E 8E ?>:@K20NI8E. ?KB D30=8AB0=0 8 @0:0 ?>:07K205B, GB> A<5=0 @568<0 =5 ?@82>48B : =5<54;5==><C 8AG57=>25=8N B5@@>@87<0. "@51C5BAO 4>;30O @01>B0 ?> @5018;8B0F88 8 2>AAB0=>2;5=8N AB@0=K. "@5BL8< M;5<5=B>< ?@54AB02;O5BAO ;8H5=85 B5@@>@8AB>2 <564C=0@>4=>9 D8=0=A>2>9 ?>4?8B:8. '5B25@B0O A>AB02;ONI0O CA?5E0  MDD5:B82=0O =0F8>=0;L=0O A8AB5<0 @07254:8, B5A=> A>B@C4=8G0NI0O A <564C=0@>4=K< @07254A>>1I5AB2>< 8 4@C38<8 ?@02>>E@0=8B5;L=K<8 >@30=0<8, :0: 2=CB@8 AB@0=K, B0: 8 70 @C156><. OBK< M;5<5=B>< AB@0B5388 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<>< O2;O5BAO >ACH5=85 8AB>G=8:>2 ?>?>;=5=8O @O4>2 2>8=>2 468E040, B.5. ?@>1;5<0 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O <54@5A5, 345 ?@>?030=48@CNBAO @048:0;L=K5 D>@<K A;0<0, 0 B0:65 1>;55 H8@>:89 2>?@>A CAB0=>2;5=8O <8@0 =0 2A5< ;86=5< >AB>:5. (>9=0 2A5340 ?>@>6405B =>2KE 2>;>=B5@>2). (5ABK<, 8 2 B> 65 2@5<O >B?@02=K< M;5<5=B>< 2 1>@L15 A B5@@>@87<>< O2;O5BAO ?@>3@0<<0 >F5=:8 =0F8>=0;L=KE C3@>7 8 @07@01>B:0 A>>B25BAB2CNI59 4>;3>A@>G=>9 AB@0B5388 ?> ?@>B82>459AB28N , =0:>=5F, 254O 2>9=C A B5@@>@87<>< 8 =0E>4OAL, ?> ACB8, 2 CA;>28OE ', <K =5 4>;6=K =0=5AB8 CI5@1 =0H8< 45<>:@0B8G5A:8< F5==>ABO< 8 CI5<8BL 3@0640=A:85 ?@020 70:>=>?>A;CH=KE 3@0640=. * * * 7 2KABC?;5=8O A5=0B>@0 '0:0 %035;0 (Chuck Hagel) K1>@K 2004 3>40 1C4CB =5 B>;L:> ?5@2K<8 ?@57845=BA:8<8 2K1>@0<8 ?>A;5 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O, >=8 D0:B8G5A:8 >?@545;OB 25:B>@ @0728B8O 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 !(, 2:;NG0O =0F8>=0;L=CN 157>?0A=>ABL, 35>?>;8B8G5A:85 8 M:>=><8G5A:85 8=B5@5AK 8 <564C=0@>4=K5 >B=>H5=8O. 8@ AB>8B =0 ?>@>35 4@0<0B8G5A:8E ?5@5<5=, 8 =0 <5@8:C, >:0702HCNAO 2 C=8:0;L=>< ?>;>65=88 548=AB25==>9 A25@E45@602K, 2>7;0305BAO A0<0O 1>;LH0O >B25BAB25==>ABL 70 2K1>@ =0?@02;5=8O 42865=8O 2 1C4CI5<. !?>@K > B><, :0: 459AB2>20BL 2 87<5=82H5<AO ?>A;5 >:>=G0=8O E>;>4=>9 2>9=K 8 B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O <8@5 =>AOB =5 ?@>AB> =0CG=>-B5>@5B8G5A:89 E0@0:B5@, 0 1C4CB 8<5BL 40;5:> 84CI85 ?>A;54AB28O, :0: 4;O AC4L1K <5@8:8, B0: 8 4;O 2A53> <8@0 2 F5;><.  >A=>2=>< @07=>3;0A8O 2>7=8:;8 ?> 2>?@>A0< ?>;57=>AB8 8;8 15A?>;57=>AB8 0;LO=A>2 8 <564C=0@>4=KE 8=AB8BCB>2, > ?@525=B82=>< ?@8<5=5=88 2>5==>9 A8;K, > ?@8>@8B5B0E <564C 45<>:@0B8G5A:8<8 F5==>ABO<8 8 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8< :C@A><, 8 B.4. >A;5 11 A5=BO1@O 2A5 <K 2ABC?8;8 2 =>2CN M?>EC, ?>;=CN =5?@542845==KE 8 =5>?@545;5==KE C3@>7 8 >?0A=>AB59. > <=>38E AB@0=0E D@8:8, 788, 0B8=A:>9 <5@8:8 8 =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5 ?@02OB @5?@5AA82=K5 8 45A?>B8G=K5 @568<K, 0 =0@>4 ?@>7O105B 2 =8I5B5 8 15A?@0288, AB@040O >B 3>;>40, 2=CB@5==8E 2>>@C65==KE :>=D;8:B>2 8 E@>=8G5A:8E 1>;57=59. >4>1=0O A8BC0F8O >BG0O=8O 8 >BACBAB28O =04564K O2;O5BAO 1;03>40B=>9 ?>G2>9 4;O 70@>645=8O @048:0;L=KE ?>;8B8G5A:8E B5G5=89 8 ?>O2;5=8O M:AB@5<8ABA:8 =0AB@>5==KE ;845@>2, >B:C40 >48= H03 4> 2>7=8:=>25=8O B5@@>@87<0. "5@<8= 2>9=0 A B5@@>@87<>< =5 A>2A5< 045:20B=> 8 ?>;=> >B@0605B :><?;5:A C3@>7, A :>B>@K<8 <K AB>;:=C;8AL.  MB>9 1>@L15 ?@8=8<0NB CG0AB85 =5 B>;L:> !, A?5FA;C61K 8 ?@02>>E@0=8B5;L=K5 >@30=K. =0 =5 <>65B 1KBL >B45;5=0 >B =0H59 M:>=><8G5A:>9, M=5@35B8G5A:>9 8 2=5H=5B>@3>2>9 AB@0B5388, CG8BK20NI59 C3@>7C B5@@>@87<0. A5 MB8 CA8;8O 4>;6=K 1KBL A8=B578@>20=K 2 548=CN 8 4>;3>A@>G=CN 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:CN AB@0B538N !( 2 21 25:5. %>GC ?@54;>68BL =0 @0AA<>B@5=85 :>=D5@5=F88 =5A:>;L:> :>=:@5B=KE =0?@02;5=89 @0728B8O =>2>9 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388 <5@8:8: !>740=85 0;LO=A>2 8 A>N7>2; >;8B8:0 2 >1;0AB8 2>5==>3> AB@>8B5;LAB20 8 ?C1;8G=0O 48?;><0B8O: -=5@35B8G5A:0O 157>?0A=>ABL 8 <8@>20O M:>=><8:0. @>B82>459AB285 B5@@>@87<C, ?@54>B2@0I5=85 @0A?@>AB@0=5=8O #, @07@5H5=85 @538>=0;L=KE :>=D;8:B>2, 1>@L10 A 154=>ABLN 8 1>;57=O<8, =>AOI8<8 M?845<8G5A:89 E0@0:B5@  2A5 MB> ?@>1;5<K, :>B>@K5 AB>OB =5 B>;L:> ?5@54 <5@8:>9, => 8 ?5@54 2A5< <564C=0@>4=K< A>>1I5AB2><. >B ?>G5<C A;54C5B =5 B>;L:> C:@5?;OBL, => 8 A>74020BL =>2K5 A>N7K 8 0;LO=AK, A?>A>1=K5 1>;55 MDD5:B82=> 1>@>BLAO A MB8<8 C3@>70<8 3;>10;L=>3> E0@0:B5@0. <5@8:0, :0: 1K =8 1K;0 A8;L=0, =5 A<>65B ?0@8@>20BL 2A5 2K7>2K A>2@5<5==>AB8 2 >48=>G:C. !>740=85 <=>3>=0F8>=0;L=KE 0;LO=A>2 8 <564C=0@>4=KE 8=AB8BCB>2 4>;6=> AB0BL :@05C3>;L=K< :0<=5< 0<5@8:0=A:>9 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B5388. (@8 MB>< <K @0AA<0B@8205< B0:85 459AB28O :0: C:@5?;5=85 8 @0AH8@5=85 0<5@8:0=A:>3> 2;8O=8O, 0 =5 :0: H038, ?@82>4OI85 : >3@0=8G5=8N =0H59 <>I8). 5GL 845B > 4>;3>A@>G=KE AB@0B538G5A:8E A>N70E, 0 =5 > A8BC0F8>==KE :>0;8F8OE, ?@84C<0==KE 04<8=8AB@0F859 CH0. 0: A?@0254;82> 70<5B8; 8725AB=K9 ?>;8B>;>3 87 0@20@4A:>3> C=825@A8B5B0 6>75D 09 (Joseph Nye), ?@>1;5<0 2 B><, GB> =K=5H=OO ?>;8B8G5A:0O A8BC0F8O 87<5=O5BAO B0:8< >1@07><, GB> 45;05B =52>7<>6=K< 4>AB865=85 A2>8E 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8E F5;59 4;O A0<>9 <>I=>9 <8@>2>9 45@602K  !(  2 >48=>G:C. !>740=85 MDD5:B82=KE 8 CAB>9G82KE A>N7>2 8 0;LO=A>2 ?>4@07C<5205B C2065=85 8=B5@5A>2 AB@0=-CG0AB=8F, 0 =5 <5=B>@A:>3> 8 =04<5==>3> ?>2545=8O, :>B>@>5 G0AB> 4>?CA:05B =K=5H=OO 0<5@8:0=A:0O 04<8=8AB@0F88. <5@8:0 4>;6=0 1>;55 B>G=> >?@545;8BLAO 2 A2>8E >B=>H5=8OE A >AA859 8 8B05<, B0: :0: >B B>3>, :0: 8 2 :0:>< =0?@02;5=88 >=8 1C4CB @072820BLAO, 2> <=>3>< 1C45B 7028A5BL 8 A8BC0F8O 2 <8@5. K 4>;6=K 1KBL =5 A>?5@=8:0<8, 0 ?0@B=5@0<8, 2<5AB5 C:@5?;ONI8<8 <564C=0@>4=CN AB018;L=>ABL. 8B09 <>65B 1KBL 25AL<0 ?>;575= 2 @07@5H5=88 ?@>1;5<K !525@=>9 >@58, 0 >AA8O  2 A?>@0E A @0=><. K 4>;6=K @01>B0BL 2<5AB5, 0 =0;8G85 >1I8E 8=B5@5A>2 ?><>65B ?@5>4>;5BL ACI5AB2CNI85 @07=>3;0A8O 8 ?@>B82>@5G8O, :>B>@K5, >G5284=>, 1C4CB 2>7=8:0BL 8 2 1C4CI5<. >9=C A B5@@>@87<>< =52>7<>6=> 2K83@0BL A ?><>ILN 0@<88, :>B>@0O, :0: ?>:070; >?KB 0;:0=, D30=8AB0=0 8 @0:0, A0<0 B>3> 3;O48 ?5@5=0?@O65BAO 8 =04;><8BAO. <55BAO 2 284C 2A5 1>;LH0O 8 1>;LH0O 2>2;5G5==>ABL @575@28AB>2 8 0F8>=0;L=>9 320@488, GB> =530B82=> A:07K205BAO =0 8E :><?;5:B>20=88 8 A>E@0=5=88 C65 8<5NI53>AO ;8G=>3> A>AB020. 0 3>@87>=B5 <0OG8B 2>?@>A > 2>7<>6=>AB8 8<5BL 2>5==CN AB@C:BC@C, 459AB2CNICN B>;L:> =0 :>=B@0:B=>9 >A=>25. 0< C65 A53>4=O =5>1E>48<> C25;8G8BL 459AB2CNICN 2 @0:5 3@C??8@>2:C ?@8<5@=> =0 10 BKAOG G5;>25:. > A;>20< A0<>3> <8=8AB@0 >1>@>=K !( >=0;L40 0<AD5;L40, AB@C:BC@0 =0H8E !, 8E 1>520O ?>43>B>2:0 8 2>>@C65=85 ?@54=07=0G5=K 4;O 2>9=K A 0@<8O<8, D;>B>< 8 2>74CH=K<8 A8;0<8 ?@>B82=8:0. ;O 2>9=K A B5@@>@87<>< B@51CNBAO @048:0;L=K5 87<5=5=8O, :>B>@K5 =52>7<>6=> 1K;> ?@>8725AB8 70 AB>;L :>@>B:89 A@>:. @><5 B>3>, 0<AD5;L4 B>65 2KA:07K205BAO 70 =5>1E>48<>ABL @07@01>B:8 4>;3>A@>G=>9 AB@0B5388 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<><, :>B>@0O ?>;030;0AL 1K =5 B>;L:> =0 ?@8<5=5=85 2>5==>9 A8;K. !53>4=O =5>1E>48<> A@>G=> 2>AAB0=>28BL ?>78B82=K9 8<846 <5@8:8 8 25@=CBL 4>25@85 : 55 ?>;8B8:5 A> AB>@>=K <564C=0@>4=>3> A>>1I5AB20. 8@ =5 <>65B 2>A?@8=8<0BL <>IL !( B>;L:> G5@57 ?@87<C ?@52>AE>4AB20 =0H8E !.  ?5@2CN >G5@54L, 4@C7LO 8 A>N7=8:8 4>;6=K ?@87=020BL =0H5 <>@0;L=>5 ;845@AB2>, >A=>20==>5 =0 AB@5<;5=88 : 45<>:@0B88, AB018;L=>AB8 8 ?@>F25B0=8N 2> 2A5< <8@5. > <=5=8N <8B@8O !09<A0, ?@57845=B0 &5=B@0 8:A>=0, :C;LBC@0 8 F828;870F8O, =02O70==K5 A ?><>ILN <5G0, =5 <>3CB 2>A?@8=8<0BLAO A 1;03>40@=>ABLN.  A>60;5=8N, =K=5H=OO 04<8=8AB@0F8O C45;O5B <0;> 2=8<0=8O B0: =07K205<>9 ?C1;8G=>9 48?;><0B88 (=0?@8<5@, ?@>3@0<<K >1<5=0 ABC45=B0<8 8 CG5=K<8 8 2>7<>6=>ABL AB068@>2:8 2 !(), :>B>@0O ?>72>;O5B 702>52K20BL =>2KE 4@C759 8 AB>@>==8:>2 70 @C156>< 8 7=0G8B5;L=> A=878BL 0=B80<5@8:0=A:85 =0AB@>5=8O. >9=0 A B5@@>@87<>< =5 <>65B 70AB028BL =0A ?@52@0B8BLAO 2 =0F8N, :>B>@0O >B3>@>48;0AL >B >AB0;L=>3> <8@0 2KA>G5==K< 701>@>< A :>;NG59 ?@>2>;>:>9, GB> <K, ?> ACB8, 8 45;05<, G@57<5@=> C65AB>G0O 287>2K9 @568<. /2;OOAL A0<>9 <>I=>9 45@602>9, <5@8:5 A;54C5B ?@>O2;OBL =5 B>;L:> A8;C, => 8 3C<0==>ABL 2 >B=>H5=88 A >AB0;L=K< <8@><. !@548 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8E ?@8>@8B5B>2 !( =5 ?>A;54=55 <5AB> 70=8<0NB M:>=><8G5A:0O 8 M=5@35B8G5A:0O 157>?0A=>ABL AB@0=K. >2>@O > 2>?@>A0E M=5@35B8G5A:>9 157>?0A=>AB8, =5:>B>@K5 22>4OB ?>=OB85 M=5@35B8G5A:0O =57028A8<>ABL. > ?>4>1=>5 =52>7<>6=>. 0?@>B82, @5GL <>65B 84B8 >1 M=5@35B8G5A:>9 2708<>7028A8<>AB8 <564C C3@>70<8 =0F8>=0;L=>9 M=5@35B8G5A:>9 157>?0A=>AB8 8 =0H59 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:>9 AB@0B53859. >4 M=5@35B8G5A:>9 157>?0A=>ABLN <K ?>=8<05< 2>7<>6=>ABL A2>1>4=> ?>:C?0BL, ?> @07C<=K< F5=0<, AK@CN =5DBL 8 ?@8@>4=K9 307 =0 <564C=0@>4=>< @K=:5. , CG8BK20O =5AB018;L=CN A8BC0F8N 2> <=>38E AB@0=0E-M:A?>@B5@0E C3;52>4>@>4=>3> AK@LO, <5@8:5 A;54C5B 4825@A8D8F8@>20BL 8AB>G=8:8 53> ?>;CG5=8O. 0@0;;5;L=> =5>1E>48<> =0@0I820BL CA8;8O (?@82;5:0O : MB><C <564C=0@>4=>5 A>>1I5AB2>) ?> ?@>42865=8N 45<>:@0B88 8 AB018;L=>AB8 2 @538>=0E, >B:C40 2 >A=>2=>< 8 8<?>@B8@CNBAO =5DBL 8 307. ( ?5@2CN >G5@54L, ;86=89 >AB>:, 0B8=A:0O <5@8:0 8 D@8:0). 'B> 65 :0A05BAO ?@8@>4=>3> 3070, F5=K =0 :>B>@K9 <5=55 ?>425@65=K 2;8O=8N ?>;8B8G5A:>9 :>=JN=:BC@K, B> 745AL 1>;LH8< 2K7>2>< ?@54AB02;O5BAO =5045:20B=0O M:>=><8G5A:0O 8=D@0AB@C:BC@0 (307>?5@5:0G820NI85 B5@<8=0;K, 702>4K ?> A6865=8N 3070 8 2=CB@5==85 307>?@>2>4K, 2 ?5@2CN >G5@54L). =5H=5?>;8B8G5A:0O AB@0B538O !( 4>;6=0 A>>B25BAB2>20BL A53>4=OH=8< @50;8O< 8 B@51>20=8O< <8@>2>9 M:>=><8:8, 3;02=K< 87 :>B>@KE O2;O5BAO A2>1>4=0O B>@3>2;O. /2;OOAL AB@0=>9 A A0<>9 1>;LH>9 8 =081>;55 48=0<8G=>9 M:>=><8:>9, <5@8:0 4>;6=0 A>E@0=8BL 70 A>1>9 8 ?5@54>2K5 ?>78F88 2 <564C=0@>4=>9 B>@3>2;5, 0 =5 70=8<0BLAO =5>?@0240==K<8 A?>@0<8 2 ". 5AB:85 ?@>B5:F8>=8ABA:85 <5@K, >4=>AB>@>==85 M:>=><8G5A:85 A0=:F88 8 B>@3>2K5 10@L5@K 2@O4 ;8 A?>A>1=K A45;0BL =0HC M:>=><8:C 1>;55 :>=:C@5=B>A?>A>1=>9 =0 <8@>2KE @K=:0E. 0< =5 =C6=> 1>OBLAO ?@>8AE>4OI8E 2 <8@5 ?5@5<5=. 0?@>B82, <5@8:0 4>;6=0 8 <>65B 2AB0BL 2> 3;025 42865=8O : A?@0254;82><C 8 ?@>F25B0NI5<C <8@>?>@O4:C. K A8;L=0O =0F8O, >1J548=O5<0O 2KA>:>9 4CE>2=>ABLN 8 25@>9. <5@8:0 2?>;=5 <>65B 4>AB8GL 2 21 25:5 CA?5E0 2 @50;870F88 A2>8E 2=5H=5?>;8B8G5A:8E 7040G, 5A;8: @87=05B, GB> 2AO:0O A8;0 8<55B A2>8 ?@545;K, 0 A ?><>ILN B>;L:> 2>5==>9 <>I8 =5;L7O ?0@8@>20BL 2A5 2K7>2K A>2@5<5==>AB8. >945B ?> ?CB8 @0745;5=8O >B25BAB25==>AB8 8 A>740=8O 4>;3>A@>G=KE AB@0B538G5A:8E 0;LO=A>2, 2 :>B>@KE ?@87=0NBAO 8 C2060NBAO 8=B5@5AK 2A5E CG0AB=8:>2. 07@01>B05B 1>;55 A10;0=A8@>20==CN ?>;8B8:C, A CG5B>< =5 B>;L:> =K=5H=8E @50;89, => 8 1C4CI59 ?5@A?5:B82K @0728B8O <8@0. * * * 0:;NG8B5;L=0O @5<0@:0 6>=0 >45ABK 0 MB>9 :>=D5@5=F88 A>1@0;8AL 8 2KABC?0;8 ;N48, :>B>@K5 ;8G=> =5<0;> A45;0;8 4;O <5@8:8, 2 B>< G8A;5 8 ?@8 @07@5H5=88 @0:5B=>3> :@878A0 =0 C15, 8 ?@8 ?>43>B>2:5 8 ?>4?8A0=88 !>3;0H5=8O 2 M<?-M2845, 8 2 ?@>F5AA5 =>@<0;870F88 >B=>H5=89 A  , 8 2> 2@5<O 5@2>9 2>9=K 2 0;825, 8 ?@8 @07@5H5=88 !525@>-:>@59A:>3> :@878A0 1994 3>40, 8 ?@8 @07@5H5=88 :@878A0 <564C   8 "0920=5< 2 =0G0;5 90-E 3>4>2, 2> 2@5<O D8=0=A>2KE :@878A>2 2 788 8 5:A8:5, 2 ?5@8>4 2>AAB0=>2;5=8O >A=88, 8 B.4. 8 B.?. 4=8< A;>2><, 2A5 MB> <=>3>>?KB=K5 ;N48, 8<5NI85 >?KB @07@5H5=8O A0<KE @07=>>1@07=KE :>=D;8:B>2 8 <564C=0@>4=KE ?@>1;5< 48?;><0B8G5A:8< ?CB5<, 0 =5 B>;L:> A ?><>ILN BC?>3> ?@8<5=5=8O 2>5==>9 A8;K. >;030N, GB> 8E A>25BK 8 @5:><5=40F88 1K;8 1K >G5=L ?>;57=K ?@8 @07@01>B:5 =>2>9 AB@0B5388 157>?0A=>AB8 8 <8@0, 2 :>B>@>9 B0: >AB@> =C6405BAO A53>4=OH=OO <5@8:0. PAGE  PAGE 4 2@ 2!*CJ mH 5CJmHCJmH 56CJ 56CJ mH 5CJ$mH5>*CJmH 5>*CJI z | d f H J $$$ z | d f H J ln !!8$:$$$&&''**++--$-&---..//00z3|3@6B6:8<899;;==@@~AADDFFHHKK4M6MtNvNQQRRSS Seln !!8$:$$$&&''**++--$-$$$-&---..//00z3|3@6B6:8<899;;==@@~AADDFF$$FHHKK4M6MtNvNQQRRSS SDSFSHST ThUxXzXYY\\6^8^$$ SDSFSHST ThUxXzXYY\\6^8^__``bbddeengpgvjxjzj|jjjPlRlnnppsshvjv&x(x4y6y${&{}}~~fhJLNȒʒbd~DFz|^`Jd8^__``bbddeengpgvjxjzj|jjjPlRlnnppsshvjv&x$$&x(x4y6y${&{}}~~fhJLN$$Ȓʒbd~DFz|^`J$$JLܪުЫҫfh02޴8:tv<>XZFHBDvx$&(*HJ02xzjl"$2446eJLܪުЫҫfh02޴8:tv$$v<>XZFHBDvx$$$&(*HJ02xzjl"$$$2446dfnp>@DFtvdfz|~$$dfnp>@DFtvdfz|~rtvxdfd f hjVXnpz|z|  !!# ### & &&&@&B&&&((H*J***+,,..p1    a~rtvxdfd f hjVX$$Xnpz|z|  !!$$j| *.|&B&&7X889JEEE FSSS$_&_`|r~t~؄ڄfZ*!*""":,;\;;B C^C*CJ mH 5CJ$mHCJmHM!# ### & &&&@&B&&&((H*J***+,,..p1r1n5p57$ & F$$p1r1n5p5777V8X899;;`?b?@@AAvCxCFEHEJEEE F FGGJJhLjLOOQQSSSSSSS0U2U>V@V>X@XtYvY[[__$_&_``aaJdLdeefghgnipikkmm4o6oq q t"tuuuuNz||r~t~؄ڄvxc777V8X899;;`?b?@@AAvCxCFEHEJEEE F FGGJJhLjL$$jLOOQQSSSSSSS0U2U>V@V>X@XtYvY[[__$_&_``aa$$aJdLdeefghgnipikkmm4o6oq q t"tuuuuNz||r~t~$؄ڄvx,.ʏ̏fhNPҚԚ(*$&$x,.ʏ̏fhNPҚԚ(*$&\^ RTXZ<>Z\:<vxzdf  fh68fhrt68ln^`~    `&\^ RTXZ<>Z\:$h$ & F$:<vxzdf  fh68fh$$rt68ln^`~:<$~:<~ TVvx(*fh  .0(*fh!!!!!!!!("*"""""##>&@&**r+t+..<1>1@2B23385:56699::::*;,;;;\<e~ TVvx(*fh$$h  .0(*fh!!!!!!!!("*""$$""""##>&@&**r+t+..<1>1@2B23385:56699::::$$:*;,;;;\<^<?@bAdA|B~BBBBB CC\C^C E EFF@IBINKPK$$\<^<?@bAdA|B~BBBBB CC\C^C E EFF@IBINKPKjMlM*O,O"P$P8S:S*CJ mHCJmH)vx :<ԙ֙*,,. $$JL"$@BԲֲµhjlnprιй$$vxnpZ\rttv$$ ^`8:R8:XZ@Bxz$ & F$^`8:R8:XZ@Bxz  :<   L N     dfJL&(              Xz  :<   L N $N     dfJL&($$h$ & F$ h&`#$$$   $&P1F/ =!"#$n% [2@2 1KG=K9_HmH sH tH:A@: A=>2=>9 H@8DB 0170F0B @B 86=89 :>;>=B8BC;  E$,)@, ><5@ AB@0=8FK2U@2 8?5@AAK;:0 >*B*phLB@"L A=>2=>9 B5:AB$a$5CJ\aJmHsHVP@2V A=>2=>9 B5:AB 2$a$56CJ\]aJmHsHJQ@BJ A=>2=>9 B5:AB 3$a$CJaJmHsH  jxp $-F8^&xJv~X!7jLa&:h":PKbtvzN   SJp1x~\<X^  !!>F  ( ( ((((($(((((333$3%3)3*3233393M3Z3q3t3u3{3}3333334 4 444444 4&466e@s@_ChCjCoCpCzCCCCCCCCCCCGGJJJJJJJJJJWW]W^WcWWWXX.Y5Y6Y;Y>YEY______ccEeLeffffh h"h(h)h1hrh|h}hhhhFݠ?M djlrv{}]e|eoptYkekS\]aev @G ''''''^,h,A-K-C3F3H3M3Q3V35555557788iAvAD%D'D.D2D9DLLLLLLNNUUZZZZZZ9[>[``eeeeeeeekk}rrrrxx{{cn!j" # u  "6P S$V$---..g1s1@@E@AAN^c^ilvlՈwD'.BERSŶζz$6FL:Mv|Du{<4 &Q^((,,03P3Q3W3Q5]5555:6g:s:`<l<@@D1DDDGGNO(O)OQR&S*S:bc||!0@C18= AlexanderA:\!5:F8O ! 1.doc Alexander*C:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.doc AlexanderNC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.asd AlexanderNC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.asd AlexanderNC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.asd AlexanderA:\NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.doc AlexanderA:\NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.doc#####*C:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\NEWAMERICANSTRATEGIES.docra 'zF2B8@Nؾ z<h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh  ^ `OJQJo(hHh[[^[`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh++^+`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hHh ^`hH.h ^`hH.h pLp^p`LhH.h @ @ ^@ `hH.h ^`hH.h L^`LhH.h ^`hH.h ^`hH.h PLP^P`LhH.h^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohpp^p`OJQJo(hHh@ @ ^@ `OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHoh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJo(hHh^`OJQJ^Jo(hHohPP^P`OJQJo(hHra NF2B z@XCr@G @@@@@8@G:Times New Roman5Symbol3& :Arial?5 :Courier New;Wingdings"qh{{AI9F";Q!d20d6==>B0F8O A 0=3;89A:>3>0@C18=##### Oh+'0|  8 D P\dlt  Normal.dot #####.d5##Microsoft Word 8.0@Ɣ @0@8-I9F ՜.+,D՜.+,L hp  home8j    6> _PID_GUIDAN{D4DE5C21-21B1-11D8-8FDE-0050BFE645DC}  !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~      !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F@ {>1TableB#WordDocument&SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjjObjectPool {> {>  F Microsoft Word MSWordDocWord.Document.89q