ࡱ> [ Pbjbj& jj{lVVVVVVVj8,jTT"vvvvvv&(((((($  \L9VvvvvvLVVvvvVvVv&v&HVVvH `jnDZ$0  jjVVVV ',/ ? 24 <0@B0 2003 3. 6C@=0; <5@8:0=A:89 :>=A5@20B>@ >?C1;8:>20; AB0BLN 0B@8:0 .LN:5=5=0 'LO 2>9=0? A ?@8<5G0B5;L=K< ?>4703>;>2:><  5>:>=A5@20B82=0O :;8:0 AB@5<8BAO 702;5GL =0HC AB@0=C 2 A5@8N 2>9=, :>B>@K5 1C4CB 25AB8AL =5 2 0<5@8:0=A:8E 8=B5@5A0E.  =59 02B>@ CB25@6405B, GB> A53>4=O <5@8:0 AB>8B ?5@54 206=K< @5H5=85<  =0G8=0BL ;8 59 A5@8N 2>9= =0 !@54=5< >AB>:5, :>B>@K5 <>3CB ?@825AB8 : AB>;:=>25=8N F828;870F89, > :>B>@>< ?@54C?@5640; !0<CM;L %0=B8=3B>=, 8 ?@8254CB : =0F8>=0;L=>9 B@035488 8 :0B0AB@>D5. 1I5AB25==>5 <=5=85 4>;6=> 7=0BL 2A5 B>G:8 7@5=8O >B=>A8B5;L=> ?@>2>48<>9 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:8 !(. K CB25@6405<, GB> 2 A@545 0<5@8:0=A:>9 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 M;8BK ACI5AB2C5B 3@C??0 703>2>@I8:>2, :>B>@0O AB@5<8BAO 2>2;5GL =0HC AB@0=C 2 A5@8N 2>9=, :>B>@K5 1C4CB 25AB8AL =5 2 8=B5@5A0E <5@8:8. K >128=O5< 8E 2 B><, GB> >=8, 459AB2CO 2 A3>2>@5 A 7@08;5<, AB@5<OBAO : @076830=8N =>2KE 2>9= 8 C=8GB>65=8N A>3;0H5=89, 4>AB83=CBKE 2 A;>. K >128=O5< 8E 2 B><, GB> >=8 ?@54=0<5@5==> CEC4H0NB >B=>H5=8O <564C !( 8 0@01A:8<8 AB@0=0<8, :>B>@K5 2KABC?0NB ?@>B82 7@08;O 8 ?>445@6820NB AB@5<;5=85 ?0;5AB8=A:>3> =0@>40 A>740BL A>1AB25==>5 3>AC40@AB2>. K >128=O5< 8E 2 B><, GB> =K=5H=OO 2>8=AB25==0O ?>;8B8:0, ?>;=0O 2KA>:><5@8O 8 A0<>=045O==>AB8, >BB0;:8205B >B =0A 2A5E =0H8E 4@C759 8 A>N7=8:>2, :0: 2 70?04=>< <8@5, B0: 8 2 8A;0<A:8E AB@0=0E. <5@8:0 8 @0=LH5 >:07K20;0AL 2 87>;OF88, => A53>4=OH=85 459AB28O ?@57845=B0 CH0, :>B>@K9 2A5 3;C165 70E>48B 2 ;>2CH:C, @0AAB02;5==CN 4;O =53> =5>:>=A5@20B>@0<8, <>3CB AB>8BL 5<C ?@57845=BA:>3> :@5A;0, 0 <5@8:0 =0 4>;385 3>4K ;8H8BAO <8@0, 4>AB83=CB>3> 42C<O ?@54K4CI8<8 ?>:>;5=8O<8 2 BO65;>< ?@>B82>AB>O=88 2 3>4K E>;>4=>9 2>9=K. 0H8 >??>=5=BK >128=ONB =0A 2 0=B8A5<8B87<5, B.5. 2 =5=028AB8 : 4@52=5<C =0@>4C 7@08;O, : 53> 25@5 8 B@048F8O<. > ?@0240 70:;NG05BAO 2 B><, GB> MB8 >128=8B5;8 BI0B5;L=> A:@K20NB A2>N AB@0AB=CN ?@82O70==>ABL =5 : A2>5<C A>1AB25==><C (!(  ?@8<. ), 0 : 4@C3><C 3>AC40@AB2C, GB> 8 70AB02;O5B 8E ?>4G8=OBL 8=B5@5AK A2>59 AB@0=K 8 459AB2>20BL, 8AE>4O 87 B578A0  GB> E>@>H> 4;O 7@08;O, B> E>@>H> 8 4;O <5@8:8. !?@0H820O, :B> 65 B0:85 =5>:>=A5@20B>@K, 02B>@ >B25G05B, GB> 8E ?5@2>5 ?>:>;5=85 A>AB>O;> 87 M:A-;815@0;>2, A>F80;8AB>2, B@>F:8AB>2 8 ;N459, :>B>@K5 ?>A;5 @52>;NF88 0:3>25@=0 ?@818;8AL : 5A?C1;8:0=A:>9 ?0@B88, :>340 2 1980 3>4C :>=A5@20B87< CA?5H=> 7025@H8; A2>9 ?>E>4 2> 2;0ABL 2 ;8F5 >=0;L40 5930=0.  B> 2@5<O ?8A0;>AL, GB> =5>:>=A5@20B>@  MB> A:>@55 @540:B>@ 6C@=0;0, G5< AB@>8B5;L=K9 @01>G89. !53>4=O  MB>, 25@>OB=55 2A53>, ?>;8B>;>3, =0?@8<5@, 87 <5@8:0=A:>3> 8=AB8BCB0 ?@54?@8=8<0B5;LAB20 8;8 >4=>3> 87 53> :;>=>2 B8?0 &5=B@0 ?> 2K@01>B:5 ?>;8B8:8 2 >1;0AB8 157>?0A=>AB8 8;8 2@59A:>3> 8=AB8BCB0 ?> 2>?@>A0< =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. 0: 70<5B8; >48= >AB@>C<=K9 G5;>25:  =5>:>=A5@20B>@ 7=0:>< 1>;LH5 A B5< :0: CAB@>5=K 8 DC=:F8>=8@CNB D01@8:8 <KA;8 (think tank), G5< A B5< :0: A:>=AB@C8@>20= 8 459AB2C5B B0=: Abrams. !@548 =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2 =5B =8 >4=>3>, :B> 1K ?@8H5; 87 <8@0 187=5A0 8;8 87 2>5==KE. 5:>B>@KE ?>@>48;0 :><?0=8O >;4C>B5@0. E 35@>O<8 O2;ONBAO C4@> 8;LA>=, $@0=:;8= 5;0=> C725;LB, 0@@8 "@C<M=, 0@B8= NB5@ 8=3, 0 B0:65 A5=0B>@K-45<>:@0BK 5=@8 65:A>= (?> ?@>728IC >;LH>9 CH) 8 MB >9=8EM=. A5 >=8  AB>@>==8:8 ?>;8B8:8 8=B5@25=F89, :>B>@CN 0:B82=> ?>445@68205B 7@08;L.  8E A?8A:5 72574 ?5@2>9 25;8G8=K G8A;OBAO 68= 8@:?0B@8:, 8;; 5==5B, 09:; >20: 8 659<A .8;LA>=. E 1C<06=K< @C?>@>< AG8B0NBAO Weekly Standard, Commentary, New Republic, National Review 8 @540:F8>==0O AB@0=8F0 Wall Street Journal. %>BO G8A;> 3075B 8 =525;8:>, => 8E 2;8O=85 =0 2;0ABL 2 >1I5AB25 G5@57 :>=B@>;L =04 @07;8G=K<8 :>=A5@20B82=K<8 D>=40<8 8 6C@=0;0<8 @0A?@>AB@0=O5BAO 7=0G8B5;L=> H8@5. ;O MB>3> B0:65 8A?>;L7C5BAO 1;87>ABL : ;N4O< 2 @07;8G=KE AB@C:BC@0E 8A?>;=8B5;L=>9 2;0AB8. 0;55 LN:5=5= >B<5G05B, GB> 2 0<5@8:0=A:>9 6C@=0;8AB8:5 O2;O5BAO 1>;LH>9 @54:>ABLN ?@O<>9 2>?@>A, ?>4>1=K9 B><C, :>B>@K9 7040; =5:>B>@>5 2@5<O B><C =0704 "8< 0AA5@B (Tim Russert) 8G0@4C 5@;C (Richard Perle): & A>>B25BAB2CNB ;8 CA8;8O ?> A25@65=8N !0440<0 %CA59=0 8=B5@5A0< !(, 8 8<55BAO ;8 745AL A2O7L A 8=B5@5A0<8 7@08;O?. = ?@>4>;605B: 0: B>;L:> 2>7=8: 2>?@>A >1 7@08;5, ?0@B8O 2>9=K A@07C ?@8C=K;0. #E>4O >B 8AB8==>3> @073>2>@0, =0H8 =5>:>=A5@20B82=K5 4@C7LO 70=8<0NB ?>78F8N ?>;8B8G5A:>3> <5=LH8=AB20, ?>425@30NI53>AO =5A?@0254;82K< =0?04:0< 8 ?>4>7@5=8O<. N48, ?@5B5=4CNI85 =0 @>;L B2>@F>2 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:8 254CI59 <8@>2>9 AC?5@45@602K, <>3;8 1K 25AB8 A51O 1>;55 <C65AB25==>.  MB>9 A2O78 1K2H89 @540:B>@ Wall Street Journal 0:A CB (Max Boot) >B<5B8;: >340 2A5 MB8 AB>@>==8:8 LN:5=5=0 AC5B;82> >1AC640NB =5>:>=A5@20B87< 8 F8B8@CNB C;LD>28F0 8 >M=0, B> @5D@5=>< 72CG8B A;>2>A>G5B0=85 52@59A:89 :>=A5@20B87<. 4=0:> CB A>3;0A8;AO A B5<, GB> :;NG52K< 4>3<0B>< =5>:>=A5@20B87<0 O2;O5BAO AB@0==0O ?@82O70==>ABL : 7@08;N. = B0:65 70O28;, GB> !B@0B538O =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, >1=0@>4>20==0O ?@57845=B>< CH5<, :0: 1C4B> 1K A?8A0=0 A> AB0B59 87 6C@=0;0 Commentary (><<5=B0@89), O2;ONI53>AO 81;859 4;O 2A5E =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2. (;O =5?>A2OI5==KE 4>1028<, GB> MB>B 565<5AOG=K9 6C@=0; 87405BAO <5@8:0=A:8< 2@59A:8< :><8B5B><). 0284 @C:A (David Brooks) 87 Weekly Standard 60;>20;AO B0:65, GB> 2A5 MB8 =0<5:8 >1 8=B5@5A0E 7@08;O =5?@8OB=> 70B@>=C;8 8 53> ;8G=>: >O M;5:B@>==0O ?>GB0 1C:20;L=> 70E;0<;5=0 15A:>=5G=K<8 0=B8A5<8BA:8<8 AB0BLO<8. =B8A5<8B87< 682, 0 53> M?8F5=B@ ?5@5<5AB8;AO >B ?@02KE AB>@>==8:>2 LN:5=5=0 : ;52><C 42865=8N 70 <8@. <C 2B>@8; >1>7@520B5;L >15@B 030= (Robert Kagan) 87 Washington Post: & ;CGH85 3>;>2K 2 >=4>=5 =0C:>>1@07=K< O7K:>< >1AC640NB B5>@8N 703>2>@0, 2K@060O >15A?>:>5==>ABL 2 A2O78 A C7C@?0F859 =5>:>=A5@20B>@0<8 (G8B09  52@5O<8) 2A59 0<5@8:0=A:>9 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:8. >C@5=A 0?;0= (Lawrence Kaplan) 87 New Republic - ?8H5B 40;55 LN:5=5= ->128=O5B =0A 2 B><, 1C4B> 1K =0H 6C@=0; AB0; B@81C=>9 4;O B5E, :B> CB25@6405B, GB> ?@57845=B CH ?@52@0B8;AO 2 G5;>25:0, >1A;C6820NI53> 8=B5@5AK @8M;O (0@>=0 8 =5>:>=A5@20B82=CN ?0@B8N 2>9=K. !AK;0OAL =0 '0@;L70 8=415@30 (Charles Lindbergh), >= >128=O5B >;0 (@545@0 (Paul Schroeder), @8A0 MBLNA0 (Chris Matthews), >15@B0 >20:0 (Robert Novak), 6>@468 595@0 (Georgie Anne Geyer), 659A>=0 5AB0 (Jason Vest) 87 Nation 8 0@@8 %0@B0 (Gary Hart), :>B>@K5 2KA:07K20NBAO 2 B>< A<KA;5, GB> G;5=K :><0=4K CH0 83@0NB =0 AB>@>=5 7@08;O, ?@>O2;OO 42>9AB25==CN ;>O;L=>ABL. 0?;0= =53>4C5B: >4>1=K5 70O2;5=8O >B@02;ONB >1I5AB25==>5 A>7=0=85 O4>< =0F8>=0;87<0. E B@C4=> >?@>25@3=CBL ipso facto.  >B25B 2 6C@=0;5 Slate ?>O2;O5BAO AB0BLO 8::8 0CA0 (Mickey Kaus) ?>4 703>;>2:><  >C@5=A 0?;0= @07K3@K205B 0=B8A5<8BA:CN :0@BC. 0?;0=, @C:A, CB 8 030= 459AB2CNB ?>4>1=> 1>@FC 70 ?@020 =53@>2 65AA8 65:A>=C, :>B>@K9, >128=OO :><?0=8N Fortune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ew Republic, ?@>D5AA>@ 87 0@20@4A:>3> C=825@A8B5B0 !B5=;8 %>DD<0= (Stenley Hoffman), @0AAC640O > G5BK@5E F5=B@0E A8;K, ?@87K20NI8E : 2>9=5, ?8A0;:  , =0:>=5F, ACI5AB2C5B =5 >G5=L AB018;L=0O 3@C??0 4@C759 7@08;O, :>B>@K5 B25@4> 25@OB, GB> C !( 8 7@08;O >4=8 8 B5 65 8=B5@5AK. =8 A<>B@OB =0 2K@01>B:C 0<5@8:0=A:>9 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:8 A >4=>9 B>G:8 7@5=8O  ?>;57=0 8;8 2@54=0 >=0 4;O 7@08;O? 0=LH5 B0:8E <KA;8B5;59 =5 >G5=L 60;>20;8 2 >AC40@AB25==>< 45?0@B0<5=B5, => A59G0A >=8 ?@>G=> >::C?8@>20;8 5=B03>=, 3@C??8@COAL 2>:@C3 >;0 C;D>28F0, 8G0@40 5@;0 8 C3;0A0 $59B0. LN:5=5= >B<5G05B B0:65 A?@0254;82K9 2>?@>A 0CA0: A;8 >1 MB>< 3>2>@8B !B5=;8 %>DD<0=, B> ?>G5<C MB>3> =5 <>65B 45;0BL @8A MBLNA? = B0:65 70<5G05B, GB> 0?;0= C<0;G8205B > A2O78 =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2 A (0@>=>< 8 53> ?0@B859 8:C4.  40;55, >15@B 0975@ (Robert Kaiser) 2 A2>59 AB0BL5 2 Washington Post 70 9 D52@0;O B0: F8B8@C5B =5=0720==>3> 2KA>:>?>AB02;5==>3> G8=>2=8:0: !53>4=O 3;02=CN @>;L 83@0NB AB>@>==8:8 8:C40. 0975@ =07K205B 5@;0, C;D>28F0 8 $59B0 G;5=0<8 ?@>87@08;LA:>9 >@30=870F88 2=CB@8 ?@57845=BA:>9 04<8=8AB@0F88 !(.  55 G;5=0< >= B0:65 ?@8G8A;O5B 02840 C@<A5@0 (David Wurmser) 87 8=8AB5@AB20 >1>@>=K 8 -;8>B0 1@0<A0 (Elliott Abrams) 87 !>25B0 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8. (1@0<A O2;O5BAO 7OB5< >@<0=0 >43>@5F0 (Norman Podhoretz), 1K2H53> 3;02=>3> @540:B>@0 6C@=0;0 Commentary, :>B>@K9 ?>AB>O==> :;59<8; ?>7>@>< 2A5E 0=B8A5<8B>2 8 :@8B8:>2 7@08;O). !?@0254;82> 70<5G0O, GB> (0@>= 2A5 2@5<O 3>2>@8B >1 >A>1>9 1;87>AB8 : AB>@>==8:0< CH0, 0975@ ?8H5B: ?5@2K5 04<8=8AB@0F8O !( 8 7@08;LA:>5 ?@028B5;LAB2>, 2>73;02;O5<>5 ?@54AB028B5;O<8 8:C40, ?@>2>48B ?>GB8 >48=0:>2CN ?>;8B8:C. >7=8:05B 70:>=><5@=K9 2>?@>A: 0: B0:>5 ?@>87>H;>? , O2;OOAL, =5A><=5==>, ?>;8B8:>9, ?@>2>48<>9 2 8=B5@5A0E (0@>=0, >B25G05B ;8 >=0 8=B5@5A0< !(? 0: B>;L:> 70:>=G8;0AL E>;>4=0O 2>9=0, =5>:>=A5@20B>@K, GB>1K >?@0240BL A2>5 ACI5AB2>20=85, AB0;8 ;8E>@04>G=> 8A:0BL 2@030 2 :0G5AB25 F5;8 =>2>3> :@5AB>2>3> ?>E>40. E 2@5<O ?@8H;> 2<5AB5 A B@0354859 11 A5=BO1@O. =8 8A?>;L7>20;8 MB> 65AB>:>5 ?@5ABC?;5=85, GB>1K =0?@028BL 3=52 0<5@8:0=A:>3> =0@>40 =0 @076830=85 =>2>9 2>9=K A> 2A5<8 2=5H=8<8 2@030<8 <5@8:8, 2:;NG0O 0@01A:85 8 8A;0<A:85 3>AC40@AB20-873>8, :>B>@K5 ?@>B82>AB>O;8 3535<>=88 !( 8 =5=02845;8 7@08;L. 4=0:> A;54C5B 70<5B8BL, GB> ?0@B8O 2>9=K AB0;0 @07@010BK20BL A2>8 ?;0=K 704>;3> 4> 11 A5=BO1@O.  :>340 ?>A;5 ?>154K =04 "0;810=>< ?@57845=B CH 704C<0;AO > =>2KE H030E 2 1>@L15 A B5@@>@87<><, =5>:>=A5@20B>@K 1KAB@5=L:> ?@54AB028;8 5<C =>2>3> 2@030, =0 GB> >= A@07C 8 :C?8;AO. !B>8B ?>4@>1=55 ?@>0=0;878@>20BL @50:F8N =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2 =0 B@03548N 11 A5=BO1@O. 12 A5=BO1@O 2AO <5@8:0 5I5 2 H>:5, 0 8;; 5==5B 2 8=B5@2LN CNN C65 70O2;O5B, GB> =0G0;0AL AE20B:0 <564C 4>1@>< 8 7;><, 8 >=3@5AA 4>;65= >1JO28BL 2>9=C 2>8=AB2CNI5<C A;0<C, 8 !( 4>;6=K ?@8<5=8BL 2A5A>:@CH0NICN A8;C.  :0G5AB25 F5;59 4;O 0B0:8 5==5B >1>7=0G05B 820=, 828N, !8@8N, @0:, @0= 8 8B09. >G5<C-B> 2 MB>< A?8A:5 >BACBAB2C5B C1568I5 B5@@>@8AB>2 A0<K  D30=8AB0=. =B5@5A=>, >B:C40 5==5B 7=0;, ?> :0:8< AB@0=0< =5>1E>48<> C40@8BL, =5 8<5O ?>=OB8O > B><, :B> A>25@H8; =0?045=85 =0 <5@8:C?  3075B0 Wall Street Journal BCB 65 ?@54;>68;0 A2>9  A?8A>: F5;59, ?@87K20O =0=5AB8 2>74CH=K5 C40@K ?> ;035@O< B5@@>@8AB>2 2 !8@88, !C40=5, 8288 8 ;68@5, 0 B0:65, 2>7<>6=>, ?> =5:>B>@K< @09>=0< =0 B5@@8B>@88 38?B0. @8 MB>< =8 >4=0 87 H5AB8 AB@0=, =0720==KE 5==5B><, =8 ?OBL, ?5@5G8A;5==KE 2 3075B5, =5 8<5;8 =8:0:>3> >B=>H5=8O : B5@0:BC 11 A5=BO1@O. !>3;0A=> AB0BL5 >10 C42>@40 CH =0 2>9=5, ?>O282H59AO 15 A5=BO1@O, >; C;D>28F 0@3C<5=B8@>20; 2>5==CN F5;5A>>1@07=>ABL 0B0:8 =0 @0:, 0 =5 =0 D30=8AB0=. >G5<C @0:? >B><C GB>, :0: A:070; C;D>28F =0 A>25I0=88 C ?@57845=B0, & 0@3C<5=BK 2 ?>;L7C 0B0:8 =0 D30=8AB0= =5 AB>;L 25A><K& , 0 2 @0:5 ACI5AB2C5B @5?@5AA82=K9 @568<, :>B>@K9 ;53:> @073@><8BL. -B> ;53:> 2K?>;=8<0O 7040G0. 20 A5=BO1@O 2001 3>40 ?@57845=B CH ?>;CG8; 8=AB@C:B82=>5 ?8AL<>, ?>4?8A0==>5 40 284=K<8 =5>:>=A5@20B>@0<8, :>B>@K5 A>25B>20;8 :0: 25AB8 1>@L1C A B5@@>@87<><. -B> 1K; A2>53> @>40 C;LB8<0BC<, ?@54JO2;5==K9 5==5B><, >43>@5F5<, 8@:?0B@8:><, 5@;><, @8AB>;;><, '0@;L7>< @0CBE0<<5@>< (254CI89 >1>7@520B5;L Washington Post) 8 4@C38<8. @57845=BC ?@54;030;>AL C=8GB>68BL >@30=870F8N %5710;;0, =0=5AB8 C40@ 2>7<5748O ?> !8@88 8 @0=C, 5A;8 B5 =5 ?@5:@0BOB ?>445@6:C B5@@>@8AB>2, 8 A1@>A8BL @568< !0440<0. >4?8A0=BK ?@54C?@5640;8 CH0, GB> >B:07 >B C40@0 ?> @0:C 1C45B >7=0G0BL :0?8BC;OF8N 2 1>@L15 A <564C=0@>4=K< B5@@>@87<><. -B> 1K; 703>2>@ 8=B5;;5:BC0;>2, :>B>@K5 A?CABO 9 4=59 ?>A;5 =0?045=8O =0 <5@8:C, 70O2;ONB 3;02=>:><0=4CNI5<C AB@0=K, GB>, 5A;8 >= =5 1C45B A;54>20BL 8E 2>5==K< ?;0=0<, B> 53> >128=OB 2 >B:075 >B 1>@L1K A B5@@>@87<><. 0<5B8<, GB> %5710;;0 =8:0: =5 ?@8G0AB=0 : B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O; MB0 >@30=870F8O ?>28==0 ;8HL 2 B><, GB> 2 A2>5 2@5<O 2KH2K@=C;0 0@<8N 7@08;O 87 820=0. @57845=B0 CH0 ?@54C?@548;8. = 4>;65= 8A?>;L7>20BL B5@0:B 11 A5=BO1@O 4;O B>3>, GB>1K =0G0BL A5@8N 2>9= A 0@01A:8<8 AB@0=0<8, :>B>@K5 =8:>340 =5 =0?040;8 =0 !(. 4=0:> 2A5 >=8 O2;O;8AL 2@030<8 7@08;O.  B> 2@5<O 818 5B0=LOEC, 1K2H89 ?@5<L5@-<8=8AB@ 7@08;O, :070;>AL, 2KABC?0; =0 2A5E :0=0;0E 0<5@8:0=A:>3> B5;52845=8O, ?@87K20; A>:@CH8BL 8<?5@8N B5@@>@0, :>B>@0O 2:;NG05B 2 A51O >@30=870F88 %0<0A, %5710;;0, 0 B0:65 @0=, @0: 8 0;5AB8=A:89 0=:;02. >=5G=>, 2A5 MB> <0;>A8<?0B8G=K5 ?5@A>=068, => GB> >=8 A45;0;8 !(? 0@B8O 2>9=K >G5=L A?5H8;0 @072O70BL =>2CN 2>9=C =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5. ">< >==5;8, 2>73;02;ONI89 ?@>3@0<<C >2K9 0<5@8:0=A:89 25:, ?@8720; : =5<54;5==><C 2B>@65=8N 2 @0:. = ?8A0;: 5 =C6=> 4>6840BLAO A>A@54>B>G5=8O ?>;C<8;;8>==>9 3@C??8@>2:8& 1>;LH59 ?@>1;5<>9 ?@54AB02;O5BAO ?>AB:>=D;8:B=>5 ?5@5CAB@>9AB2> @0:0. <C 2B>@8; >=0E >;415@3 87 National Review: !( A;54C5B =0G0BL 2>9=C A @0:><, B0: :0: 2A5 @02=> ?@845BAO 2>520BL 2 MB>< @538>=5, 0 @0: ?@54AB02;O5BAO =081>;55 ?>4E>4OI59 F5;LN. > ACB8, >;415@3 F8B8@>20; B0: =07K205<CN 4>:B@8=C 848=0 (The Ledeen Doctrine), 1K2H53> 2KA>:>?>AB02;5==>3> G8=>2=8:0 5=B03>=0, 2 :>B>@>9 70O2;O;>AL, GB> ?@8<5@=> @07 2 45AOBL ;5B !( A;54C5B 2K18@0BL :0:CN-=81C4L =51>;LHCN AB@0=C A ?0@H82K< @568<>< 8 H<O:0BL 55 >1 AB5=C, GB>1K ?>:070BL 2A5<, GB> <K A5@L57=K5 @51OB0.  6C@=0;5 >;415@30 GB>-B> =5 C?><8=0;>AL >1 M?87>45, ?@>87>H54H5< =0 48?;><0B8G5A:>< ?@85<5 2 >=4>=5, 345 D@0=FC7A:89 ?>A>; 7040; @8B>@8G5A:89 2>?@>A: , A>1AB25==>, ?>G5<C 87-70 :0:>9-B> <0;5=L:>9 3>2Q==>9 AB@0=K <K 4>;6=K 84B8 =0 @8A: @072O7K20=8O B@5BL59 <8@>2>9 2>9=K? !0< 65 848= 1K; 01A>;NB=> :>=:@5B5= 2 >B=>H5=88 @568<>2, :>B>@K5 A;54C5B C=8GB>60BL. &8B8@C5<:  ?5@2CN >G5@54L <K 4>;6=K A20;8BL B5@@>@8AB8G5A:85 @568<K 2 @0=5, @0:5 8 !8@88. 0B5< =0< ?@845BAO @07>1@0BLAO A !0C4>2A:>9 @02859. >A;5 MB>3> =0< ?@845BAO 1KBL 30@0=B0<8 CAB0=>2;5=8O 2 MB8E AB@0=0E 45<>:@0B8G5A:>3> ?@02;5=8O& 0H0 7040G0 =5 A>E@0=5=85 AB018;L=>AB8 2 MB8E AB@0=0E, 0 A<5=0 ACI5AB2CNI8E B0< @568<>2. >?@>A ;8HL 2 B><, :0: 8E 45AB018;878@>20BL =081>;55 >?B8<0;L=>. 0;55 848= ?5@5E>48B : >?@545;5=8N ?>4;8==>9 8AB>@8G5A:>9 <8AA88 <5@8:8: > 3;02C C3;0, :0: 2=CB@8 AB@0=K, B0: 8 70 @C156><, 4>;6=> 1KBL ?>AB02;5=> A>7840B5;L=>5 @07@CH5=85. K D0:B8G5A:8 5654=52=> @07@CH05< AB0@K9 ?>@O4>:. -B> 70B@038205B 2A5 AD5@K 687=8  187=5A, =0C:C, ;8B5@0BC@C, 8A:CAAB2>, 0@E8B5:BC@C, :8=>, ?>;8B8:C, ?@02> 8 B.4. 0H8 =54@C38 2A5340 =5=02845;8 B2>@G5A:CN M=5@38N 0<5@8:0=F52, :>B>@0O, ?>4>1=> A<5@GC, ?C30;0 8 C3@>60;0 8E A@54=525:>2K< CAB>O< 8 B@048F8O<. K 4>;6=K @07@CH8BL MB8 @568<K 8 2K?>;=8BL A2>N 8AB>@8G5A:CN <8AA8N ?> ?@>42865=8N ?@>3@5AA0 F828;870F88. >4>1=K9 ?0AA06 <>3 1K A:>@55 2K9B8 87-?>4 ?5@0 L20 "@>F:>3>, 2 =5< O2=> ?@8ACBAB2C5B 4CE O:>18=AB20, >4=0:> >=, >G5284=>, =5 A>>B25BAB2C5B :>=F5?F88 8AB8==>3> :>=A5@20B87<0. 4=0:> 4;O Weekly Standard A?8A>: F5;59 848=0 ?>:070;AO =54>AB0B>G=K<. > 55 <=5=8N, <K 4>;6=K =5 B>;L:> >1JO28BL 2>9=C 2A5< B5@@>@8AB8G5A:8< >@30=870F8O< 8 3>AC40@AB20<, ?@54>AB02;ONI8< 8< C1568I5, => 8 =0G0BL 2>9=C ?@>B82 ;N1>3> @568<0, A:;>==>3> : ?>445@6:5 <564C=0@>4=>3> B5@@>@87<0 8 3>AC40@AB2-873>52.  ?@542:CH5=88 =>2>3> @<03544>=0 C >15@B0 030=0 8 8;LO<0 @8AB>;;0 1C:20;L=> 3>;>2K 70:@C68;8AL. @54AB>OI0O 2>9=0 1C45B @0A?@>AB@0=5=0 =0 @O4 4@C38E AB@0=& >=0 1C45B ?>E>60 =0 B> A0<>5 AB>;:=>25=85 F828;870F89, :>B>@K< =0A B0: 4>;3> ?C30;8. >7<>6=>, GB> 70B5< =0AB0=5B >G5@54L @568<>2 8 2 B0: =07K205<KE C<5@5==KE 0@01A:8E AB@0=0E. >@<0== >43>@5F 87 Commentary ?>H5; 5I5 40;LH5. = AB0; :@0A=>109AB2>20BL, 70O2;OO, GB> <K 4>;6=K ?@825BAB2>20BL 2>9=C F828;870F89, ?>B><C GB> '5B25@B0O <8@>20O 2>9=0 ?@>B82 2>8=AB2CNI53> A;0<0 O2;O5BAO 4;O ?@57845=B0 CH0 53> 8AB>@8G5A:>9 <8AA859. @8 MB>< @568<K, :>B>@K5 ?>4;560B C=8GB>65=8N, =5 >3@0=8G820NBAO ?@5A;>2CB>9 >ALN 7;0 (@0:, @0=, !525@=0O >@5O). 0: <8=8<C< AN40 ?>?040NB !8@8O, 820= 8 828O, 0 B0:65 4@C7LO <5@8:8 - !0C4>2A:0O @028O 8 38?5B 2<5AB5 A 0;5AB8=A:>9 02B>=><859. CH 4>;65= >B25@3=CBL B@CA;82K5 ?;0=K A25@E >AB>@>6=>3> >;8=0 0CM;;0, - ?8A0; >43>@5F.  40;55: & >= 4>;65= =09B8 2 A515 A<5;>ABL 8 =02O70BL =>2CN ?>;8B8G5A:CN :C;LBC@C ?>25@65==><C 8A;0<A:><C <8@C. 54L <K 65 ?>H;8 =0 @07@CH5=85 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 >@30=870F88 "0;810=, 2>NO ?@>B82 B5@@>@8AB>2 87 ;L-084K. >43>@5F ?@>4>;605B: K <>65< >:070BLAO 2 A8BC0F88, :>340 1C45< 2K=C645=K ?@8153=CBL : A8;5, GB>1K A25@3=CBL ?OBL 8;8 H5ABL 8A;0<A:8E B8@0=89, 2:;NG0O =K=5H=NN ?0;5AB8=A:CN 04<8=8AB@0F8N 2> 3;025 A /A8@>< @0D0B><. >6=> ?@54AB028BL =5A:>=G05<CN G5@54C 2>9=, :0640O 87 :>B>@KE 1C45B >1CA;>2;5=0 :0:>9-;81> =>2>9 8AB>@8G5A:>9 <8AA859 <5@8:8, AB@5<OI59AO ?@54C?@548BL ?>O2;5=85 @568<>2 5I5 1>;55 70A;C6820NI8E =0:070=8O 8 @5D>@<8@>20=8O, G5< ACI5AB2CNI85 =K=5 45A?>B88. B0:, 2 A?8A>: 1;86=52>AB>G=KE @568<>2, :>B>@K5, ?> <=5=8N >43>@5F0, 5==5B0, 848=0, 5B0=LOEC 8 3075BK Wall Street Journal, A;54C5B C=8GB>68BL, 2E>4OB ;68@, 828O, 38?5B, !C40=, 820=, !8@8O, @0:, !0C4>2A:0O @028O, @0=, 0 B0:65 04<8=8AB@0F8O 0;5AB8=A:>9 02B>=><88, >@30=870F88 %5710;;0 8 %0<0A, 8 2 F5;>< 2>8=AB2CNI89 A;0<.  GL8E MB> 8=B5@5A0E? B> 2K83@05B >B 2>9=K F828;870F89 <564C 0?04>< 8 A;0<><? B25B >G52845=  MB> 7@08;L, (0@>= 8 53> ?0@B8O 8:C4. 59AB28B5;L=>, 2 D52@0;5 2003 3>40 <564C (0@>=>< 8 53> 0<5@8:0=A:8<8 ?@8A;C68=8:0<8 =01;N40;>AL 01A>;NB=>5 548=><KA;85. KABC?0O ?5@54 45;530F859 :>=3@5AA<5=>2 !(, (0@>=, 2 G0AB=>AB8, 70<5B8;, GB> ?>A;5 B>3>, :0: @568< !0440<0 1C45B ?>25@65=, 687=5==> 206=K< 4;O !( ?@54AB02;O5BAO @07>@C65=85 @0=0, !8@88 8 8288.  <8=8AB@ >1>@>=K 7@08;O (0C; >D07 (Shaul Mofaz) =0 :>=D5@5=F88 <5@8:0=A:8E 52@59A:8E >@30=870F89 ?@O<> A:070;, GB> ?>A;5 2ABC?;5=8O 0<5@8:0=A:8E 2>9A: 2 03404, !( 4>;6=K >@30=87>20BL ?>;8B8G5A:>5, M:>=><8G5A:>5 8 48?;><0B8G5A:>5 402;5=85 =0 "535@0=. @8 MB>< =5>:>=A5@20B>@>2 01A>;NB=> =5 15A?>:>8B, GB> 2>9=0 2 @0:5 <>65B ?@825AB8 : ?045=8N 4@C65AB25==KE @568<>2 2 0@01A:8E AB@0=0E. 5@>OB=>, >=8 4065 E>B5;8 1K B0:>3> @0728B8O A>1KB89. 8G0@4 5@; :0:-B> >1<>;28;AO, GB> C10@0: =5 B0:>9 C65 8 4@C3 <5@8:8. >6=> =09B8 5<C 8 ;CGHCN 70<5=C.  8N;5 2002 3>40 ?> ?@83;0H5=8N 5@;0 2 8=8AB5@AB25 >1>@>=K 2KABC?0; 1K2H89 ?><>I=8: 8=4>=0 0@CH0 >@5= C@028: (Laurent Murawiec). 3> A;>20 ?>B@OA;8 4065 5=@8 8AA5=465@0. C@028: =0720; !0C4>2A:CN @028N A@54>B>G5=85< 7;0 8 A0<K< >?0A=K< ?@>B82=8:>< !(. > 53> <=5=8N, 0H8=3B>= 4>;65= ?@54JO28BL -@- 8O4C C;LB8<0BC<  87>;8@>20BL 8 =0:070BL 2A5E ?@8G0AB=KE : B5@@>@8AB8G5A:>9 45OB5;L=>AB8, 2:;NG0O A>B@C4=8:>2 !0C4>2A:>9 @07254:8; ?@5:@0B8BL 0=B887@08;LA:CN ?@>?030=4C.  ?@>B82=>< A;CG05 !( 2B>@3=5BAO 2 !0C4>2A:CN @028N, 2>7L<5B ?>4 :>=B@>;L =5DBO=K5 ?>;O 8 >::C?8@C5B 5::C.  70:;NG8B5;L=>9 G0AB8 2KABC?;5=8O C@028: ?@54;>68; A2>N >;LHCN AB@0B538N 4;O ;86=53> >AB>:0, ?> :>B>@>9 @0: O2;O5BAO B0:B8G5A:>9 F5;LN, !0C4>2A:0O @028O  AB@0B538G5A:>9, 0 38?5B  65;0B5;L=>9. > =8:B> =5 7040; 5<C 2>?@>A0, 0 :0:>20 <>65B 1KBL @50:F8O A;0<A:>3> <8@0 =0 ?>O2;5=85 2 5::5 0<5@8:0=A:8E >::C?0F8>==KE 2>9A:?  G5<C 459AB28B5;L=> AB@5<OBAO =5>:>=A5@20B>@K, B0: MB> B>;L:> : >15A?5G5=8N 157>?0A=>AB8 7@08;O, 70 :>B>@CN 1C45B ?@>;820BLAO :@>2L 0<5@8:0=A:8E A>;40B. 57>?0A=>AB8 A ?><>ILN 0<5@8:0=A:>3> <5G0, 70=5A5==>3> =04 3>;>2>9 2A53> A;0<A:>3> <8@0. 540:B>@ Washington Times @=>;L4 45 >@E3@0D (Arnold de Borchgrave) =0720; MB> 4>:B@8=>9 (0@>=0-CH0. >B, GB> >= ?8H5B: !> 2@5<5= ?@8H5AB28O CH0 2 5;K9 4>< 2> 3;025 0<5@8:0=A:>9 ?>;8B8:8 =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5 2AB0;8 AB>@>==8:8 8 ?@8A?5H=8:8 8:C40. 5>:>=A5@20B>@K E>BOB A>740BL <5@8:0=A:CN 8<?5@8N, 0 AB>@>==8:8 (0@>=0 AB@5<OBAO : 3535<>=88 =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5. E F5;8 8 7040G8 A>2?040NB. %>BO =5>:>=A5@20B>@K 3>2>@OB, GB> ?@8G8=>9 2>9=K 2 @0:5 8 1>@L1K A 2>8=AB2CNI8< A;0<>< O28;>AL 11 A5=BO1@O, =0 A0<>< 45;5 >=8 =0G0;8 @07@010BK20BL A2>8 2>5==K5 ?;0=K 704>;3> 4> MB>3> =0?045=8O =0 <5@8:C. ;02=K< ?;0=8@>2I8:>< =5>:>=A5@20B82=>9 AB@0B5388 O2;O5BAO 8G0@4 5@;. I5 2 1970 3>4C AB0;8 4>AB>O=85< 3;0A=>AB8 53> B5;5D>==K5 @073>2>@K A ?>A>;LAB2>< 7@08;O, 2 :>B>@KE 5@; >1AC640; A5:@5B=CN 8=D>@<0F8N, ?>ABC?82HCN : =5<C 87 !>25B0 =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8.  2 AB0BL5 2@58 8 0<5@8:0=A:0O ?>;8B8:0, >?C1;8:>20==>9 2 1974 3>4C, 55 02B>@ !B825= 970: (Stephen D. Isaacs) ?@O<> ?8A0;: 8G0@4 5@; 8 >@8A -<8B59 8<5NB =0 0?8B>;89A:>< E>;<5 A2>N <0;5=L:CN A5<8BA:CN 0@<8N, 459AB2CNICN 2 8=B5@5A0E 52@59A:>3> =0@>40.  1983 3>4C 3075B0 New York Times A>>1I8;0, GB> 8G0@4 5@; 4>;3>5 2@5<O ?>;CG0; A5@L57=K5 45=L38 >B 87@08;LA:8E ?@>872>48B5;59 >@C68O.  1996 3>4C 5@; 2 A>02B>@AB25 A C3;0A>< $59B>< (Douglas Feith) 8 0284>< C@<A5@>< (David Wurmser) ?8H5B >2CN AB@0B538N 4;O >15A?5G5=8O 157>?0A=>AB8 3>AC40@AB20, ?@54=07=0G5==CN ?@5<L5@-<8=8AB@C 5B0=LOEC.  MB>< B@C45 02B>@K ?@87K20NB 818 701KBL 8 ?>E>@>=8BL A>3;0H5=8O, ?>4?8A0==K5 2 A;> 53> C18BK< ?@54H5AB25==8:>< FE0:>< 018=>< 8 =0G0BL @50;870F8N =>2>9 03@5AA82=>9 AB@0B5388. 7@08;L <>65B AD>@<8@>20BL =>2CN ?>;8B8G5A:CN A@54C, A>B@C4=8G0O A "C@F859 8 >@40=859, => A45@6820O 8 >A;01;OO !8@8N. 3@0=8G5=8O @538>=0;L=KE 0<18F89 !8@88 A;54C5B 4>1820BLAO G5@57 CA8;8O ?> A25@65=8N !0440<0 %CA59=0  3;02=>9 AB@0B538G5A:>9 7040G8 7@08;O. ?>@>9 MB><C <>3CB ?>A;C68BL ?@54;>65=8O. >@40=88 2>AAB0=>28BL 2 @0:5 ?@02;5=85 48=0AB88 %0H5<8B>2. !>3;0A=> MB>9 AB@0B5388, 3;02=K< ?@>B82=8:>< 7@08;O ?@54AB02;O5BAO !8@8O, => 4>@>30 2 0<0A: ;568B G5@57 03404. ;0= ?5@;0, $59B0 8 C@A<5@0, ?@54;>65==K9 7@08;N, 2 :>B>@>< ?@54;0305BAO 2>7@>48BL ?@8=F8? ?@525=B82=>AB8, A53>4=O =02O7K205BAO 8 A0<>9 <5@8:5.  A2>59 AB0BL5 !B@0B538O 4;O 7@08;O, ?>O282H59AO 5I5 2 1997 3>4C, $59B =0AB>OB5;L=> A>25BC5B >::C?8@>20BL B5@@8B>@88, =0E>4OI85AO ?>4 :>=B@>;5< 0;5AB8=A:>9 04<8=8AB@0F88, =5 >1@0I0O 2=8<0=8O =8 =0 :0:85 ?>B5@8.  C;A<5@ ?@54;>68; A2>9 ?;0= A>2<5AB=KE 459AB289 !( 8 7@08;O: & =0=5AB8 A>:@CH8B5;L=K9 C40@ ?> F5=B@0< @048:0;87<0 =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5. K 4>;6=K =5 ?@>AB> @07>@C68BL, => 8 A>:@CH8BL @568<K 2 0<0A:5, 034045, "@8?>;8, "535@0=5 8 2 A5:B>@5 07K B0:8< >1@07><, GB>1K =8:B> 8 =5 ?><KH;O; 2KABC?0BL ?@>B82 !( 8;8 7@08;O. -B>B ?;0= 1K; >?C1;8:>20= 1 O=20@O 2001 3>40, B.5. 70 452OBL <5AOF52 4> B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O.  2>B GB> ?8H5B ?> ?>2>4C 2A59 MB>9 AB@0B5388 5@;0-$59B0-C@A<5@0 09:; 8=4 (Michael Lind): 048:0;L=KE A8>=8AB>2, : :>8< ?@8=04;560B 5@; 8 $59B, =5<=>3>, => >=8 83@0NB 206=CN @>;L 2 D>@<8@>20=88 ?>;8B8:8 5A?C1;8:0=F52. -B>B D5=><5= CE>48B :>@=O<8 2 :>=5F 70-E 8 =0G0;> 80-E 3>4>2, :>340 <=>385 52@59A:85 8=B5;;5:BC0;K ?>:8=C;8 ?0@B8N 5<>:@0B>2 8 ?@8A>548=8;8AL : H8@>:>9 :>0;8F88 5930=0.  E>BO ?C1;8G=> 2A5 MB8 OAB@51K ?@87K20NB : :@5AB>2><C ?>E>4C 70 45<>:@0B8N, =0 45;5 MB8 =5>:>=A5@20B>@K 1>@NBAO 70 8=B5@5AK 7@08;O. !;54C5B ?>4G5@:=CBL, GB> >=8 70=8<0NB 206=K5 ?>ABK 2> 2;0AB8. 5@; 2>73;02;O5B ><8B5B ?> 2K@01>B:5 >1>@>==>9 ?>;8B8:8; $59B O2;O5BAO 70<<8=8AB@0 >1>@>=K; C@A<5@  A?5F80;L=K9 ?><>I=8: 70<5AB8B5;O 3>AA5:@5B0@O ?> :>=B@>;N =04 2>>@C65=8O<8 6>=0 >;B>=0, :>B>@K9 A0< ?>445@68205B 8458 5@;0-(0@>=0. >B GB> >= =5402=> 3>2>@8; =0 2AB@5G5 A 87@08;LA:8<8 ?>;8B8:0<8: & =5B A><=5=8O, GB> <5@8:0 0B0:C5B @0: 8, GB> 70B5< =0< ?@845BAO @5H0BL, GB> 45;0BL A C3@>70<8 A> AB>@>=K !8@88, @0=0 8 !525@=>9 >@58. 26 O=20@O 1998 3>40 B>340H=89 ?@57845=B ;8=B>= ?>;CG8; ?8AL<>, 2 :>B>@>< 53> C?@0H820;8 2=5AB8 2 A2>5 1@0I5=85 : =0F88 2>?@>A > A25@65=88 @568<0 !0440<0 %CA59=0 2 :0G5AB25 3;02=>9 ?>;8B8G5A:>9 F5;8 !(. @8 MB>< ?>4G5@:820;0AL 206=>ABL C?><8=0=8O 8A?>;L7>20=8O 2>5==>9 A8;K, 5A;8 48?;><0B8G5A:85 CA8;8O ?>B5@?OB D80A:>.  MB>< A;CG05 ?>4?8A02H85 MBC ?5B8F8N  -;8>B 1@0<A, 8;; 5==5B, 6>= >;B>=, >15@B >30=, 8;LO<A @8AB>;;, 8G0@4 ?5@; 8 >; C;D>28F  >15I0;8 ?@57845=BC ?>;=CN ?>445@6:C 2 MB>< B@C4=><, => =5>1E>48<>< =0G8=0=88. 0<5BLB5, GB> 70 G5BK@5 3>40 4> B@035488 11 A5=BO1@O =5>:>=A5@20B>@K C65 4C<0;8 > A<5=5 @568<0 2 @0:5.  1992 3>4C 87 >D8A0 >;0 C;D>28F0 2 5=B03>=5 ?@>87>H;0 CB5G:0 ?>@078B5;L=>3> 4>:C<5=B0. 0@B>= 5;<0= 87 Washington Post =0720; 53> A5:@5B=K< ?;0=>< ?> 2K1>@C =0?@02;5=8O @0728B8O 3>AC40@AB20 2 A;54CNI5< AB>;5B88. -B>B B0: =07K205<K9 5<>@0=4C< C;D>28F0 ?@54CA<0B@820; ?>AB>O==>5 2>5==>5 ?@8ACBAB285 !( =0 2A5E H5AB8 :>=B8=5=B0E 4;O A45@6820=8O ?>B5=F80;L=KE A>?5@=8:>2, ?@5B5=4CNI8E =0 @>;L @538>=0;L=>3> 8;8 3;>10;L=>3> ;845@0. >;8B8:0 A45@6820=8O 2@5<5= E>;>4=>9 2>9=K 70<5=O;0AL =>2>9 0<18F8>7=>9 AB@0B53859, ?@54=07=0G5==>9 CAB0=>28BL 8 70I8B8BL =>2K9 <8@>?>@O4>:. O4 <KA;59 87 MB>3> <5<>@0=4C<0 =0H5; >B@065=85 2 0F8>=0;L=>9 AB@0B5388 157>?0A=>AB8, ?>4?8A0==>9 ?@57845=B>< CH5< 21 A5=BO1@O 2002 3>40. 5?>@B5@ Washington Post "8< 59E (Tim Reich) =0720; MB>B 4>:C<5=B  2>4>@0745;>< 2> 2=5H=59 ?>;8B8:5 !(, >7=0G0NI8< ?5@5A<>B@ DC=40<5=B0;L=>3> ?@8=F8?0 ?>;8B8:8 A45@6820=8O, O2;ONI53>AO 1>;55 ?>;C25:0 @C:>2>4AB2>< : 459AB28N 4;O 2A5E 0<5@8:0=A:8E ?@57845=B>2. =0;878@CO !B@0B538N =0F8>=0;L=>9 157>?0A=>AB8, ?@>D5AA>@ >AB>=A:>3> C=825@A8B5B0 -=4@N 0A528G (Andrew Bacevich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ax Americana, ?@54;0305<K9 =5>:>=A5@20B>@0<8, A?>A>15= 225@3=CBL <5@8:C 2 B0:85 2@5<5=0, :>340, ?> A;>20< 0@@8 0@=A0 (Harry Barnes), 1C45B 84B8 ?5@<0=5=B=0O 2>9=0 70 ?5@<0=5=B=K9 <8@. 0: C65 3>2>@8;>AL, 20 A5=BO1@O 2001 3>40 ?@57845=B0 CH0 C65 ?@54C?@548;8, GB> >B:07 >B 0B0:8 =0 @0: 1C45B >7=0G0BL :0?8BC;OF8N ?5@54 <564C=0@>4=K< B5@@>@87<><. <C B0:65 ?>A>25B>20;8 =5 4028BL =0 7@08;L. G5284=>, GB> =5>:>=A5@20B>@K, CA?5H=> @07K3@02H85 0=B8A5<8BA:CN :0@BC, 3>B>2K @07K3@0BL 8 <N=E5=A:CN. 0?><=8<, GB> 3>4 =0704, :>340 ?@57845=B CH ?>B@51>20; 2K25AB8 87@08;LA:85 2>9A:0 A 0?04=>3> 15@530, B> 2 >B25B (0@>= 70O28;, GB> =8:><C =5 ?>72>;8B A45;0BL A 7@08;5< B>, GB> 2 A2>5 2@5<O A>25@H8; 528; '5<15@;5= 2 >B=>H5=88 '5E>A;>20:88. 3> BCB 65 ?>445@60; $@M=: 0D=8 (Frank Gaffney) 87 &5=B@0 ?> 2K@01>B:5 ?>;8B8:8 2 >1;0AB8 157>?0A=>AB8: 0H8=3B>= 2A5 2@5<O AG8B05B, GB> 53> 3;02=K9 A>N7=8: =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5, ?@>2>48B =5045:20B=CN ?>;8B8:C, B>G=> B0: 65 :0: 0@86 8 >=4>= 4C<0;8 > =565;0=88 '5E>A;>20:88 70:;NG8BL <8@ A 8B;5@>< 2 >1<5= =0 G0ABL A2>59 B5@@8B>@88.  :>340 1K2H89 :><0=4CNI89 0<5@8:0=A:8<8 2>9A:0<8 2 " 35=5@0; 6>@46 6C;0= (George Jouwlan) 70<5B8;, GB> !( <>3;8 1K 8 ?>4B>;:=CBL 7@08;L 8 0;5AB8=C : 70:;NG5=8N <8@0, B> 0D=8 >B25B8;: -B8 ;N48 3>B>2K ?>9B8 4065 40;LH5, G5< $@0=F8O 8 5;8:>1@8B0=8O, ?@>402H85 2 1938 3>4C A2>53> A>N7=8:0 2 N=E5=5. K 4>;6=K C?>4>18BLAO 38B;5@>2A:><C 25@<0EBC, 70E20B82H5<C !C45BA:CN >1;0ABL, B.5. 70E20B8BL 8 ?5@540BL /A8@C @0D0BC 0?04=K9 15@53, A5:B>@ 07K 8, 2>7<>6=>, G0ABL 5@CA0;8<0. >43>@5F B>65 A>3;0A8;AO A (0@>=><, ?>AG8B02 ?>;8B8G5A:8 =5@07C<=>9 0=0;>38N A N=E5=A:8< A3>2>@><. "5?5@L, 5A;8 ?@57845=B CH ?>?@>1C5B 4028BL =0 7@08;L, GB>1K @50;87>20BL !>3;0H5=8O, 4>AB83=CBK5 2 A;>, ?> D>@<C;5 <8@ 2 >1<5= =0 75<;8, B> 53> A@07C 65 >128=OB 2 0=B8A5<8B87<5 8 <N=E5=A:>< A3>2>@5, :0: 87@08;LBO=5, B0: 8 =5>:>=A5@20B>@K 2 53> A>1AB25==>< 4><5. 4=0:> 4>AB865=85 <8@0 =0 ;86=5< >AB>:5 <0;>25@>OB=> ?>:0 C 2;0AB8 2 7@08;5 =0E>48BAO (0@>=.  157 MB>3> <5@8:0 =5 <>65B GC2AB2>20BL A51O 2 157>?0A=>AB8, ?>B><C GB> 2 B0:>< A;CG05 =52>7<>6=> ?>;>68BL :>=5F B5@@>@87<C. 54L A2O7L <564C 0=B80<5@8:0=A:8<8 =0AB@>5=8O<8 2 A;0<A:>< <8@5, >B:C40 8 ?@>87@0AB05B A53>4=OH=89 B5@@>@87<, 8 1577C1K<8 ?>?KB:0<8 >A048BL (0@>=0 A 53> G@57<5@=K< ?@8<5=5=85< A8;K, >AC48BL 70E20B 0;5AB8=A:8E 75<5;L, >B:07>< 8< 2 ?@025 =0 A0<>>?@545;5=85  2?>;=5 >G5284=0. 0 0<5@8:0=F52 2>7;0305BAO <>@0;L=0O >B25BAB25==>ABL 70 459AB28O 87@08;LBO=. 0209B5 ?>4KB>68<  ?8H5B LN:5=5= - =0@>4 7@08;O O2;O5BAO 4@C3>< 0<5@8:0=F52. = 8<55B ?@02> =0 <8@ 8 157>?0A=>ABL A2>8E 3@0=8F.  <K 4>;6=K 2 MB>< ?><>GL 87@08;LBO=0<. <5@8:0 8<55B ?5@54 7@08;5< <>@0;L=K5 >1O70B5;LAB20 8 =5 A>18@05BAO 8E =0@CH0BL. > 8=B5@5AK !( 8 7@08;O =5 >48=0:>2K. 0G0ABCN >=8 4065 2ABC?0NB 2 ?@>B82>@5G85, 8 B>340 <K 4>;6=K >BAB0820BL A2>8 A>1AB25==K5 8=B5@5AK. >;55 B>3>, <K =5 AG8B05<, GB> @568< (0@>=0 O2;O5BAO ;CGH8< 4@C3>< <5@8:8. !> 2@5<5= 5= C@8>=0 ?@02OI85 :@C38 7@08;O 254CB A51O ?>4>1=> 4>:B>@C 65:8;C 8 <8AB5@C %094C.  50-E 3>40E 4;O B>3>, GB>1K @07@CH8BL E>@>H85 >B=>H5=8O <564C !( 8 38?B>< 2> 3;025 A 0A5@><, 035=BK >AA040 27>@20;8 @O4 0<5@8:0=A:8E >1J5:B>2 2 08@5, ?@54AB0282 MB> 45;>< @C: A0<8E 538?BO=. > 2@5<O H5AB84=52=>9 2>9=K ?> ?@8:07C 7@08;O 1K;> 0B0:>20=> 157>@C6=>5 0<5@8:0=A:>5 AC4=> !2>1>40 (Liberty), 2 @57C;LB0B5 G53> 34 <>@O:0 ?>381;8 8 171 ?>;CG8; @07;8G=K5 @0=5=8O. @8 MB>< ?@028B5;LAB2> !( =5 B>;L:> =8:0: =5 =0:070;> 28=>2=KE MB>9 1>9=8, => 4065 =5 ?@>25;> =8:0:8E @0AA;54>20=89 MB>3> 8=F845=B0. 064K9 3@0640=8= 7@08;O ?>;CG8; >B !( ?>@O4:0 20 BKAOG 4>;;0@>2, => AB@0=0 ?@>4>;605B AB@>8B5;LAB2> =>2KE ?>A5;5=89 =0 ?0;5AB8=A:8E 75<;OE, GB> A>1AB25==> 8 ?>@>48;> 8=B8D04C. 8:C4 A45;0;0 =0A <>@0;L=K<8 A>CG0AB=8:0<8 :@>202KE ?@5ABC?;5=89 2 0<0;;5. 7@08;L ?@>4020; 0<5@8:0=A:>5 >@C685 8 2>5==K5 B5E=>;>388, 2:;NG0O ?@>B82>@0:5B=K9 :><?;5:A MB@8>B (Patriot) 8 @0:5BK :;0AA0 2>74CE-2>74CE $5=8:A (Phoenix) 8B0N. -B> 65 >B=>A8BAO 8 : 87@08;LA:><C 8AB@518B5;N 028 (Lavi), A>740==><C =0 1075 8 ?> B5E=>;>388 0<5@8:0=A:>3> F-16.  B>;L:> ?@O<>5 2<5H0B5;LAB2> !( ?@54>B2@0B8;> ?@>406C 7@08;5< 2>74CH=>3> :><?;5:A0 ! (AWACS). 7@08;L 1;03>A;>28; 6>=0 >;;0@40 =0 :@06C =0H8E A5:@5B>2 8 4> A8E ?>@ >B:07K205BAO ?@54>AB028BL 4>:C<5=BK, ?>4B25@640NI85 8;8 >?@>25@30NI85 ?5@5?@>406C A5:@5B=>9 8=D>@<0F88 >A:25. >340 ;8=B>= ?>?KB0;AO 2KABC?8BL 2 @>;8 ?>A@54=8:0 2 ?5@53>2>@0E <564C 5B0=LOEC 8 @0D0B><, B> 818 2 >1<5= =0 A2>N ?>4?8AL ?>4 4>3>2>@>< 70E>B5; 2KB>@3>20BL >A2>1>645=85 >;;0@40. 0725 =0H8 1;8609H85 4@C7LO, 1@8B0=FK, 254CB A51O ?>4>1=K< >1@07><? %>BO <K 8 2KA>:> F5=8< <=>3>5 87 B>3>, GB> A45;0; 8 45;05B 4;O AB@0=K =K=5H=89 0<5@8:0=A:89 ?@57845=B, =>, 5A;8 >= =5 >B:065BAO >B =5>:>=A5@20B82=>9 ?>;8B8:8 15A:>=5G=KE 2>9= A A;0<A:8< <8@><, =0?@02;5==>9 =0 70I8BC 8=B5@5A>2 4@C3>3> 3>AC40@AB20, B> MB>B G5;>25: =5 <>65B 1KBL A=>20 ?5@5871@0= ?@57845=B>< !(. PAGE  PAGE 10  "@*dr|2 : < H J X $$--44 5,5.585^5l5n5v5x555555555566^67.808z88880@<@>@L@PI^I`IlIXXXYZo\o0pCJmHsH56CJmHsH CJmHsH CJmHsH CJ(mHsH5CJ(mHsH5CJ$mHsHO "$2Zb"'.-17>F,N~V[^fjjsz}$a$$a$N0pPpRplqjtlw x|4~BH<ލ|zpķƷH068Bv:DhvHVDF f(*,02>@쿼0J j0JU56>*CJ\]mHsH56>*CJmHsHCJ56CJmHsH CJmHsH56CJ\]mHsHJҌ|IJƷ8: $a$,.0HJLNPh]h&`#$$a$@DFHNP CJmHsH0J j0JU0JmHnHu$&P1F/ =!"#$n% i2@2 1KG=K9_HmH sH tHVV 03>;>2>: 1$$@&a$56>*CJ\aJmHsHuRR 03>;>2>: 2$$@&a$56>*CJ$aJ mHsHu:A@: A=>2=>9 H@8DB 0170F0B @B 86=89 :>;>=B8BC;  E$,)@, ><5@ AB@0=8FKJB@J A=>2=>9 B5:AB$a$CJaJmHsHuNP@"N A=>2=>9 B5:AB 2$a$CJaJmHsHu{ f_ 1]!%?)+W-T1o3p37<T?iDMFSFWNPPbWY]]``pchhkvnqq vx{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{0000@@0@0 0p@P~PN !!]dep }   & i n o s " , B G f p w } 18 &256: 0 #$(  $ '(1OST]`efmot5:DHZav &   F K c i j q !!!'!(!.!B!L!M!Q!!!!!!!! "e"m"o"t"u"|""""""""#####?#I###R$X$$$C%R%m'v'''((2(B(((_)e)))))n*r*s*x*n+v+++++,&,,,---.5.7.A.C.O.Y.c.n.{.......R/Y/\/f/00114282:2C222223344444444x555555556677<<<<9>B>a?i?n?x???AAAA^BeBBBBBUC[C\CdCDDDDDDDDDDDDEEEE3F8FFFKFFFFFFG4G;GGGGGGGGGHH{IIJ J!J'J(J-J.J5J7J>J?JGJhJsJuJ|JKK5L>AAnDEFFEOPOQ8 4>:C<5=BK\'LO >9=0.doc AlexanderC:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\'LO >9=0.doc AlexanderC:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\'LO >9=0.doc AlexanderC:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\'LO >9=0.doc AlexanderBC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O 'LO >9=0.asd AlexanderBC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O 'LO >9=0.asd AlexanderBC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O 'LO >9=0.asd AlexanderBC:\WINDOWS\Application Data\Microsoft\Word\2B>:>?8O 'LO >9=0.asd#####A:\'LO >9=0.doc Alexander'C:\>8 4>:C<5=BK\>8 4>:C<5=BK1\war.doc{{{{@d4!{pp$p6pFUnknownG:Times New Roman5Symbol3& :Arial"1hς{ς{se4j6!d0d}|2 'LO >9=00@C18= Alexander Oh+'0  4 @ L Xdlt|  Normal Alexander 2exMicrosoft Word 9.0@@O@څ@څe ՜.+,0 hp  home=4}2     !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry F@1Table WordDocument& SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjjObjectPool@@  F Microsoft Word MSWordDocWord.Document.89q